From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Souter v. Davenport

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jun 1, 1834
15 N.C. 600 (N.C. 1834)

Opinion

(June Term, 1834.)

A variance between the bond declared on and that produced in evidence can only be taken advantage of upon the trial; it forms no ground for arresting the judgment.

This action was originally commenced by a warrant in which the defendant was to answer the plaintiff "in a plea of debt, the sum of one hundred dollars with interest."

No counsel appeared for either party.


The plaintiff was nonsuited before the magistrate and appealed to the County Court of BUNCOMBE, where he obtained judgment for $97.84, principal and $6.03, interest. From this judgment, the defendant appealed to the Superior Court, where the case was tried at the special term held in July last by his Honor Judge Martin. The plaintiff produced a bond of the defendant's for $350, upon which several payments were endorsed, and obtained a verdict for the balance due, (601) viz: $96.48. The defendant then moved in arrest of judgment, upon the ground of a variance between the warrant and the bond, which motion being overruled and judgment rendered upon the verdict, he appealed.


The cause has been here submitted without argument, and the only error assigned by the appellant is clearly not sustainable. After verdict, it appears that defendant's counsel moved in arrest of judgment upon the ground that the warrant which was the plaintiff's declaration, and the bond offered in evidence, did not correspond; which motion was overruled by the Court. Had there been a variance, which we by no means admit, the objection should have been taken on the trial. A motion in arrest can only be found on some intrinsic cause appearing upon the face of the record.

Judgment is to be affirmed, with costs.

PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed.


Summaries of

Souter v. Davenport

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jun 1, 1834
15 N.C. 600 (N.C. 1834)
Case details for

Souter v. Davenport

Case Details

Full title:JOSEPH SOUTER v. DAVID DAVENPORT

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jun 1, 1834

Citations

15 N.C. 600 (N.C. 1834)