From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Smith v. Allstate Ins Co.

Michigan Court of Appeals
Dec 15, 1980
102 Mich. App. 473 (Mich. Ct. App. 1980)

Opinion

Docket No. 48309.

Decided December 15, 1980.

Gualtieri, Steinberg Larco, P.C., for plaintiff.

Garan, Lucow, Miller, Lehman, Seward Cooper, P.C. (by Joseph Kochis), for defendant.

Before: M.F. CAVANAGH, P.J., and D.F. WALSH and D.C. RILEY, JJ.


Plaintiff appeals from the circuit court's entry of accelerated judgment in favor of defendant.

Plaintiff and his father were sued by a third party for an alleged assault and battery that occurred on July 26, 1973. On August 28, 1978, a judgment was entered against plaintiff and his father, jointly and severally, for $25,000.

Plaintiff sought indemnification from defendant for the amount of the judgment based on the general liability coverage of a homeowner's insurance policy. Defendant notified plaintiff that an investigation would be undertaken, but no payment was ever made.

On August 1, 1979, plaintiff filed an action for a declaratory judgment with regard to defendant's obligation to provide insurance coverage for the $25,000 judgment. Defendant moved for accelerated judgment on the ground that, since the cause of action accrued on July 26, 1973, the date of the alleged assault and battery, the suit was barred by the running of the six-year statute of limitations period. The circuit court granted defendant's motion for accelerated judgment.

The sole issue on appeal is whether the limitations period on the claim presented in this lawsuit began to run on the date of the incident upon which liability is based or upon the date judgment was entered against the plaintiff.

A cause of action based on an alleged breach of contract to indemnify is subject to a six-year statute of limitations under MCL 600.5807(8); MSA 27A.5807(8). Insurance Co of North America v Southeastern Electric Co, Inc, 405 Mich. 554, 557; 275 N.W.2d 255 (1979). Parties to an insurance contract may specify the time when a cause of action accrues. Traverse City State Bank v Ranger Ins Co, 72 Mich. App. 150, 153; 243 N.W.2d 333 (1976). Plaintiff's insurance policy included the following provision:

"(a) No suit or action shall lie against Allstate unless:

"(1) as a condition precedent thereto there has been full compliance with all of the provisions and stipulations of this policy, and

"(2) the amount of the Insured's obligation to pay has been finally determined:

"a. by judgment against the Insured after actual trial; or

"b. by written agreement of the Insured, the claimant and Allstate."

This section of the insurance contract specified the event which started the running of the statutory limitation period. There was no obligation to pay the insured until a judgment was rendered. The statute of limitations, therefore, did not begin to run until August 28, 1978. The trial court erred in ruling that the statutory period commenced on the date of the incident upon which the liability was based. Since the suit was brought within the six-year statutory period, defendant's motion for accelerated judgment was improperly granted.

Reversed.


Summaries of

Smith v. Allstate Ins Co.

Michigan Court of Appeals
Dec 15, 1980
102 Mich. App. 473 (Mich. Ct. App. 1980)
Case details for

Smith v. Allstate Ins Co.

Case Details

Full title:SMITH v ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY

Court:Michigan Court of Appeals

Date published: Dec 15, 1980

Citations

102 Mich. App. 473 (Mich. Ct. App. 1980)
302 N.W.2d 208

Citing Cases

Wells Fargo Bank v. Trolley Indus., L.L.C.

Under Michigan law, the parties to a contract are free to agree to a duty to indemnify a loss which is not…