Case No. 2:15-CV-00774-RJS (D. Utah Jan. 15, 2016)

From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Scott v. Pena

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF UTAH, CENTRAL DIVISION

Jan 15, 2016

Case No. 2:15-CV-00774-RJS (D. Utah Jan. 15, 2016)

Opinion

Case No. 2:15-CV-00774-RJS

01-15-2016

JOHN ELIAS SCOTT, Plaintiff, v. ANDREA PENA, STATE OF UTAH, PROVO CITY, UTAH COUNTY, PROVO 4th DISTRICT COURT, and CLAUDIA LAYCOCK Defendant.

Magistrate Judge Evelyn J. Furse

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION TO REMAND RE: ECF NO. 7

Judge Robert J. Shelby Magistrate Judge Evelyn J. Furse

Defendants Andrea Pena, the State of Utah, Provo 4th District Court, and the Honorable Claudia Laycock (the "State Defendants") move the Court, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c), to remand this action back to the Provo 4th District Court. (Defs.' Mot. to Remand & Mem. in Supp. ("Mot."), ECF No. 7.) Having carefully considered the parties' briefing, the undersigned RECOMMENDS the Court REMAND this action and award the State Defendants reasonable attorney's fees incurred because Mr. Scott improperly removed the case from state court.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

In April 2006, Plaintiff John Elias Scott filed a petition for divorce from Andrea Pena Scott in the Provo 4th District Court thus initiating a divorce proceeding that has proven highly contentious. (Scott v. Scott, No. 064400836, Docket, at Attachment A.) Mr. Scott disapproves of the state court orders as "egregious, unsavory, unlawful, forbidden, and inappropriate" and alleges that these decisions harm his minor children. (Notice of Removal 2, ECF No. 3.)

Mr. Scott also brought multiple lawsuits in both state and federal court alleging constitutional violations and other tortious conduct arising from the state court's divorce, child custody, and parenting-time decision. (Mot. 4-5, ECF No. 7.)

On October 30, 2015, Mr. Scott filed a Notice of Removal of that case alleging violations of his civil and constitutional rights under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. (Notice of Removal 1, ECF No. 3.) The Notice of Removal contains three other case numbers. (Id.) One of them, 20150813, is the appellate case number for the divorce case. (Attachment B.) The other case number, 154401950, is a protective order case with Mr. Scott as the petitioner and its appeal, 20150812. (Attachments C & D.) Because of the nature of these cases, the Court cannot access most of the relevant filings. Mr. Scott also filed a supplemental "Notice of Pendant Federal Torts and Other Federal Questions & Challenges" in this Court naming 150 "federal questions and challenges" as well as 191 "additional defendants" who have allegedly committed tortious acts against him. (ECF No. 3-2.)

On November 12, 2015, the State Defendants filed the instant Motion to Remand, (ECF No. 7), as well as a Motion to Expedite Briefing on the Motion to Remand, (ECF No. 8), in which the State Defendants requested that the Court shorten the deadline for Mr. Scott to respond to their Motion to Remand. On November 17, 2015, the Court denied the State Defendants' request to expedite briefing, but granted the State Defendants' waiver of their right to file a Reply, and agreed to consider the Motion to Remand in an expedited manner. (ECF No. 9.) On November 30, Mr. Scott filed an Opposition to the State Defendants' Motion to Remand. (Pl.'s Mot. for Sanctions & Obj. to Def.'s Mot. to Remand ("Opp'n"), ECF No. 10.)

DISCUSSION

A. Mr. Scott, as the Petitioner in the Listed Cases, May Not Remove the Cases to Federal Court.

28 U.S.C. § 1441, which governs the removal of civil actions, states that "[e]xcept as otherwise expressly provided by Act of Congress, any civil action brought in a State court of which the district courts of the United States have original jurisdiction, may be removed by the defendant or defendants, to the district court of the United States . . . ." 28 U.S.C. § 1441(a) (emphasis added). Thus, under the plain language of 28 U.S.C. § 1441, only defendants may remove a case to federal court. 28 U.S.C. § 1441(a). The Supreme Court has confirmed that plaintiffs may not invoke the removal statute. See Shamrock Oil & Gas Corp. v. Sheets, 313 U.S. 100, 104-108 (1941) (explaining that removal statute's legislative history shows Congress intended to narrow federal jurisdiction on removal to defendants). Similarly, § 1443, which governs the removal of civil rights cases, only allows removal by defendants. 28 U.S.C. §1443.

Mr. Scott is the petitioner in both cases he seeks to remove. Mr. Scott does not dispute the long-standing principle that only defendants may remove a case from state to federal court but makes the unsupported allegation that the Provo 4th District Court's "egregious, unsavory, unlawful, forbidden, and inappropriate orders have caused that Petitioner is now a defendant in his own case." (Notice of Removal 2, ECF No. 3.) Mr. Scott offers no explanation as to how he became a "defendant in his own case" nor does the record indicate the State Defendants filed any counterclaims against him. As a result, the undersigned RECOMMENDS the Court grant the State Defendants' Motion to Remand because Mr. Scott, as petitioner, cannot remove the listed cases as a matter of law. B. Mr. Scott's Completely Improper Removal Entitles the State Defendants to Reasonable Attorney's Fees.

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c), a court "may require payment of just costs and any actual expenses, including attorney fees, incurred as a result of the removal" in its order remanding the case. 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c). The award of attorney's fees under § 1447(c) turns on the reasonableness of the removal. Martin v. Franklin Capital Corp., 546 U.S. 132, 141 (2005). "Absent unusual circumstances, courts may award attorney's fees under § 1447(c) only where the removing party lacked an objectively reasonable basis for seeking removal." Id. That a litigant proceeds pro se does not prevent courts from imposing sanctions under § 1447(c). See Topeka Hous. Auth. v. Johnson, 404 F.3d 1245, 1248 (10th Cir. 2005) (affirming district court's award of § 1447(c) attorney's fees to plaintiff due to improper removal by pro se defendant).

Mr. Scott lacked an objectively reasonable basis for seeking removal of his two cases. First, even a cursory reading of 28 U.S.C. §§ 1441(a) and 1443, the latter of which Mr. Scott cites in his Notice of Removal, reveals that only defendants can remove an action to federal court. Moreover, even if Mr. Scott truly lacked an awareness of the impropriety of his removal, the State Defendants' Motion to Remand should have put Mr. Scott on notice. See Doe ex rel. Hughes v. Martinez, 674 F. Supp. 2d 1282, 1285 (D. N.M. 2009) (granting § 1447(c) attorney's fees in part because plaintiffs' motion to remand should clearly have put defendant's lawyer on notice of the improper removal). Mr. Scott not only opposed the Motion to Remand without basis, he also filed a motion for sanctions that same day, requiring the State Defendants to respond. (ECF No. 11, 13.)

Furthermore, the timing of Mr. Scott's removal also provides evidence of bad faith. Mr. Scott filed the removal shortly before a hearing on child support. (Notice of Removal, ECF No. 3; Scott v. Scott, Docket at 24, at Attachment A.) By filing the removal, Mr. Scott delayed potential changes in his child support payments by months.

The Supreme Court explained that the appropriate test for awarding § 1447(c) attorney's fees "should recognize the desire to deter removals sought for the purpose of prolonging litigation and imposing costs on the opposing party, while not undermining Congress' basic decision to afford defendants a right to remove as a general matter, when the statutory criteria are satisfied." Martin, 546 U.S. at 140. As the State Defendants point out, the record indicates Mr. Scott previously filed numerous unmeritorious claims, for which one court found him a vexatious litigant, sanctioned him, and ordered him to retain an attorney or pay a civil fine for frivolous filings. (Ruling & Order: Sanctions 2-4, ECF No. 7-3.) Mr. Scott's actions indicate his motivation stems, at least in part, from the desire to prolong litigation and impose costs on people whom he dislikes or believes have harmed him. As such, despite Mr. Scott's pro se status, the undersigned RECOMMENDS the Court award reasonable attorney's fees under § 1447(c).

C. The Domestic Relations Exception

As a point of information, the Supreme Court has long held that federal courts lack jurisdiction over "[t]he whole subject of the domestic relations of husband and wife, parent and child." Ankerbrandt v. Richards, 504 U.S. 689, 703 (1992) (alteration in original) (quoting In re Burrus, 136 U.S. 586, 593-94 (1890)). This "domestic relations" exception to federal question and diversity jurisdiction "divests the federal courts of power to issue divorce, alimony, and child custody decrees." Id. Mr. Scott correctly asserts that the Constitution does not dictate this result (Opp'n 5-6, ECF No. 10); rather, statutory interpretation imposes the limitation. Ankerbrandt, 504 U.S. at 700. Without access to Mr. Scott's Petitions, however, the undersigned lacks the necessary information to determine conclusively whether Mr. Scott's cases fall within the domestic relations exception.

RECOMMENDATION

For the foregoing reasons, the undersigned RECOMMENDS the Court GRANT the State Defendants' Motion to Remand and award the State Defendants reasonable attorney's fees incurred as a result of Mr. Scott's removal. The Court will send copies of this Report and Recommendation to the parties, who are hereby notified of their right to object to the same. The parties are further notified that they must file any objection to this Report and Recommendation with the clerk of the district court, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636(b) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(b), within fourteen (14) days of service thereof. Failure to file objections may constitute waiver of objections upon subsequent review.

DATED this 15th day of January, 2016.

BY THE COURT:

/s/_________

EVELYN J. FURSE

United States Magistrate Judge

4TH DISTRICT COURT - PROVO

UTAH, STATE OF UTAH

SCOTT, JOHN ELIAS vs. SCOTT, ANDREA ODETTE PENA

CASE NUMBER 064400836 - Divorce/Annulment **** PRIVATE **** CURRENT ASSIGNED JUDGE: CLAUDIA LAYCOCK

Parties

Relationship	Party	Represented By
Petitioner	JOHN ELIAS SCOTT
Respondent	ANDREA ODETTE PENA SCOTT	MELISSA K MELLOR
Guardian Ad Litem	GAL
Guardian Ad Litem	JERE RENEER
Guardian Ad Litem	JERE RENEER
Guardian Ad Litem	JERE RENEER
Now Known As	ANDREA ODETTE PENA
Guardian Ad Litem	GAL
Intervenor	STATE OF UTAH ORS	MARIAN H ITO

Events

Date	Event
April 17, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Divorce Education Requirement
April 17, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Child Support Obligation Worksheet (sole custody andpaternity)
April 17, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Military Service
April 17, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Verified Petition
April 17, 2006	Petition filed
April 18, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion and Affidavit for Waiver of Court Fees (granted)
April 18, 2006	Filed: Wavier of Court Fees Granted
April 18, 2006	Filed: Order Regarding Respondent's Military Status (non active duty status)
April 19, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Divorce Educaton Certificate Of Completion - Andrea Scott
April 19, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Divorce Educaton Certificate Of Completion - John Scott
April 20, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Acceptance of Service Appearance Consent and Waiver
April 20, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Letter from John and Andrea Scott
April 20, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Divorce Education Class as to John taken on 4/19/06
April 20, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Divorce Education Class as to Andrea taken on 4/19/06
April 20, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: 2005 Joint Taxes
April 21, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Income Verification and Compliance with theUniform Child Support Guidelines
April 21, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Affidavit of Jurisdiction and Grounds forDivorce
April 21, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit for Entry of Default Decree of Divorce
April 21, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice for Entry of Default Certificate
April 24, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Default Certificate
April 25, 2006	Filed: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
April 25, 2006	Judgment Entered - Amount $0.00
April 25, 2006	Filed: Decree of Divorce and Judgment
April 25, 2006	Case Disposition is Judgment
April 27, 2006	Fee Account created
April 27, 2006	Fee Payment
May 02, 2006	Fee Account created
May 02, 2006	Fee Payment

May 03, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Appearance of Counsel for Respondent / Julie Woodyatt
May 11, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion To Stay Decree Of Divorce
May 11, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion To Set Aside Decree Of Divorce And Requst ForEx Parte Hearing And Temporary Orders
May 11, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit In Support Of Respondent's Motion To StayDecree Of Divorce And Set Aside Divorce Decree
May 11, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum Of Points And Authorities In Support OfRespondent's Motion to Stay Decree Of Divorce And Set Aside Divorce Decree
May 15, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit
May 16, 2006	Fee Account created
May 16, 2006	Fee Payment
May 22, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Exparte Restraining Order
May 22, 2006	Filed: Ex Parte Restraining Order
May 22, 2006	TEMP RESTRAIN ORDER set on 05/31/2006
May 22, 2006	TEMP RESTRAIN ORDER resched:
May 31, 2006	TRO TEMP ORDERS set on 06/15/2006
May 31, 2006	Minutes for Temp Restrain Order
June 02, 2006	Fee Account created
June 02, 2006	Fee Payment
June 05, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Service to Attorney for Petitioner
June 05, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Withdrawal of May 11, 2006 Notice to Submit
June 05, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Exparte Hearing
June 13, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support ofPetitioner's Motion to Quash Restraining Order; In Opposition to Respondent's Motionfor Order to Show Cause; In Opposition to Motion to Set Aside Divorce Decree; InOpposition to etc....
June 13, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Quash Restraining Order
June 13, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of John Elias Scott
June 13, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Daphne W.
June 13, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Curtis B.
June 15, 2006	TEMP RESTRAIN ORDER set on 06/29/2006
June 15, 2006	Minutes for TRO TEMP ORDERS
June 15, 2006	LAW AND MOTION set on 06/21/2006
June 16, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of John Elias Scott
June 19, 2006	Filed: Order 5/31/06 Hearing
June 22, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Amended Affidavit
June 22, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Support of Respondent's Memorandum inOpposition of Petitioner Motion to Quash Restraining Order; in Support of Respondent'sMotion to Stay Decree of Divorce,; In Support to Respondent's Motion to Set AsideDivorce Decree
June 23, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Memorandum in Opposition of Petitioner'sMotion to Quash Restraining Order; in Support of Respondent's Motion to Stay Decreeof Divorce; In Support of Respondent's Motion to Set Aside Divorce Decree and Motionfor Visitation
June 23, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit Of John Elias Scott
June 28, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Amended Memorandum in Opposition of Petitioner'sMotion to Quash Restraining Order; in Support of Respondent's Motion to Stay Decreeof Divorce; in Support of Respondent's Motion to Set Aside Divorce Decree and Motionfor Visitation
June 29, 2006	Minutes for Temp Restrain Order
July 12, 2006	REVIEW HEARING set on 08/17/2006
August 11, 2006	Fee Account created
August 11, 2006	Fee Account created
August 11, 2006	Fee Payment
August 17, 2006	REVIEW HEARING set on 09/06/2006

August 17, 2006	Minutes for Review Hearing
September 05, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Order To Show Cause
September 05, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit Of Andrea Scott
September 06, 2006	Minutes for Review Hearing
September 06, 2006	REVIEW HEARING set on 10/02/2006
September 06, 2006	Filed: Order on Temporary Orders (Hearing on June 29, 2006)
September 18, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Financial Declaration
September 18, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit In Support Of Respondent's Financial Declaration
September 18, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Answer
September 18, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit For Decision
September 27, 2006	TELEPHONE RULING set on 10/19/2006
September 27, 2006	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 9435941
September 27, 2006	TELEPHONE RULING Cancelled
September 27, 2006	TELEPHONE RULING set on 10/19/2006
September 29, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of John Elias Scott
September 29, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Financial Declaration
October 02, 2006	REVIEW HEARING set on 11/01/2006
October 02, 2006	TELEPHONE CONFERENCE set on 10/23/2006
October 02, 2006	Minutes for Review Hearing
October 19, 2006	EVIDENTIARY HEARING set on 11/27/2006
October 19, 2006	Minutes for TELEPHONE RULING
October 23, 2006	Minutes for TELEPHONE CONFERENCE
October 23, 2006	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Notice of Telephone Ruling
November 01, 2006	REVIEW HEARING Cancelled
November 21, 2006	EVIDENTIARY HEARING resched:
January 16, 2007	Minutes for EVIDENTIARY HEARING
January 16, 2007	Final Exhibit List
January 26, 2007	Filed: Order On Hearing (Hearing: September 9, 2006)
January 31, 2007	Fee Account created
January 31, 2007	Fee Payment
February 01, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Entry of Order (Hearing September 9, 2006)
February 01, 2007	Fee Account created
February 01, 2007	Fee Payment
February 12, 2007	Fee Account created
February 12, 2007	Fee Account created
February 12, 2007	Fee Payment
February 23, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
February 23, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of John Elias Scott
February 23, 2007	Filed: Order to Show Cause
February 26, 2007	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 03/14/2007
March 06, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Hand Delivery of Affidavitin Support ofOrder to Show Cause and Order to Show Cause
March 09, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Hand Delivery
March 09, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Response to Petitioner's Order to Show Causeand Petition to Modify
March 09, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Objection to Petitioner's Order to Show Cause
March 09, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Proposed Amended Decree of Divorce andJudgment
March 09, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petition to Modify
March 09, 2007	Fee Account created
March 09, 2007	Fee Payment

March 14, 2007	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
March 20, 2007	Filed: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
March 20, 2007	Filed: Amended Decree of Divorce and Judgment
March 20, 2007	Fee Account created
March 20, 2007	Fee Payment
March 21, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Michael K. Black
March 21, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Opposition to the Respondent's Motion for ExParte Restraining Order
March 21, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Opposition to Respondent's Motion for ExParte Restraining Order
March 21, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Michael K. Black
March 22, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Commissioner's Recommendation and Requestfor Hearing
March 22, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Ex Parte Hearing
March 28, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Response to Petitioner's Order to Show Caueand Petition to Modigy and Temporary Restraining Order
March 28, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Support of Temporary Restraining OrderRe: Temporary Orders
March 28, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Julie Woodyatt
March 29, 2007	Minutes for Temp Restrain Order
March 29, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion in Support of Temporary Restraining Oder Re:Temporary Order
March 29, 2007	Filed: Signed Minutes TRO
May 15, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Proposed Order Denying TemporaryRestraining order (Hearing Dated 3/29/07)
May 17, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice Of Intent To Default
May 25, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Notice of Intent to Default
May 31, 2007	Filed: Ruling Denied
June 04, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice Of Service (Deliverd To M Black)
June 04, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
June 04, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Support of Order to Show Cause
June 04, 2007	Filed: Order to Show Cause
June 08, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing
June 15, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Opposition to Respondent's Order to ShowCause
June 18, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Objection to Petitioner's Order to Show Cause
June 18, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Objection to Petitioner's Order to Show Cause
June 18, 2007	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 06/20/2007
June 20, 2007	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
June 25, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Answer to Petition to Modify
July 16, 2007	Filed: Order on Order to Show Cause (Hearing of June 20, 2007)
August 07, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel for the Petitioner /Michael Black
August 08, 2007	Fee Account created
August 08, 2007	Fee Payment
August 15, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Appear or Appoint Counsel
October 02, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Order To Show Cause
October 02, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit In Support Of Order To Show Cause
October 02, 2007	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 02, 2007	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 10/31/2007
October 02, 2007	OSC/PRETRIAL set on 10/31/2007
October 09, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Pretrial Hearing 10/31/07
October 25, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice Of Service

October 25, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Subpoena Duces Tecum (Personal Appearance Required)To Colleen Harper
October 25, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affiavit Of Andrea Scott In Support Of Temporary ChangeOf Custody Due To Immediate Danger and Irreparable Harm
October 26, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Response to Respondent's Order to Show Cause
October 29, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Continuance Of Respondent's Order To ShowCause/ Request For Expedited Decision
October 30, 2007	Minutes for ORDER APPOINTING GAL
October 30, 2007	GAL REPORT/ OSC/ PRETRIAL on 12/03/2007
October 30, 2007	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 9732108
October 30, 2007	Filed: Signed Minutes Order Appointing GAL Notice
November 02, 2007	Fee Account created
November 02, 2007	Fee Payment
November 13, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appearance of Counsel for the Minor children /kelly peterson
November 30, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Strike Petitioner's Response Pleadings
November 30, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Proposed Parenting Plan
December 03, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Stipulation - Exhibit 1
December 03, 2007	Minutes for GAL REPORT/ OSC/PRETRIAL
December 03, 2007	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE set on 01/10/2008
December 11, 2007	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Process Service Invoice
January 07, 2008	Filed: Order on Order to Show Cause (Hearing of December 3, 2007)
January 07, 2008	Filed: Order on Guardian ad Litem Repory (Hearing Date of December 3, 2007)
January 07, 2008	Filed: Order on Petitioner's Motion for Continuance (granted to 12/3/07)
January 08, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE resched:
January 10, 2008	Filed: Order Re: GAL Office Item (granted)
January 10, 2008	Minutes for Pretrial Conference
February 06, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion To Continue Pretrial
February 06, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit For Motion To Continue
February 06, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Expedited Decision On Pretrial
February 07, 2008	CONT PRETRIAL CONF set on 03/06/2008
February 07, 2008	Minutes for Pretrial Conference
February 07, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Proposed Parenting Plan
February 21, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit for Decision
March 06, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Stipulation
March 06, 2008	Minutes for CONT PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
March 06, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Stipulation
March 14, 2008	Filed: Pretrial Order
March 17, 2008	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 9829885
March 17, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE set on 04/25/2008
March 17, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE set on 04/25/2008
March 17, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE Cancelled
March 17, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Notice of Pretrial Conference
March 21, 2008	Filed: Order (Hearing February 7, 2008)
March 26, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Continue Pretrial Conference
April 09, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE resched:
April 16, 2008	Filed: Order Continuing Pretrial Conference (from April 25 to May 12, 2008)
April 22, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE set on 05/12/2008
April 25, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appearance of Counsel for the Petitioner / GaryWeight
May 12, 2008	Minutes for Pretrial Conference
May 12, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE set on 08/01/2008

May 12, 2008	BENCH TRIAL set on 09/08/2008
May 12, 2008	BENCH TRIAL set on 09/09/2008
June 26, 2008	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 08/07/2008
June 26, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order to Show Cause
June 27, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Guardian ad Litem's Verified Motion for and Memorandumin Support of Order to Show Cause
June 27, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order To Show Cause
July 11, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice Of Lodgment
July 14, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate Of Service
July 14, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Subpoena Duces Tecum for John Elias Scott
July 16, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Response To Order To Show Cause and Request to AppearFor Hearing By Telephone
July 16, 2008	Filed: Order Appointing Custody Evaluator
July 17, 2008	BENCH TRIAL Cancelled
July 17, 2008	BENCH TRIAL set on 11/20/2008
July 17, 2008	BENCH TRIAL set on 11/21/2008
July 17, 2008	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 9919378
July 17, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Notice of Bench Trial
July 29, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Stipulated Motion for Temporary Order Hearing to beConsolidated with Order to Show Cause Hearing (Hearing Date: August 7, 2008)
July 30, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE resched:
July 30, 2008	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 9926765
July 30, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE Modified
July 30, 2008	PRETRIAL CONFERENCE set on 11/07/2008
July 30, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Notice of Pretrial Conference
July 31, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Notice of Bench Trial
August 01, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Response to Order to Show Cause and inSupport of Temporary Relief
August 04, 2008	** SEALED ** Filed: Supplemental Affidavit in Response To Order To ShowCause And In Support Of Temporary Relief
August 07, 2008	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
August 07, 2008	CONT ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE on 08/20/2008
August 20, 2008	CONT ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE on 09/03/2008
August 20, 2008	Minutes for Order of Settlement
September 03, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Subpoena to Testify at Hearing
September 03, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Subpoena Duces Tecum as to Colleen Harper
September 03, 2008	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
September 16, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Preferred Family Clinic Report
October 20, 2008	Fee Account created
October 20, 2008	Fee Account created
October 20, 2008	Fee Payment
October 22, 2008	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 11/13/2008
October 22, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Order To Show Cause
October 22, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit In Support Of Order To Show Cause
October 22, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 27, 2008	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 29, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Service by Mail and By Facsmile
October 29, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing for Temporary Orders
October 29, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Temporary Orders
October 29, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Support of Motion for Temporary Orders
November 06, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate Of Service By Mail And By Facsimile To J.Woodyatt and K. Peterson

November 07, 2008	Minutes for Pretrial Conference
November 10, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Response to the Petitioner's Motion for Temporary Ordersand Petitioner's Order to Show Cause
November 13, 2008	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
November 13, 2008	BENCH TRIAL Cancelled
November 18, 2008	STIPULATION AGREEMENT on 11/20/2008
November 20, 2008	Minutes for STIPULATION AGREEMENT
November 20, 2008	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Stipulation and Settlement Agreement
January 14, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Appoint Counsel or Appear Pro Se
January 14, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Appoint Counsel or Appear Pro Se
March 03, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request For Telephone Conference; Or In The Alternative,For Status Conference
March 03, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Amended Notice To Appoint Counsel Or Appear Pro Se
March 23, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Guardian Ad Litem's Motion and Memorandum in Supportof Motion for Judgment for Attorney's Fees and Costs
March 31, 2009	SCHEDULING CONFERENCE on 05/07/2009
March 31, 2009	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 12026894
March 31, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Notice of Scheduling Conference
April 06, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit For Decision
April 13, 2009	Filed: Judgment and Order Awarding Guardian Ad Litem Attorney's Fees
April 13, 2009	Judgment Entered - Amount $4837.50
April 16, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Response to Kelly Peterson Ad Litem
April 17, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Entry of Judgment
April 23, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Copy of Audio Record/Completed (Picked upby John Soctt 5/01/09
April 23, 2009	Fee Account created
April 23, 2009	Fee Payment
April 23, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Transcript Rquest Form for hearing 1/16/07; requested byJohn Scott.
May 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Temporary Orders
May 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit In Support Of Temporary Orders
May 07, 2009	Minutes for SCHEDULING CONFERENCE
May 07, 2009	CONTINUED SCHED CONFERENCE on 05/27/2009
May 11, 2009	CONTINUED SCHED CONFERENCE Modified
May 11, 2009	CONT SCHED CONF / MTO on 05/27/2009
May 12, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing
May 27, 2009	Minutes for MOTION FOR TEMP ORDERS
June 12, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request For Telephone Conference; Or In The Alternative,For Status Conference
June 19, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Proposed Amended Decree Of Divorce (Apporved ByGAL)
June 19, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Proposed Amended Findings Of Fact and Conclusions OfLaw (Approved By GAL)
June 29, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Chid Support Obligation Worksheet
June 29, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement of Compliance
June 29, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Tax Returns for 2008 (Andrea O. Pena)
June 29, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Tax Returns 2008 (John E. Scott)
June 29, 2009	Minutes for TELEPHONE CONFERENCE
July 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement of Compliance
July 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Child Support Obligation Worksheet (sole custody andpaternity)
July 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Paystub of Andrea
July 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: W-2 2008

July 30, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit for Entry of Amended Decree of Divorce
August 07, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel for the Respondent / JulieWoodyatt
August 19, 2009	Filed: Amended Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
August 19, 2009	Filed: Amended Decree of Divorce
September 04, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice To Appear Or Appoint Counsel
September 04, 2009	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 10/14/2009
September 04, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Withdrawal Of Counsel (K Peterson As Guardian AdLitem)
September 22, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Amended Notice to Appear or Appoint Counsel
October 09, 2009	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE Cancelled
October 09, 2009	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 11/04/2009
November 02, 2009	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE resched:
November 09, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Order To Show Cause
November 09, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Declaration Of John Elias Scott In Support Of Motion ForOrder To Show Cause
November 09, 2009	Filed: Order to Show Cause
November 16, 2009	CONTINUED OSC set on 12/09/2009
November 17, 2009	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
November 23, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Motion for Order to Show Cause, forJudgment, for Order of Contempt and for Sanctions
November 23, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Respondent in Support of Respondent's Motionfor Order to Show Cause
November 23, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Respondent in Opposition to Petitioner's Orderto Show Cause
November 24, 2009	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Jacki's tape request has been completed and picked up
November 24, 2009	Filed: Order to Show Cause
December 02, 2009	Fee Account created
December 02, 2009	Fee Payment
December 08, 2009	CONTINUED OSC resched:
December 16, 2009	Minutes for CONT ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
December 31, 2009	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 01/26/2010
January 20, 2010	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE resched:
January 26, 2010	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 03/01/2010
February 12, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
February 12, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Declaration of John Elias Scott in Support of Motion forOrder to Show Cause
February 12, 2010	Filed: Order to Show Cause (Petitioner's)
February 16, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Withdrawal of Counsel for the Petitioner / Douglas Gubler
February 17, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order To Show Cause In RE Contempt
February 22, 2010	Filed: Order On Order To Show Cause (December 16, 2009 Hearing)
February 26, 2010	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE resched:
March 02, 2010	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 03/10/2010
March 05, 2010	Fee Account created
March 05, 2010	Fee Payment
March 09, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Order to Show Cause and Counter Claim
March 09, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Respondent in Support of Objection to Order toShow Cause
March 10, 2010	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE resched:
March 19, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Supplemental Affidavit of Respondent in Support ofObjection to Order to Show Cause
March 24, 2010	Minutes for Order to Show Cause

March 24, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Rebuttal Declaration of John Elias Scott in Reponse toRespondent's Objection to Order to Show Cause Cause[sic]
April 01, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Letter to Judge Pullan from Petitioner, John Scott.
April 05, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitoiner's Objection to The Commissioner'sRecommendation
April 09, 2010	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Response to Petitioner's Objection toCommissioner's Ruling
April 23, 2010	Filed: Order On Temporary Orders Hearing (Hearing Of May 27, 2009)
May 13, 2010	RULING
May 13, 2010	** SEALED ** Filed: Letter to Petitioner from Judge Pullan. Filed Under Seal
September 29, 2010	Fee Account created
September 29, 2010	Fee Account created
September 29, 2010	Fee Payment
February 15, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Verified Petition to Modify Decree of Divorce
February 15, 2011	Fee Account created
February 15, 2011	Fee Payment
March 16, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Request for Hearing on Objection toCommissioner Recommendation
April 01, 2011	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 13688277
April 01, 2011	ORAL ARGUMENT set on 06/13/2011
June 10, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Acceptance of Service
June 10, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Entry of Default Certificate
June 10, 2011	ORAL ARGUMENT continued to 09/06/2011
June 15, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Answer to Respondent's Verified Petition ToModify Decree of Divorce
June 17, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Default Certificate
August 03, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
August 03, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Affidavit in Support of Motion for Order toShow Cause
September 06, 2011	Minutes for ORAL ARGUMENT
September 06, 2011	OA/OBJ. TO COMM. REC. on 09/22/2011
September 20, 2011	OA/OBJ. TO COMM. REC. on 12/02/2011
October 17, 2011	Fee Account created
October 17, 2011	Fee Payment
October 19, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Copy of Video/Audio Record Completed
November 29, 2011	OA/OBJ. TO COMM. REC. Cancelled
November 29, 2011	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 14177608
November 29, 2011	ORAL ARGUMENT set on 01/24/2012
December 02, 2011	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Mediation
December 09, 2011	Filed: Order on Order to Show Cause (March 24, 2010 Hearing)
December 23, 2011	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 01/25/2012
December 30, 2011	Fee Account created
December 30, 2011	Fee Payment
January 17, 2012	Filed: Order to Show Cause
January 17, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
January 17, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Declaration of John Elias Scott in Support of Motion forOrder to Show Cause (dated January 17, 2012)
January 17, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order to Show Cause
January 23, 2012	Filed: Signed Minute Entry
January 23, 2012	Minutes for ORDER
January 24, 2012	ORAL ARGUMENT Cancelled
January 25, 2012	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 02/07/2012

January 25, 2012	Minutes for Order to Show Cause
January 25, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Utah County Government Check Stub Information forAndrea Pena
February 02, 2012	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE continued to 02/27/2
February 08, 2012	Fee Account created
February 08, 2012	Fee Account created
February 08, 2012	Fee Payment
February 17, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Affidavit in Support of Objection to Order toShow Cause and Counter Claim
February 17, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Order to Show Cause and Counter Claim
February 23, 2012	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE continued to 03/05/2
March 02, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Rebuttal Declaration of John Elias Scott in Support ofMotion for Order to Show Cause (Dated March 1, 2012)
March 05, 2012	REVIEW HEARING set on 05/07/2012
March 05, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Minutes for Order to Show Cause
March 29, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Completed Audio Request for Bud Powell
April 02, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Full Satisfaction of Judgment (Andrea Scott Only)
April 02, 2012	Judgment # 2 Modified $ 4837.50
April 24, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Mediation
May 02, 2012	REVIEW HEARING continued to 06/11/2012
May 09, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: ADR Disposition Report
June 08, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Substitution of Counsel (Jalyn Peterson)
June 08, 2012	REVIEW HEARING continued to 07/10/2012
July 03, 2012	REVIEW HEARING continued to 10/22/2012
September 17, 2012	REVIEW HEARING continued to 10/09/2012
October 01, 2012	REVIEW HEARING continued to 10/15/2012
October 03, 2012	Fee Account created
October 03, 2012	Fee Payment
October 10, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Andrea Odette Pena for October 15, 2012Review Hearing
October 12, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Declaration of John E Scott for October 15, 2012 Order toShow Cause/ Review Hearing
October 12, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Supplemental Declaration of John E Scott for October 15,2012 Order to Show Cause/ Review Hearing
October 15, 2012	REVIEW HEARING set on 01/15/2013
October 15, 2012	REVIEW HEARING set on 04/15/2013
October 15, 2012	REVIEW HEARING set on 07/15/2013
October 15, 2012	REVIEW HEARING set on 01/13/2014
October 15, 2012	REVIEW HEARING set on 10/15/2013
October 15, 2012	Minutes for TELEPHONE CONF
October 15, 2012	Filed: Order on Order to Show Cause (March 5, 2012 Hearing)
October 15, 2012	Filed: Order on Order to Show Cause (January 25, 2012 Hearing)
October 15, 2012	Minutes for OSC/REVIEW HEARING
October 16, 2012	Fee Account created
October 16, 2012	Fee Payment
October 19, 2012	Fee Account created
October 19, 2012	Fee Payment
October 23, 2012	Fee Account created
October 23, 2012	Fee Account created
October 23, 2012	Fee Payment
October 26, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Completed Audio CD Request for hearing on 10/15/12(John Scott)

October 29, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Objection to Commissioner's Recommendation
October 30, 2012	Fee Account created
October 30, 2012	Fee Payment
October 30, 2012	Minutes for TRO
October 30, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Filing
October 30, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Ex Parte Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
October 30, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of ExParte Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
October 30, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respondent's Affidavit in Support of Ex Parte Motion forTemporary Restraining Order
October 30, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Service of Ex-Parte Motion for TemporaryRestraining Order
November 06, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Substitution of Counsel
November 07, 2012	Fee Account created
November 07, 2012	Fee Payment
November 09, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Completed Audio Request for Jalyn Peterson
November 13, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Response to Petitioner's Objection to the Commissioner'sRecommendation
November 26, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling re: petitioner's objection to commissioner'srecommendation
November 26, 2012	NOTICE TO THE PARTIES
December 04, 2012	Fee Account created
December 04, 2012	Fee Account created
December 04, 2012	Fee Payment
December 05, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Filing
December 21, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Support of Respondent's Motion for Order toShow Cause
December 21, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
December 31, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Filing
December 31, 2012	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Substitution of Counsel (DeRae Preston forRespondent)
December 31, 2012	Filed: Order to Show Cause
January 02, 2013	REVIEW HEARING Modified
January 02, 2013	OSC/REVIEW HEARING set on 01/15/2013
January 02, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Order to Show Cause (October 15,2012 Hearing) (unsigned, mailing cert unsigned)
January 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Amended Notice of Filing
January 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Response to Order to Show Cause & CounterRequest for a Finding or Certification of Respondent's Contempt
January 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Verified Petition to Modify Decree of Divorce
January 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Filing
January 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Reply to Petitioner's Response to Order to Show Cause andResponse to Petitioner's Request for a Finding or Certification of Respondent's Contempt
January 15, 2013	Minutes for OSC/REVIEW HEARING
January 15, 2013	OSC/REVIEW HEARING set on 02/25/2013
January 15, 2013	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE Modified
January 15, 2013	GAL REPORT/OSC set on 02/25/2013
January 17, 2013	Fee Account created
January 17, 2013	Fee Account created
January 17, 2013	Fee Payment
January 30, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Ruling of Commissioner on October 15, 2012Hearing
February 04, 2013	Filed: Consolidated Orders of the Court

February 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: ORDER (PROPOSED) ON RESPONDENT'S EX PARTEMOTION FOR TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER
February 11, 2013	Filed: ORDER: ON RESPONDENT'S EX PARTE MOTION FOR TEMPORARYRESTRAINING ORDER
February 11, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: RETURN OF ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION
February 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: ANSWER TO PETITIONER'S VERIFED PETITION TOMODIFY DECREE OF DIVORCE
February 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: EXHIBIT A TO NOTICE OF FILING
February 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: NOTICE OF FILING
February 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: RETURN OF ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION
February 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: REPONSE TO OBJECTION TO RULING OFCOMMISSIONER ON OCTOBER 15, 2012 HEARING
February 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: RETURN OF ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION
February 19, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit
February 20, 2013	Filed: Order on Hearing (January 15, 2013)
February 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appearance (Amber Ruder GAL)
February 23, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Entry of Temporary Restraining Order
February 25, 2013	GAL REPORT/OSC Cancelled
March 07, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: OBJECTION TO PETITIONER'S NOTICE TO SUBMIT
March 07, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: OTHER EXHIBIT A TO NOTICE OF FILING
March 07, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: OTHER NOTICE OF FILING
March 07, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: RETURN OF ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION
April 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other Exhibit A to Notice of Filing
April 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other Notice of Filing
April 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
April 15, 2013	Minutes for Review Hearing
May 02, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other Notice of Filing
May 02, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 03, 2013	REVIEW HRG/PGAL REPORT on 06/10/2013
May 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing
May 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 14, 2013	Fee Account created
May 14, 2013	Fee Payment
June 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other Notice of Filing
June 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
June 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Private Guardian ad Litem for Attorney's Fees
June 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Private Guardian ad Litem Attorney's Fees
June 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
June 10, 2013	Minutes for REVIEW/PGAL REPORT
June 10, 2013	REVIEW HEARING set on 09/03/2013
July 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Withdrawal of Counsel
July 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 11, 2013	REVIEW HEARING Cancelled
July 12, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Hearing on Motion for Attorney's Fees
July 12, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other Proposed :Garnishee Order (Proposed) Order onReview Hearing (June 10, 2013)
July 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 17, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service
July 17, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 17, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Garnishee Order Order on Review Hearing(June 10, 2013)

July 17, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 17, 2013	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 15352434
July 17, 2013	REVIEW HEARING Modified
July 17, 2013	REVIEW HEARING/ORAL ARG on 09/03/2013
July 18, 2013	Filed: Garnishee Order Order on Review Hearing (June 10, 2013)
July 18, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Withdraw
August 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 29, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Stipulation for Entry of Order
August 29, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 30, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Achievement Award - Love and Logic Parent - John Scott
September 03, 2013	Minutes for REVIEW HEARING/ORAL ARG
September 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Affidavit in Response to Petition to VacateEntered into Agreement - Exhibits Attached
September 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Vacate and Set Aside Settlement Agreement
September 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) Temporary Order Modifying Decree ofDivorce
September 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit
September 13, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: : Response to Motion to Set Aside
September 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service
September 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 20, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order Temporary Order Modifying Decreeof Divorce
September 20, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 21, 2013	Filed: Order Temporary Order Modifying Decree of Divorce
September 21, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 23, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service
September 23, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Response to Petitioner's Motion to Vacate and Set AsideSettlement Agreement
September 23, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 09, 2013	REVIEW HEARING resched to 10/24/2013
October 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Attend Hearing Telephonically
October 10, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 14, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Motion to Withdraw
October 14, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: 2nd Notice of Contempt
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: 3rd Notice of Contempt
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for assignment of Fees to GAL
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request to Remove GAL from Case
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Add Party to Case and Hold Party in Contempt
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request To Add To Review Hearing (Notice To Submit ForDecision)
October 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion For Informal Pauper Us
October 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Petitioners Motion to Add Party to Case andHold Party in Contempt
October 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Petitioners Second and Third Notice ofContempt
October 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Withdrawal of Counsel Motion to Withdraw as Counsel forRespondent
October 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 18, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Filing

October 18, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 21, 2013	RULING
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Request Enforcement of Protective Order uponParty
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Add Party to Case Known as a Joinder ofIndispensable Party
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Proper Sanctions for 3rd Notice of Contempt
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Proper Sanctions for 2nd Notice of Contempt
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: 3rd Notice of Contempt Additional Info
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Appearance of Counsel: Limited Appearance of Counsel(only for filing)
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Judgment (Proposed)
October 22, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 24, 2013	Minutes for REVIEW HEARING
October 28, 2013	Filed: Ruling
October 30, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other - Declined to Sign Judgment (Proposed)
November 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) Findings and Order Denying PetitionersMotion to Vacate and Set Aside Settlement Agreement
November 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) Order Modifying Decree of Divorce
November 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Notice to Submit for Entry ofFindings and Order
November 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Notice to Submit of Entry ofOrder Modifying Decree of Divorce
November 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Withdrawal of Counsel
November 04, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
November 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Ruling of Commissioner on October 24, 2013Hearing
November 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Verified Petition to Modify Decree of Divorce
November 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Waive Fees
November 08, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit Supporting Motion to Waive Fees
November 14, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Judgment (Proposed) for Andrea Pena
November 14, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Judgment (Proposed) for John Scott
November 14, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
November 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order Order Modifying Decree of Divorce
November 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order Findings and Order DenyingPetitioners Motion to Vacate and Set Aside Settlement Agreement
November 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
November 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
November 15, 2013	Filed: Order Findings and Order Denying Petitioners Motion to Vacate and Set AsideSettlement Agreement
November 15, 2013	Filed: Order Modifying Decree of Divorce
November 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
November 15, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
November 18, 2013	Filed: Order on Motion to Waive Fees (granted)
November 25, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Quash Judgment and Assign Fees to Respondent
December 06, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request to Enforce Order for Petitioner to Claim TaxCredits and Exemptions for Minor Children on 2013 Tax Return
December 09, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Reply: Response to Petitioners Motion to Quash Judgment
December 09, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
December 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit
December 16, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
December 19, 2013	Judgment # 1 Modified $ 3022.34
December 19, 2013	Filed: Decree of Divorce

December 19, 2013	Judgment Entered - Amount $3022.34
December 20, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Appearance of Counsel
December 20, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
December 20, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: [PROPOSED] Order on Motion to Quash and assignGuardian Ad Litem fees to Respondent
December 20, 2013	Filed: Additional Information and Affidavit for Trial on Petition to Modify Custody andfind in Contempt
December 20, 2013	Filed: Response on Response Motion to Quash Judgment
December 23, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Request to Enforce Order for Taxes onPetitioner's 2013 Tax Returns
December 23, 2013	REVIEW HEARING Modified
December 23, 2013	REVIEW HEARING/ORAL ARGUMEN 01/13/2014
December 23, 2013	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 15658594
December 23, 2013	Judgment # 3 Modified $ 3022.34
December 23, 2013	Filed: Judgment
December 23, 2013	Judgment Entered - Amount $3022.34
December 24, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Judgment (Proposed)
December 24, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Judgment (Proposed)
December 24, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
December 26, 2013	Filed: Judgment
December 30, 2013	Fee Account created
December 30, 2013	Fee Account created
December 30, 2013	Fee Payment
December 30, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion: Ex-Parte Motion for Enlargement of Time toRespond to Pending Motions and Pleadings and Stay Entry of any Pending Orders
December 30, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order on Respondents Ex-Parte Motionfor Enlargment of Time to Respond to Pending Motions and Pleadings and Stay Entry ofany Pending Orders
December 30, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
December 31, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Recuse the Hon Judge and Commissioner fromCase/Change of Venue Request
December 31, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Submit
December 31, 2013	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Hearing with Commissioner Scheduled forJanuary 13, 2014
January 06, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling of 1/6/14 re: Certifying DisqualificationIssue to Presiding Judge
January 06, 2014	CERTIFYING DISQUALIFICATION ISSUE/PRESID
January 06, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Answer to Petition to Modify Decree of Divorce
January 06, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exhibit List: Exhibit A to Respondents Opposition toPetitioners Motions
January 06, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Opposition to: Respondents Opposition to PetitionersMotions
January 06, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Opposition to: Respondents Opposition to Petitioners TaxExemptions Motion
January 06, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
January 13, 2014	Filed: Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Commissioner and Judge
January 13, 2014	Minutes for REVIEW/ORAL ARGUMENT
January 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other - Declined to Sign Order (Proposed): Order onRespondents Ex-Parte Motion for Enlargment of Time to Respond to Pending Motionsand Pleadings and Stay Entry of any Pending Orders
January 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
January 17, 2014	RULING
January 17, 2014	Filed: Ruling

January 30, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exigent Demand to Revoke Signature for MediationAgreement in the Interest of Justice and Constitutional Challenges and to Set Aside AllOrders of the Court Entered into by Fraud of Court and Abuse of Process
February 19, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Entry of Judgment (GAL fees)
February 19, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
March 03, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling of 3/3/14 re: Ruling and Order on Notice toSubmit
March 07, 2014	Filed: Motion for Informal Pauper Us
March 07, 2014	Filed: Ex Parte Exigent Pick Up Order for Rightful Parent-Time with Minor Childrenwith Mandatory Police Assistance
March 07, 2014	Filed: Order on Ex Parte Pickup Order (denied)
March 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
March 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
March 24, 2014	Filed: Order to Show Cause
March 24, 2014	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 04/21/2014
March 25, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion To Transfer
March 25, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
March 27, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service
March 27, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
March 31, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Motion to Quash and Deny Transfer of Case toJuvenile Court
April 07, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Reply Memo in Support of Motion to Consolidate andTransfer Case
April 07, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit for Decision
April 07, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
April 14, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Continue Hearing
April 14, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order on Motion to Continue Hearing
April 14, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit
April 14, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
April 16, 2014	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 15885196
April 16, 2014	TELEPHONE CONFERENCE set on 04/17/2014
April 16, 2014	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 15885196
April 17, 2014	Minutes for TELEPHONE CONFERENCE
April 18, 2014	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE Cancelled
April 23, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order on April 17 2014 TelephoneConference
April 23, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 01, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other - Declined to Sign Order (Proposed): Order onMotion to Continue Hearing
May 01, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 09, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order: Order on April 17 2014 TelephoneConference
May 09, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 09, 2014	Filed: Order: Order on April 17 2014 Telephone Conference
May 09, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
June 25, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Ex Parte Order (Proposed)
June 25, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Supplemental Hearing
June 25, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 08, 2014	MTN TO IDENTIFY JUDGMENT on 08/11/2014
July 08, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Ex Parte Order
July 08, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 14, 2014	Filed: Ex Parte Order
July 14, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification

July 15, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: TRANSCRIPT for Hearing of 01-16-2007
July 15, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Partially Set Aside or Vacate MediationAgreement and Modify Final Order of the Court
July 15, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum Support Motion to Partially Set Aside orVacate Mediation Agreement and Modify Final Order of the Court - Hearing Requested
July 15, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request to Submit for Decision - Hearing Requested
July 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Stay of Proceedings Between Petitioner andRespondent
July 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 21, 2014	RULING
July 22, 2014	Filed: Ruling
July 23, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Set Aside Default Judgment and Request forHearing
July 23, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of John Scott
July 23, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: [PROPOSED] Order
August 11, 2014	Minutes for MOTION TO IDENTIFY DEBTORS P
August 11, 2014	MTN TO IDENTIFY JUDGMENT on 09/09/2014
August 11, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Service upon JOHN SCOTT for
August 11, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 11, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit/Declaration: Affidavit of Shala Reynolds
August 11, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 11, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Application for Writ of Garnishment
August 11, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Writ of Garnishment - Non Wage (Proposed)
August 12, 2014	Filed: Writ of Garnishment - Non Wage
August 12, 2014	Fee Account created
August 12, 2014	Fee Payment
August 12, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 27, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Stay of All Proceedings
August 27, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Stay of All Proceedings
August 27, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Copy of Video/Audio Record (completed and picked up forJohn Scott)
September 08, 2014	MTN TO IDENTIFY JUDGMENT Cancelled
September 24, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection and Response to Petitioners Motion to Set asideDefault Judgment
September 24, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 10, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Withdrawal
October 10, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Satisfaction of Judgment
October 10, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 31, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Document Transferred from Juvenile Court Case#1092493/1092486 (Answer to Verified Petition to Terminate Parental Rights andCounter Petition for Change in Legal and Physical Custody)
October 31, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Document Transferred from Juvenile Court Case#1092493/1092486 (Order on October 6, 2014 Hearing)
December 16, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
December 16, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
December 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: : Notice of Change of Firm and Address
December 17, 2014	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
December 18, 2014	Filed: Order to Show Cause
December 18, 2014	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 01/26/2015
January 02, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Supplemental Statement Supporting Motion for Order toShow Cause
January 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exhibit D to Supplemental Statement Supporting Motionfor Order to Show Cause
January 16, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Continue Hearing

January 16, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
January 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) Continuing OSC Hearing
January 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit
January 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
January 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
January 26, 2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE continued to 02/12/2
January 26, 2015	Fee Account created
January 26, 2015	Fee Payment
January 26, 2015	Minutes for ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
January 30, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Other - Declined to Sign Order (Proposed) Continuing OSCHearing
January 30, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
February 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit/Declaration Curtis Scott Declaration 2015-02-03
February 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit/Declaration Daphne Scott Declaration 2015-02-03
February 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit/Declaration Respondents Declaration 2015-02-05
February 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exhibit List Respondents Exhibits in Support of Oppositionto Petitioners OSC
February 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum Respondents Memo in Opposition toPetitioners OSC
February 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
February 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Reply to Respondent's Memorandum inOpposition of Petitioner's Motion for Order to Show Cause
February 12, 2015	Minutes for ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
February 12, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) Change Minor Childrens Last Name
February 12, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) Petitioners Order to Show Cause
February 12, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
February 17, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Plaintiff's Petition and Motion to stay all Actions andProceedings on case and to remove to Federal Court upon reasonable discovery ofIrregularities therefore raising Constitutional Questions and Challenges
February 23, 2015	RULING
February 23, 2015	Filed: Ruling
February 25, 2015	Filed: Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Commissioner Patton
February 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order Petitioners Order to Show Cause
February 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order Change Minor Childrens Last Name
February 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
February 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
February 27, 2015	Filed: Order Change Minor Childrens Last Name
February 27, 2015	Filed: Order Petitioners Order to Show Cause
February 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
February 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
March 06, 2015	Fee Account created
March 06, 2015	Fee Account created
March 06, 2015	Fee Payment
March 06, 2015	Fee Account created
March 06, 2015	Fee Account created
March 06, 2015	Fee Payment
March 09, 2015	Fee Account created
March 09, 2015	Fee Payment
March 13, 2015	Fee Account created
March 13, 2015	Fee Payment
March 16, 2015	Reversal
March 16, 2015	Fee Account created

March 16, 2015	Fee Payment
April 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause and Request for Hearing
April 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
April 06, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
April 06, 2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 05/05/2015
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Income Verification and Compliance withUniform Child Support Guidelines
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Child Support Worksheet
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Support of Motion to Establish SupportOrder
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Establish Support Order
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Intervene/Join
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed) for
April 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
April 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exhibit A Pages 1-2 Exhibit B Pages 3-6
April 27, 2015	Filed: Order for
April 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
April 28, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit/Declaration: Declaration of Respondent
April 28, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to OSC
April 28, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 04, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Reply to Respondent's Answer Opposing Petitioner's Orderto Show Cause
May 05, 2015	Minutes for ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
May 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Service ROS, Andrea Scott
May 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 20, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order on OSC
May 20, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit: Notice to Submit for Decision
May 20, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Order to Show Cause held May 5,2015
May 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Set Aside Proposed Order On Order fromFebruary 12, 2015 OSC hearing and Enter Petitioner's Proposed Order on Order Insteadand To Sanction Counsel. Hearing Requested.
May 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion to Set Aside Proposed OrderOn Order from February 12, 2015 OSC hearing and Enter Petitioner's Proposed Order onOrder Instead and To Sanction Counsel. Hearing Requested.
May 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order on Motion to Set Aside Proposed Order on Orderfrom February 12, 2015 OSC hearing and Enter Petitioner's Proposed Order on OrderInstead and To Sanction Counsel
May 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: : Notice of Compliance Regarding Community Service
May 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum: Response to Petitioners Motion to Set AsideOrder
May 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: : Subpoena Duces Tecum
May 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order: Order on OSC
May 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
May 29, 2015	Filed: Order: Order on OSC
May 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Vacate and Seal Subpoena and InformationReceived from Such (hearing Requested)
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Petitioner's Motion to Vacate andSeal Subpoena and Information Received from Such
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Motion to Vacate and Seal Subpoenaand Information Received from Such

June 01, 2015	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 16708953
June 01, 2015	RULE 101 HEARING set on 07/07/2015
June 01, 2015	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 16708953
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Objection to Commissioner's Recommendation (HearingRequested)
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Petitioner's Objection toCommissioner's Recommendation
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Proposed Amendments to the Parties' Amended Decree ofDivorce November 2013
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Motion to Amend Parties' AmendedDecree of Divorce
June 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Petitioner's Objection toCommissioner's Recommendations
June 09, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request to Submit for Decision- Hearing Requested
June 09, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request to Submit fpr Decision (Order on Order to ShowCause with Requested Sanctions Against Counsel)
June 09, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Quash Subpoena
June 09, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
June 10, 2015	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 16733531
June 10, 2015	TELEPHONE RULING Modified
June 10, 2015	RULE 101/ MTN TO VACATE on 07/07/2015
June 10, 2015	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 16733531
June 12, 2015	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 16737477
June 12, 2015	TELEPHONE RULING Modified
June 12, 2015	R. 101/ MTN TO VCT/ ORDR OSC 07/07/2015
June 12, 2015	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 16737477
June 12, 2015	RULING ON OBJ. TO COMMISSIONER'S RECOMME
June 12, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling of 6/12/15 re: Objection to Commissioner'sRecommendation
July 07, 2015	Minutes for RULE 101/ MTN TO VAC/ ORDER
July 07, 2015	Fee Account created
July 07, 2015	Fee Payment
July 16, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Sanctions (Hearing Requested)
July 20, 2015	EX PARTE COMMUNICATION
July 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Minute Entry
July 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing
July 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
July 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling re: Request for Sanctions (denied)
July 27, 2015	RULING ON REQUEST FOR SANCTIONS
July 28, 2015	MOTION TO ADJUST CHILD SUPPOR 09/11/2015
July 30, 2015	Fee Account created
July 30, 2015	Fee Payment
July 31, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Ex Parte Communication
August 04, 2015	Fee Account created
August 04, 2015	Fee Payment
August 04, 2015	MOTION TO ADJUST CHILD SUPPOR 10/23/2015
August 04, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
August 04, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
August 04, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Order to Show Cause
August 05, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
August 05, 2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 09/15/2015
August 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing Notice of Continuance

August 05, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 07, 2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE continued to 09/21/2
August 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Change
August 13, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling and Order on Notice of Change of 8/13/15 --denied
August 17, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Returned Mail for John Scott (Return to Sender, Attempted,Not Known Unable to Forward)
August 17, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Returned Mail (John E Scott; RTS and unable to forward)
August 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Ex Parte Order (Proposed)
August 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion: Ex Parte Motion for Enforcement of Parent Time and for Writ of Assistance
August 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Writ of Assistance (Proposed)
August 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 21, 2015	Filed: Writ of Assistance
August 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 21, 2015	Filed: Ex Parte Order
August 21, 2015	Fee Account created
August 21, 2015	Fee Account created
August 21, 2015	Fee Account created
August 21, 2015	Fee Payment
August 21, 2015	MTN FOR ENF PARENT TIME/WRIT 08/25/2015
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petition to Modify Child Custody, Parent-time and ChildSupport
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petition to Set Aside and Vacate Order or Writ ofAssistance
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Respodent's Ex Parte Verified Motion for Enforcement ofParent-Time and Motion for Writ of Assistance
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit in Support of Ex Parte Motion for TemporaryRestraining Order
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Affidavit of Service of Ex Parte Motion for TemporaryRestraining Order
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of ExParte Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Limited Appearance (Paige Hefley for theRespondent)
August 24, 2015	Filed: Ruling and Order on Various Motions and Other Documents Filed by thePetitioner on August 24, 2015.
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Divorce Modify
August 24, 2015	Fee Account created
August 24, 2015	Fee Payment
August 25, 2015	Minutes for MTN FOR ENF PARENT TIME/WRIT
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Order on Emergency Ex Parte Motion toEnforce Commissioner's Recommendation and Order to Appoint Private Guardian asLitem
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Emergency Ex Parte Motion to Enforce Commissioner'sRecommendation and Order to Appoint Private Guardian ad Litem
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Petitioner's Motion for Emergency ExParte Motion to Enforce Commissioner's Recommendation and Order to Appoint PrivateGuardian ad Litem
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to the Court of Constitutional Violations of HisFreedom of Religion and Demand to Immediately Return his Children to Him Who arePresently Unsafe
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Withdrawal of Consent to Service by ElectronicMeans
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Objection to Commissioner's Recommendationon Respondent's Writ of Assistance (Hearing Requested)

August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Support of Petitioner's Objection toCommissioner's Recommendation on Respondent's Writ of Assistance (HearingRequested)
August 27, 2015	ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF'S EX PARTE MOTIO
August 27, 2015	Fee Account created
August 27, 2015	Fee Payment
August 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petition For Immediate Order of the Court for PhysicalEvaluations of Minor Children (NJPS dob 12/19/2003 and EOPS dob 12/4/2006) byQualified Health Professional /Doctor
August 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Order Denying Plaintiff's Ex Parte Motion
August 31, 2015	ORDER REGARDING RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE
August 31, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling of 8/31/15
August 31, 2015	NOTICE TO THE PARTIES RE: FILING OF DOCU
August 31, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Signed Ruling of 8/31/15 re: Notice ot the Parties
September 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Immediate, Ex-Parte, Emergency Petition to JudicialBranch of Government for Phone Visitations, Skype, and Visitations
September 01, 2015	Fee Account created
September 01, 2015	Fee Payment
September 04, 2015	Fee Account created
September 04, 2015	Fee Payment
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Utah Court of Appeals Correspondence
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to Petitioners Petition forPhysical Evaluations of the Minor Children
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to Petitioners Immediate ExParte, Emergency Petition for Phone Visitations, Skype, and Visitations
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum: Respondents Response to PetitionersObjection to Commissioners Recommendation
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order Appointing Private Guardian adLitem
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order on August 25, 2015 Hearing
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order: Order Appointing Private Guardianad Litem
September 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Addendum to Statement Supporting Motion for Order toShow Cause and Additional Causes of Action
September 15, 2015	Filed: Order: Order Appointing Private Guardian ad Litem
September 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Utah Court of Appeals)
September 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order COA
September 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Answer: Respondents Answer to Petition to Modify
September 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Opposition to Petitioners OSC filed on 8-3-15
September 15, 2015	Filed: NOTICE OF EVENT DUE DATES
September 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal (Order Regarding Rules of CivilProcedure)
September 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal (Protective Order Minute Entry)
September 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal (Writ of Assistance)
September 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal (Notice of Change)
September 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal (Ruling and Order on Various Motionsand Other Documents Filed by the Petitioner on 8/24/15)
September 21, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal (Notice to the Parties Regarding Filing ofDocuments)
September 21, 2015	Minutes for ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

September 21, 2015	ORDER OF RECUSAL AND REASSIGNMENT
September 22, 2015	Filed: Order of Recusal and Reassignment
September 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request/Notice to Submit: Notice to Submit for Decision
September 22, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 23, 2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE set on 10/27/2015
September 23, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause (filed 8/4/2015)
September 23, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause (filed 9/23/2015)
September 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exhibits to Motion for Order to Show Cause (filed8/4/2015)
September 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
September 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
September 23, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Exhibits to Motion for Order to Show Cause (filed9/23/2015)
September 24, 2015	MOTION TO ADJUST CHILD SUPPOR 11/12/2015
September 30, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
September 30, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order: Order on August 25, 2015 Hearing
October 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 01, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 02, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Correspondence from Utah Court of Appeals to Mr. Scott
October 02, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Correspondence from Utah Court of Appeals to John Scott
October 03, 2015	Filed: Order: Order on August 25, 2015 Hearing
October 03, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Hearing Notice of Continuance
October 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Special Pro Se Rights (ExParte)
October 08, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 08, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 08, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 08, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice to Court for Request for Hearing/Trial by Evidenceand Testimony
October 08, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petition for Extension of Time of Initial Disclosures
October 08, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Initial Disclosures Under Sealed Documents andPetition for Gag Order
October 13, 2015	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 16991967
October 13, 2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE Modified
October 13, 2015	OSC/ PET FOR EXTENSION OF TIM 10/27/2015
October 13, 2015	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 16991967
October 13, 2015	NOTICE OF EXPARTE COMMUNICATIONS
October 13, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Utah Court of Appeals Order (Petition for ExtraordinaryWrit Denied)
October 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Appeal
October 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Exparte Communications (Signed)
October 14, 2015	NOTICE for Case 064400836 ID 16994205
October 14, 2015	TEL. CONF. RE. OSC ISSUANCE 10/26/2015
October 14, 2015	Filed: Notice for Case 064400836 ID 16994205
October 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 15, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Relevant Evidence
October 19, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Audio Request
October 19, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
October 20, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Special Pro Se Rights

October 20, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Utah Court of Appeals Correspondence
October 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Completed Request for Audio CD for Jared Saldivar/ORS
October 26, 2015	OSC/ PET FOR EXTENSION OF TIM 12/11/2015
October 26, 2015	Minutes for TELEPHONE CONFERENCE
October 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law RegardingAppointment of Guardian ad Litem
October 27, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order Appointing a Private Guardian ad Litem
October 27, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 27, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 28, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Statement Supporting Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 28, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion for Order to Show Cause
October 28, 2015	Filed: Order to Show Cause
October 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Removal to Federal Court
November 12, 2015	MOTION TO ADJUST CHILD SUPPORT
November 18, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Remettitur
December 02, 2015	Filed: Notice of Vacation of Order to Show Cause and Petition for Extension of Time
December 03, 2015	OSC/ PET FOR EXTENSION OF TIME Cancelled
December 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Letter from Utah Court of Appeals
December 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Utah Court of Appeals Order of Consolidation
December 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Appearance of Counsel/Notice of Limited AppearanceCraig M. Bainum Private Guardian ad Litem
December 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification

Account Summary

Account	Details
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 3.50Amount Paid: $ 3.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 3.00Amount Paid: $ 3.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 4.25Amount Paid: $ 4.25Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 7.50Amount Paid: $ 7.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 7.00Amount Paid: $ 7.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.25Amount Paid: $ 0.25Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 1.25Amount Paid: $ 1.25Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 7.00Amount Paid: $ 7.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 8.00Amount Paid: $ 8.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCEMODIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 40.00Amount Paid: $ 40.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCE MODIFY	Amount Due: $ 40.00Amount Paid: $ 40.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCE/CUSTMODIFY	Amount Due: $ 40.00Amount Paid: $ 40.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 2.50Amount Paid: $ 2.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 5.00Amount Paid: $ 5.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 5.00Amount Paid: $ 5.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY	Amount Due: $ 10.00Amount Paid: $ 10.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.50Amount Paid: $ 0.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 2.00Amount Paid: $ 2.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 6.50Amount Paid: $ 6.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCEMODIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 100.00Amount Paid: $ 100.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCE MODIFY	Amount Due: $ 100.00Amount Paid: $ 100.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCE/CUSTMODIFY	Amount Due: $ 100.00Amount Paid: $ 100.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY	Amount Due: $ 10.00Amount Paid: $ 10.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 1.00Amount Paid: $ 1.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 8.00Amount Paid: $ 8.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.75Amount Paid: $ 0.75Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 2.00Amount Paid: $ 2.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.50Amount Paid: $ 0.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY	Amount Due: $ 10.00Amount Paid: $ 10.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 1.00Amount Paid: $ 1.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 2.00Amount Paid: $ 2.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY	Amount Due: $ 20.00Amount Paid: $ 20.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 10.00Amount Paid: $ 10.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 32.00Amount Paid: $ 32.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 1.00Amount Paid: $ 1.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 3.50Amount Paid: $ 3.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 6.00Amount Paid: $ 6.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: GARNISHMENT	Amount Due: $ 50.00Amount Paid: $ 50.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.75Amount Paid: $ 0.75Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 1.50Amount Paid: $ 1.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 1.50Amount Paid: $ 1.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 3.00Amount Paid: $ 3.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: TELEPHONECHARGES	Amount Due: $ 0.00Amount Paid: $ 0.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE:TELEPHONE/FAX/EMAIL	Amount Due: $ 0.00Amount Paid: $ 0.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: TELEPHONECHARGES	Amount Due: $ 5.00Amount Paid: $ 5.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE:TELEPHONE/FAX/EMAIL	Amount Due: $ 5.00Amount Paid: $ 5.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.75Amount Paid: $ 0.75Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.50Amount Paid: $ 0.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.50Amount Paid: $ 0.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFIED COPIES	Amount Due: $ 1.50Amount Paid: $ 1.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 1.50Amount Paid: $ 1.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: CERTIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 4.00Amount Paid: $ 4.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCEMODIFICATION	Amount Due: $ 100.00Amount Paid: $ 100.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCE MODIFY	Amount Due: $ 100.00Amount Paid: $ 100.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: DIVORCE/CUSTMODIFY	Amount Due: $ 100.00Amount Paid: $ 100.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.25Amount Paid: $ 0.25Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.75Amount Paid: $ 0.75Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

Account Adjustments
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.50Amount Paid: $ 0.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
Date	Amount	Reason
November 18, 2013	* $ 0.00	Waived
November 18, 2013	* $ 0.00	Waived
November 18, 2013	* $ 0.00	Waived
March 16, 2015	-* $ 5.00	Reversal of transaction which created the account.
March 16, 2015	-* $ 5.00	Reversal of transaction which created the account.

Appellate Docket Search

Docket Information Case - 20150813

Utah Court of Appeals Title: Scott v. Pena Docket No: 20150813 Docket Date: 10/02/2015
Agency: FOURTH DISTRICT, PROVO DEPT Case: 064400836
Status: Closed

Date	Action	Disposition Date
10/02/2015	Notice of Appeal Filed
10/02/2015	New Appeal Letter Sent
10/06/2015	Certificate of Service
10/07/2015	Miscellaneous
10/28/2015	Courtesy Copy
11/03/2015	Order of Default Dismissal
11/17/2015	Docketing Statement-FAX/Email
11/20/2015	Docketing Statement Filed
12/10/2015	Consolidate-Courts Own Motion
12/10/2015	Consolidated
12/31/3000	Case Before Court Previously

4TH DISTRICT COURT - PROVO

UTAH, STATE OF UTAH

SCOTT, JOHN E vs. PENA, ANDREA O

CASE NUMBER 154401950 - Protective Orders **** PRIVATE **** CURRENT ASSIGNED JUDGE: CLAUDIA LAYCOCK

Parties

Relationship	Party	Represented By
Petitioner	JOHN E SCOTT
Respondent	ANDREA O PENA	MELISSA K MELLOR

Events

Date	Event
August 06, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for Protective Order
August 06, 2015	Petition filed
August 07, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Service Assistance Information, (Proposed) Return of Service
August 07, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice Of Hearing
August 07, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Temporary Protective Order
August 07, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: (Proposed) Protective Order
August 07, 2015	Filed: Temporary Protective Order
August 07, 2015	Filed: Amended Temporary Protective Order
August 07, 2015	PROTECTIVE ORDER set on 08/25/2015
August 07, 2015	Filed: Amended Temporary Protective Order
August 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Service (Temp PO, Req for PO, NOH)
August 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Request for the Court's Assistance and to Hold Parties inContempt (Hearing Requested)
August 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Continue
August 11, 2015	Filed: Minute Entry
August 13, 2015	NOTICE OF EX PARTE COMMUNICATION
August 14, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Ex Parte Communication (Signed)
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Motion to Dismiss Protective Order
August 24, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
August 25, 2015	Minutes for ORDER DISMISSING PROTECTIVE
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Petitioner's Objection to Commissioner's Recommendationon Petitioner's Ex Parte Po (Hearing Requested)
August 26, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum in Support of Petitioner's Objection toCommissioner's Recommendation on Petitioner's Ex Parte Po (Hearing Requested)
September 04, 2015	Fee Account created
September 04, 2015	Fee Payment
September 04, 2015	Fee Payment
September 04, 2015	Fee Account created
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Memorandum: Response to Petitioners Objection toCommissioners Recommendation
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order (Proposed): Order Dismissing Protective Order
September 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Order Dismissing Protective Order (Signed)
September 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Commissioner Order: Order Dismissing Protective Order
September 11, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification
September 16, 2015	Case Disposition is Dismissed
September 16, 2015	Filed: Order: Order Dismissing Protective Order
September 16, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Return of Electronic Notification

October 01, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Completed Audio Request
October 28, 2015	Fee Payment
October 28, 2015	Fee Account created
October 29, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Notice of Removal to Federal Court
December 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Letter from Utah Court of Appeals
December 10, 2015	** PRIVATE ** Filed: Utah Court of Appeals Order of Consolidation

Account Summary

Account	Details
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 0.50Amount Paid: $ 0.50Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY	Amount Due: $ 10.00Amount Paid: $ 10.00Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00
REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COPY FEE	Amount Due: $ 6.75Amount Paid: $ 6.75Amount Credit: $ 0.00Balance: * $ 0.00

Appellate Docket Search

Docket Information Case - 20150812

Utah Court of Appeals Title: Scott v. Pena Docket No: 20150812 Docket Date: 10/02/2015
Agency: FOURTH DISTRICT, PROVO DEPT Case: 154401950
Status: Under Dispositive Motion

Date	Action	Disposition Date
10/02/2015	Notice of Appeal Filed
10/02/2015	Case Before Court Previously
10/02/2015	New Appeal Letter Sent
10/07/2015	Notice
10/28/2015	Courtesy Copy
10/30/2015	Order of Default Dismissal
11/17/2015	Docketing Statement-FAX/Email
11/20/2015	Docketing Statement Filed
11/20/2015	Reinstated: Order of Dismissal
12/10/2015	Sua Sponte Motion for Summary
12/30/2015	Response to Motion for Summary
01/01/3000	Transcript Request Due Due	10/15/2015
01/01/3000	Response to Mtn Sum Disp Due Due	12/30/2015

Scott v. Pena

Opinion

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION TO REMAND RE: ECF NO. 7

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

DISCUSSION

C. The Domestic Relations Exception

RECOMMENDATION

4TH DISTRICT COURT - PROVO

UTAH, STATE OF UTAH

SCOTT, JOHN ELIAS vs. SCOTT, ANDREA ODETTE PENA

Parties

Events

Account Summary

Appellate Docket Search

Docket Information Case - 20150813

4TH DISTRICT COURT - PROVO

UTAH, STATE OF UTAH

SCOTT, JOHN E vs. PENA, ANDREA O

Parties

Events

Account Summary

Appellate Docket Search

Docket Information Case - 20150812

Scott v. Pena

Scott v. Pena

Case Details

Citations

Citing Cases

Scott v. Pena

Opinion

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION TO REMAND RE: ECF NO. 7

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

DISCUSSION

C. The Domestic Relations Exception

RECOMMENDATION

4TH DISTRICT COURT - PROVO

UTAH, STATE OF UTAH

SCOTT, JOHN ELIAS vs. SCOTT, ANDREA ODETTE PENA

Parties

Events

Account Summary

Appellate Docket Search

Docket Information Case - 20150813

4TH DISTRICT COURT - PROVO

UTAH, STATE OF UTAH

SCOTT, JOHN E vs. PENA, ANDREA O

Parties

Events

Account Summary

Appellate Docket Search

Docket Information Case - 20150812

Scott v. Pena

Scott v. Pena

Case Details

CitationsCopy Citation

Citing Cases

Citations