From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Roochvarg v. Port of New York Authority

Supreme Court, Special Term, Queens County
Sep 22, 1947
190 Misc. 406 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1947)

Opinion

September 22, 1947.

Joseph M. Conroy for plaintiff.

Leander I. Shelley for defendant.


Plaintiff, who had for many years occupied certain business space at La Guardia Airport, considered himself a statutory tenant and refused to remove at the request of the defendant. Thereupon defendant, without resorting to any court or pursuing any legal remedy, physically removed plaintiff's stock and fixtures from the space one night after plaintiff had closed his shop for the day. Plaintiff has brought this action to regain his stock and fixtures and possession of the space and now seeks a temporary order restraining defendant from renting the space to anyone else pendente lite. Defendant cross moves to dismiss the complaint for lack of jurisdiction, upon the ground that it has governmental immunity from suit.

Regardless of how the court may feel about defendant's high-handed manner of dispossessing the plaintiff, the authorities sustain defendant's position that it is immune from suit ( Hergott v. Port of New York Authority, 269 A.D. 770). Accordingly, plaintiff's motion is denied and defendant's cross motion is granted.

Submit order.


Summaries of

Roochvarg v. Port of New York Authority

Supreme Court, Special Term, Queens County
Sep 22, 1947
190 Misc. 406 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1947)
Case details for

Roochvarg v. Port of New York Authority

Case Details

Full title:SOLOMON A. ROOCHVARG, Plaintiff v. PORT OF NEW YORK AUTHORITY, Defendant

Court:Supreme Court, Special Term, Queens County

Date published: Sep 22, 1947

Citations

190 Misc. 406 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1947)
74 N.Y.S.2d 479

Citing Cases

Trippe v. Port of N.Y. Auth

However, the complaint nowhere contains separate allegations against the defendant airlines for such nuisance…

Marmor v. Port of N.Y. Authority

The recently enacted law of New York (L. 1950, ch. 301) and the later enactment by the State of New Jersey of…