From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Retirement Credit Plan, Inc. v. Melnick

Court of Appeals of Georgia
Sep 16, 1976
228 S.E.2d 740 (Ga. Ct. App. 1976)

Opinion

52358.

ARGUED JULY 6, 1976.

DECIDED SEPTEMBER 16, 1976.

Action on note. Fulton Civil Court. Before Judge Moran.

Wills, Catts Ford, Warren W. Wills, Jr., for appellant.

Smith, Cohen, Ringel, Kohler Martin, Warren C. Fortson, for appellee.


This case involves a foreign judgment obtained in Wisconsin on December 1, 1967. Plaintiff seeks to enforce it in the Georgia courts in an action filed on August 22, 1974, against defendant now a Georgia resident.

On motion for summary judgment defendant seeks to pierce the pleadings by showing the foreign judgment is more than five years old, and the statute of limitation set forth in Code § 3-701 bars its enforcement in this state. Whereupon, plaintiff amended its complaint attempting to show a revival of the judgment in Wisconsin by an order granting leave to sue. It contends it then could sue on a new cause of action, the Georgia courts having authority to entertain transitory causes of action arising in another state.

The motion for summary judgment was granted in favor of the defendant, and plaintiff appeals. Held:

1. On August 22, 1974, defendant's Wisconsin judgment was more than five years old and barred by the statute of limitation contained in Code § 3-701 unless a revived judgment was obtained which is not barred by the five year statute. Watkins v. Conway, 385 U.S. 188 ( 87 SC 357, 17 L.Ed.2d 286); Fagan v. Bently, 32 Ga. 534; Baty v. Holston, 108 Ga. App. 359 ( 133 S.E.2d 107).

2. Examination of the stipulation of facts discloses a Wisconsin court order granting plaintiff leave to sue on the judgment for revival purposes, but no order of revival as that found in Fagan v. Bently, supra, and Baty v. Holston, supra. Plaintiff, by brief, refers to the fact that the order granting leave to sue was a final appealable judgment which has not been appealed. But this does not make it a "revived" judgment. Nor does it create a transitory cause of action on which the Georgia courts may grant judgment. Georgia courts may grant judgment on the foreign decree but lack authority to revive a Wisconsin judgment. Dormant judgments may be revived under Code Ch. 110-10, but this chapter of the Code, as amended, does not authorize the revival of a foreign judgment.

3. Defendant argues that the Wisconsin judgment has never been dormant under Wisconsin law, hence cannot be revived; and that this case is controlled by Frank v. Wolf, 17 Ga. App. 468 (1) ( 87 S.E. 697). But this is not established by the evidence, and since we cannot take judicial cognizance of the law of Wisconsin and that which allegedly applies had not been proven in the lower court, we cannot hold that Frank v. Wolf, supra, controls. See Independent Order of Puritans v. Cadden, 25 Ga. App. 27 ( 102 S.E. 454); Norman v. Sovereign Camp, WOW, 69 Ga. App. 437 (1) ( 25 S.E.2d 887).

4. An order to sue is not an order of revival of a judgment, whether or not the plaintiff had a right to revive. It may be a final order but it is not a final foreign money judgment which plaintiff is seeking to have made into a judgment in this state. The cases as to suits on transitory actions do not support the plaintiff here. The foreign judgment on which plaintiff seeks judgment in this state is barred; and the lower court did not err in granting summary judgment.

Judgment affirmed. Marshall and Smith, JJ., concur.


ARGUED JULY 6, 1976 — DECIDED SEPTEMBER 16, 1976.


Summaries of

Retirement Credit Plan, Inc. v. Melnick

Court of Appeals of Georgia
Sep 16, 1976
228 S.E.2d 740 (Ga. Ct. App. 1976)
Case details for

Retirement Credit Plan, Inc. v. Melnick

Case Details

Full title:RETIREMENT CREDIT PLAN, INC. v. MELNICK

Court:Court of Appeals of Georgia

Date published: Sep 16, 1976

Citations

228 S.E.2d 740 (Ga. Ct. App. 1976)
228 S.E.2d 740

Citing Cases

Smith v. State

In 13 related enumerations, Mrs. Smith contends the trial court erred in granting the State of Georgia's…