From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Raymond v. State

Supreme Court of Indiana
Apr 26, 1965
246 Ind. 422 (Ind. 1965)

Opinion

No. 30,526.

Filed April 26, 1965.

APPEAL — Death of Appellant — Moot Question. — Where appellant dies while appeal is pending the case becomes moot because in the event the judgment of the trial court is sustained it would be impossible of execution, and in event of reversal of said judgment the appellant would not be available for trial.

From the Vanderburgh Circuit Court, Ollie C. Reeves, Judge.

Appellant, Richard Homer Raymond, was convicted of the offense of entering a house to commit a felony. Pending decision on appeal the appellant died.

Appeal dismissed.

John G. Bunner, of Evansville, for appellant.

Edwin K. Steers, Attorney General, Frederick J. Graf and David S. Wedding, Deputies Attorney General, of Indianapolis.


The appellant was convicted in the Vanderburgh Circuit Court of the offense of entering a house to commit a felony. The transcript of the record and appellant's assignment of errors were filed with the clerk of this court on January 27, 1964, and said cause has been fully briefed and argued.

It now appears by a verified statement of John G. Bunner, attorney for the appellant, which statement is supported by a death certificate of the City-County Department of Health of Vanderburgh County, Indiana, that the appellant died on the 16th day of January, 1965.

As a result of the death of appellant herein this cause has become moot for the following reasons: (1) In event the judgment of the trial court were sustained the judgment would be impossible of execution, and (2) in event of reversal of said judgment the within named party would not be available for trial. Neville v. State (1962), 243 Ind. 28, 181 N.E.2d 638; Strack v. State (1930), 202 Ind. 272, 173 N.E. 323; Blackwell v. State (1916), 185 Ind. 227, 113 N.E. 723; Harris v. State (1914), 181 Ind. 503, 104 N.E. 969; Gibson v. State (1912), 178 Ind. 315, 99 N.E. 424.

Appeal dismissed.

Arterburn, C.J., Landis Myers, JJ. concur.

Jackson, J. dissents [without opinion].

NOTE. — Reported in 206 N.E.2d 139.


Summaries of

Raymond v. State

Supreme Court of Indiana
Apr 26, 1965
246 Ind. 422 (Ind. 1965)
Case details for

Raymond v. State

Case Details

Full title:RAYMOND v. STATE OF INDIANA

Court:Supreme Court of Indiana

Date published: Apr 26, 1965

Citations

246 Ind. 422 (Ind. 1965)
206 N.E.2d 139

Citing Cases

Whitehouse v. State

In the past, under like circumstances, this Court has simply dismissed the appeal, as moot. Blackwell v.…

State v. Morris

Often, the appeal results only in a new trial, for which the deceased would be unavailable. State v. Carter,…