Opinion
2:23-cv-01301-AB-KS
06-25-2024
MILTON QUINONES, an individual, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. STG LOGISTICS, INC., a California corporation; STG CARTAGE, LLC, a Delaware corporation; and DOES 1 through 100, inclusive Defendants.
[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING FINAL SETTLEMENT AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARD AND JUDGMENT
HONORABLE ANDRÉ BIROTTE JR. UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
Plaintiff Milton Quinones (“Plaintiff”), on behalf of himself and the Class, and Defendants STG Logistics, Inc. and STG Cartage, LLC f/k/a/ XPO Logistics Cartage, LLC) (“STG” or “Defendants”) (collectively, the “Parties”) entered into a Class Action Settlement Agreement (the “Settlement”) in this action.
The provisions of the Court's Order Granting Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement, Approving Form and Manner of Notice, and Setting Date for Fairness Hearing (“Preliminary Approval Order”) as to notice of the settlement were fully complied with, and notice to the Class was given in the manner required by the Court.
On May 24, 2024, Plaintiff moved for Final Approval of the Settlement, as set forth in the Preliminary Approval Order. Plaintiff's Motion for Final Approval of the Settlement includes a request for final approval of the settlement of claims under the California Labor Code Private Attorney General Act (“PAGA”), as required by California Labor Code § 2699, subdivision (1), for the civil penalties sought as part of the Settlement.
The Court held a Final Approval Hearing on June 7, 2024, at which time all interested persons were afforded the opportunity to be heard. The Court has considered the Plaintiff's Motion, all papers and evidence submitted in connection therewith, the Settlement, and all of the submissions and arguments presented at the Final Approval Hearing with respect to the proposed Settlement.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that:
1. This Final Approval Order and Judgment (“Judgment”) incorporates by reference the definitions in the Settlement, and all capitalized terms used in this Judgment that are not otherwise defined shall have the same meanings as those set forth in the Settlement.
2. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of the action, and over all Parties and all those found by the Court to be members of the class (the “Class Members”). The Court hereby GRANTS final certification of members who did not submit an Opt-Out Form to the Settlement Administrator as members of a certified class (the “Class”) for settlement purposes only. A final list of the certified Class Members is attached hereto as Exhibit A. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Court does retain jurisdiction over the opt-outs for the limited purposes of the settlement of the PAGA claims.
3. The notification provided for and given to the Class: (1) was provided and made in full compliance with the Court's Preliminary Approval Order; (2) constituted the best notice practicable under the circumstances; (3) constituted notice that was reasonably calculated to apprise the Class of the terms of the Settlement, of the proposed plan of allocation, of Class Counsel's application for an award of attorneys' fees and litigation expenses incurred in connection with this action, of Class Counsel's application for a Service Award to Plaintiff, and of the right of Class Members to appear at the Fairness Hearing; (4) constituted due, adequate, and sufficient notice to all persons entitled to receive notice of the proposed Settlement; and (5) fully satisfied the notice requirements of Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the United States Constitution (including the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution), and all other applicable law and rules.
4. No objections were submitted.
5. In light of the substantial benefits provided to the Class by the Settlement, the complexity, expense and possible duration of further litigation of the action, including any possible appeals, the risks of establishing liability and damages, and the costs of continued litigation, the Court hereby fully and finally approves the settlement as set forth in the Parties' Settlement in all respects, including, without limitation, the PAGA penalties sought therein, and finds that the Settlement is, in all respects, fair, reasonable and adequate, and in the best interests of Plaintiff, the Class, and the Class Members.
6. This Court further finds that the Settlement is the result of arms-length negotiations conducted under the supervision of a neutral mediator by highly experienced counsel representing the interests of their respective Parties.
7. Plaintiff and Defendants (collectively, the “Settling Parties”) are hereby ordered to consummate the Settlement in accordance with the terms and provisions therein.
8. The settlement of the PAGA claims released in the Settlement is approved on behalf of the “aggrieved employees,” as that term is used in California Labor Code § 2698, et seq. Settlement of the PAGA claims is binding on the Parties, aggrieved employees, and the California Labor and Workforce Development Agency (“LWDA”), including all members of the Class as well as those that opted-out.
9. The operative Second Amended Complaint in this action, filed on November 27, 2023, is hereby dismissed in its entirety, with prejudice, and without costs to any party, except as otherwise provided in the Settlement.
10. The Court further finds that during the course of the action, the Settling Parties and their respective counsel at all times complied with the requirements of Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
11. Upon the Effective Date of the Settlement, Plaintiff and all other Class Members, on behalf of themselves and each of their respective heirs, executors, trustees, administrators, predecessors, successors, and assigns, shall be deemed to have fully, finally and forever waived, released, discharged, and dismissed each and every one of the Released Claims as against each and every one of the Releasees, and shall forever be barred, enjoined and restrained from commencing, instituting, prosecuting or maintaining any and all of the Released Claims against any and all of the Releasees.
12. Each Class Member is bound by this Judgment, including, without limitation, the release of claims set forth above. Any persons or Related Entities that validly and timely request exclusion from the Class by submitting an Opt-Out Form will be excluded from the Class and are not Class Members but remain bound by the Settlement with respect to the resolution of the PAGA claims. The persons listed in Exhibit B hereto have validly and timely requested exclusion from the Class by submitting an Opt-Out Form, such that those persons are excluded from the Class and are not Class Members but remain bound by the Settlement with respect to the resolution of the PAGA claims.
13. This Judgment and the Settlement, whether or not consummated, and any discussions, negotiations, proceedings or agreements relating to the Settlement, and any matters arising in connection with settlement discussions or negotiations, proceedings, or agreements, shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of the Settling Parties, or their respective counsel, for any purpose other than in an action to enforce the terms hereof, and in particular:
a. do not constitute, and shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of Defendants as evidence of, or construed as, or deemed to be evidence of any presumption, concessions, or admissions by Defendants with respect to the truth of any allegation by Plaintiff and the Class, or the validity of any claim that has been or could have been asserted in the action or in any litigation, including, but not limited to, the Released Claims, or of any liability, damages, negligence, fault or wrongdoing of Defendants or any person whatsoever;
b. do not constitute, and shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of Defendants as evidence of a presumption, concession, or admission of any fault, misrepresentation, or omission with respect to any statement or written document approved or made by the Defendants, or against or to the prejudice of Plaintiff or any other Class Member(s) as evidence of any infirmity in the claims of Plaintiff or the other Class Members;
c. do not constitute, and shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of Defendants, Plaintiff, and any other Class Member(s), or their respective counsel, as evidence of a presumption, concession, or admission with respect to any liability, damages, negligence, fault, infirmity or wrongdoing, or in any way referred to for any other reason against or to the prejudice of any of the Defendants, Plaintiff, and Class Members, or their respective counsel, in any other civil, criminal or administrative action or proceeding, other than such proceedings as may be necessary to effectuate the provisions of the Settlement;
d. do not constitute, and shall not be construed against Defendants, Plaintiff, or any other Class Member(s), as an admission or concession that the consideration to be given hereunder represents the amount which could be
or would have been recovered after trial; and
e. do not constitute, and shall not be construed as or received in evidence as an admission, concession, or presumption against Plaintiff or any other Class Member(s) that any of their claims are without merit or that damages recoverable in the action would not have exceeded the Settlement Payment.
14. In the event that the Settlement does not become effective in accordance with the terms provided therein, then this Judgment shall be rendered null and void to the extent provided by and in accordance with the Settlement and shall be vacated; and in such event, all orders entered and releases delivered in connection herewith shall be null and void to the extent provided by and in accordance with the Settlement.
15. Without further order of the Court, the Settling Parties may agree to reasonable extensions of time to carry out any of the provisions of the Settlement.
16. The Court finds that the requested attorneys' fees, costs, and service award are fair and reasonable. Accordingly, the Court GRANTS the Plaintiff's Motion for Attorneys' Fees, Costs, and Service Award. Such order shall in no way disturb or affect this Judgment, and shall be considered separate and apart from the Settlement and this Judgment. The Court hereby approves Class Counsel's application for attorneys' fees, costs, and a Service Award, as follows:
a. The Court grants Class Counsel's request for attorneys' fees in the amount of $1,050,000 (or 25% of settlement value).
b. The Court grants Class Counsel's request for reimbursement of costs in the amount of $18,184.13.
c. The Court grants Plaintiff's request for a service award of $15,000.
17. Without affecting the finality of this Judgment in any way, this Court hereby retains continuing jurisdiction over: (1) implementation of the Settlement; (2) any award or distribution of the Class Settlement Fund; (3) disposition of the Class Settlement Fund; (4) hearing and determining applications for attorneys' fees, costs, a Service Award, and payment of expenses in the action; (5) all Settling Parties for the purpose of construing, enforcing and administering the Settlement and this Judgment; and (6) all other matters related or ancillary to the foregoing.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
EXHIBIT A
No.
Authorized Individual or Officer
1.
Abarca, Ringo
2.
Ackerman, John
3.
Acosta, Ruben
4.
Aguilar, Eddy
5.
Aguilar, Juan M Diaz
6.
Aguilar, Manuel
7.
Aguilar, Roberto
8.
Aguilera, Joel
9.
Aguirre, Jaime
10.
Ahumada, Salvador Mora
11.
Alcala, Carlos
12.
Alcala, Mauricio
13.
Alexander, Demonte Raymond
14.
Alfaro, Benjamin
15.
Aljbory, Ali
16.
Aljumaili, Ahmed Basim
17.
Alkady, Andrew Amr
18.
Alkas, Mukhlis
19.
Alsadoon, Mohammed
20.
Alsarray, Muayad Jassim
21.
Alshuailat, Ali I
22.
Alvarado, Fredy A
23.
Alvarado, Jose Antonio
24.
Alvarado, Steven Joseph
25.
Alvarenga, Jose Carlos
26.
Alvarez, Alejandro
27.
Alvarez, Angel
28.
Alvarez, Josue
29.
Arby, Tareq Jay
30.
Arce, Francisco Javier Alvarado
31.
Arceo, Vicente
32.
Arredondo, Noe Torres
33.
Arreola, Donaciano
34.
Arteaga, Raymundo Gomez
35.
Atwal, Kulwinder Singh
36.
Avalos, Adolfo Rogelio
37.
Barragan, Federico Y
38.
Barraza, Elias Armando
39.
Barreto, Liliana
40.
Behnam, Fanar
41.
Beltran, Alvaro
42.
Bernal, Adalberto
43.
Blanton, Regis Ladon
44.
Bonilla, Jose B Cruz
45.
Brown, Jason
46.
Buencamino, Emilio Espiritu
47.
Buksh, Shameer Nishan
48.
Bustamante, Pedro Trejo
49.
Caballero, Carlos
50.
Cain, Kevin
51.
Camarena, Enrique
52.
Caminos, Julio A
53.
Campos, Alfonso Limon
54.
Canty, Isaac Blake
55.
Cardenas, Luis Reyes
56.
Cardozo, Marcos Tablas
57.
Carrillo, Pedro
58.
Carvajal, Eduardo Montano
59.
Castillo, Jerry
60.
Castro, Ignacio
61.
Catarino, Juan Manuel
62.
Cazarez, Javier
63.
Ceballos, Sergio J
64.
Cevallos, David S
65.
Chamraia, Vivek
66.
Chandhok, Harsahib Singh
67.
Chavez, Anthony Guadalupe Ramon
68.
Chavez, Francisco Antonio
69.
Chavez, Jaime Villalvazo
70.
Chavez-Montano, Arturo
71.
Chibukhchyan, Armen
72.
Cleveland, Raymond S
73.
Cobian, Julio
74.
Connish, Jamal Ray
75.
Contreras, Bryan
76.
Contreras, Derek Jonathan
77.
Contreras, Miguel
78.
Cook, Bryon L
79.
Cortes, Fortino
80.
Cortes, Jesus A Perez
81.
Cotright, Steven
82.
Cruz, Arthur
83.
Cruz, Jose
84.
Cruz, Manuel
85.
Cuadros, Rosie M
86.
Cuevas, Brian Alexis
87.
Cuevas, Juventino
88.
Curiel, Carlos Arias
89.
Dacostta, William A
90.
Danial, Danial Eskander
91.
Daniel, Larry
92.
Daniels, Gerald W
93.
Dashto, Tony
94.
Davis, Frederic Michael
95.
Delgado, Jose Ricardo Soto
96.
Dennis, Brandon
97.
Deol, Kulwinder Singh
98.
Dhaliwal, Harry
99.
Dhanoa, Iqbal
100.
Dias, Manuel Velazques
101.
Diaz, Miguel Antonio
102.
Disus, Albert A
103.
Dominguez, Andrew
104.
Dominguez, Guillermo
105.
Dominguez, Manuel Antonio
106.
Dukes, Ronnie
107.
Dupper, Robert Lee
108.
Elizalde, Jose Carmen
109.
Ellerbe, Oliver Rommel
110.
Escalante, Roberto Martin
111.
Espinoza, Arnulfo Alvarado
112.
Espinoza, Jose Barajas
113.
Esquivel, Andres
114.
Estevez, Ricardo
115.
Etienne, Shawn Michael
116.
Fernandez, Carlos Guillermo
117.
Ferrer, Milton Quinones
118.
Figueroa, Franklin
119.
Figueroa, Raul Armando
120.
Fite, Regenia Anna
121.
Flores, Allen Albert
122.
Flores, Bryan Jerry
123.
Franco, Francisco
124.
Franco, Ricardo A
125.
Frye, Barry Scott
126.
Fuentes, Oscar A Lopez
127.
Gallaga, Gerardo Rocha
128.
Gallego, Alfredo Fonseca
129.
Galvan, Albert
130.
Garcia, Jose A
131.
Garcia, Juan
132.
Garcia, Manuel De Jesus Dozal
133.
Garcia, Miguel Quiroz
134.
Garcia, Oscar Eduardo
135.
Garcia, Reyes De Jesus Orozco
136.
Gill, Chainvarinder Singh
137.
Giron, Celso
138.
Gomez, Abel
139.
Gomez, Angel
140.
Gomez, Gabriel
141.
Gomez, Miguel Angel
142.
Gonzalez, Francisco
143.
Gonzalez, Gilberto Salas
144.
Gonzalez, Jair Alejandro
145.
Gonzalez, Jorge
146.
Gonzalez, Jose Raul
147.
Gonzalez, Jose Santiago
148.
Gonzalez, Mauricio
149.
Gonzalez, Raul
150.
Gonzalez, Sergio
151.
Goraj, Tomasz Pawel
152.
Gorges, Waad
153.
Gutierrez, Alejandro Olguin
154.
Gutierrez, Vicente
155.
Guzman, Janis Antonio
156.
Hamika, Tom Riyadh
157.
Hayward, Terry Lamont
158.
Hearst, Timothy
159.
Hermz, Arkan H
160.
Hermz, F adi
161.
Hernandez, Franklin S Serpas
162.
Hernandez, Ignacio
163.
Hernandez, Jose Luis
164.
Hernandez, Juan Carlos
165.
Hernandez, Luis Enrique
166.
Hernandez, Manuel Ruiz
167.
Hernandez, Rodrigo Escobedo
168.
Hibyan, Mouhamed Al
169.
Hidalgo, Marlo A Cruz
170.
Hiemer, Petr
171.
Hillman, Derek
172.
Hirmiz, Mario
173.
Howard, Kenneth Fred
174.
Ibarra, Ricardo Ramirez
175.
Ibarra, Rogelio
176.
Ibarra, Tomas
177.
Ifeacho, Kingsley Obinna
178.
Inaya, Mustafa M
179.
Iscoa, Jose Francisco
180.
Islas, Jesus Herrera
181.
Islas, Juan Manuel
182.
Jackson, Aaron
183.
Jackson, Andre Barnard
184.
Jamily, Mathew Mamoon
185.
Jaramillo, Gustavo N
186.
Jato, Donald A
187.
Jones, Kimberly
188.
Juarez, Rene Gustavo Nerio
189.
Kanozi, Rimon Khaleel
190.
Khadir, Mohamed Fethi
191.
Kisinuik, Jose Luis Castro
192.
Korkes, Lorans
193.
Korkmaz, Irfan
194.
Kramer, Alex
195.
Kumar, Ashish
196.
Kumar, Deepak Ray
197.
Lara, Jesus
198.
Larios, David
199.
Larkin, Donald
200.
Ledesma, Joseph Luis
201.
Lee, Dyntaie Eugene
202.
Lemus, Miguel
203.
Leon, Fredi Ramon Leal
204.
Lewis, Ramon Antonio
205.
Lindsey, Donald Bruce
206.
Lizarraga, Ruben
207.
Llanos, Miguel Alejandro Moreno
208.
Llanos, Ulyses Ismael Moreno
209.
Logan, Darius Demone
210.
Lomeli, Gregorio Hernandez
211.
Lomeli, Jose Angel
212.
Lopez, Antonio
213.
Lopez, Guillermo
214.
Lopez, Joel
215.
Lopez, Jose Carlos
216.
Lopez, Marco Antonio
217.
Lopez, Miguel
218.
Lopez, Raul Ortiz
219.
Lopez, Roberto
220.
Lopez, Rudy Alberto
221.
Lor, Alvin
222.
Lowe, Terrence Dwayne
223.
Luna, Said Diaz
224.
Macias, Carlos
225.
Maloney, Robert Michael
226.
Markovics, Kevin J
227.
Marquez, Florencio
228.
Marroquin, Karla S
229.
Marshall, Keith L
230.
Martinez, Armando
231.
Martinez, Jose O
232.
Martinez, Oscar Parrillas
233.
Martinez, Rafael
234.
Mccloud, Marcel Anthony
235.
Medina, Gerardo Dominguez
236.
Mejia, Atenogenes Coronel
237.
Mejia, Leonel Amilkar
238.
Mejia, Victor M
239.
Mendez, Medardo E
240.
Mesui, Niuloa Kena
241.
Miguel-Ortiz, Angel
242.
Mikha, Bassam Jibrayeil
243.
Mims, Jermaine
244.
Miranda, Mario Mata
245.
Mixon, Antony Dusche
246.
Miziolek, Tomasz
247.
Mojica, Arturo Felix
248.
Monge, Denis Xavier
249.
Montes, Marlon
250.
Montes, Oscar
251.
Montes-Guevara, Erick
252.
Montoya, Anthony
253.
Montoya, Joseph
254.
Monzonquevedo, Byron
255.
Moore, Rodney Herman
256.
Mora, Erick Jose
257.
Mora, Pedro Moreno
258.
Moran, Mario Lopez
259.
Moreno, Jesus Eduardo
260.
Moshi, Layth S
261.
Mosqueda, Sergio
262.
Munoz, Bernardino Munoz
263.
Murillo, Christopher Angel
264.
Murillo, Luis Angel Ramirez
265.
Murrieta, Carlos
266.
Naemo, Roni Amer
267.
Najjar, Olven B
268.
Neves, Canonchet
269.
Nguyen, Binh Thoi
270.
Nishikawa, Joshua George
271.
Nunes, Theodore Eugene
272.
Nuno, Eduardo Buenrostro
273.
Nuno, Leopoldo A Amador
274.
Olivas, Armando Prieto
275.
Olmassakian, Vahe
276.
Oraha, David
277.
Oraha, Wisam B
278.
Ordonez, Juan Nieves
279.
Ortega, Jose Antonio Lopez
280.
Ortiz, Javier G
281.
Osorio, Jorge
282.
Pahuamba, Javier Pablo
283.
Paez, Jose Israel Alvarado
284.
Palacios, Samuel Ramirez
285.
Parada, Edwin Oswaldo
286.
Paredes, Leodan
287.
Parra, Roberto Macias
288.
Partida, Carlos
289.
Patel, Ishwar Lal
290.
Paz, Maximino
291.
Pena, Edgar Calixto Benavides
292.
Penilla, Carlos
293.
Peraza, Jose T
294.
Perera, Anton
295.
Perez, Alfredo Patron
296.
Perez, Domingo
297.
Perez, Iran Manuel
298.
Perez, Jose Guadalupe Garduno
299.
Pimentel, Pedro
300.
Pleitez, Neftaly
301.
Poliza, Norman Najeb
302.
Polus, Wala
303.
Ponce, Jose
304.
Ponce, Rafael Franco
305.
Pooler, Kevin Timothy
306.
Prieto, Martin Soto
307.
Qaryaqos, Qays Lateef
308.
Qilo, Rami Rimon
309.
Quezada, Omar Arambula
310.
Quintanar, Gerardo
311.
Rajab, Miron
312.
Ramirez, F ernando Garcia
313.
Ramirez, Jose Angel
314.
Ramirez, Nicanor
315.
Ramirezgonzalez, Pablo
316.
Ramos, Eduardo Benito
317.
Rangel, Cesar
318.
Rauda, Jose W
319.
Regalado, Francisco
320.
Rios, Jose Alberto
321.
Rivera, Edgar
322.
Rivera, Francisco
323.
Rizo, Micker Eden Dunaway
324.
Roberts, David Wayne
325.
Robinson, Jonte Lee
326.
Rocha, Juan Eustolio
327.
Rodriguez, Jose Luis
328.
Rodriguez, Mauricio
329.
Rodriguez, Ricky
330.
Rogers, Claudine Jan
331.
Rojas, Armando Sarmiento
332.
Romo, Salvador
333.
Roots, Anthony Tyrone
334.
Rosiles, Manuel
335.
Ruiz, Marco A
336.
Ruiz, Ruben Aldrete
337.
Ruiz, Virgilio Juarez
338.
Russell, William
339.
Saenz, Carlos Alberto
340.
Sahagun, Francisco E
341.
Saka, Emad
342.
Salas, Alejandro Garcia
343.
Salazar, Robert
344.
Salgado, Felipe De Jesus
345.
Sanchez, Brian Allen
346.
Sanchez, Emer
347.
Sanchez, Fernando
348.
Sanchez, Gerardo
349.
Sanchez, Jose Solis
350.
Sanchez, Victor Enrique Enciso
351.
Sandhu, Gurdeep
352.
Sandoval, Angel
353.
Sandoval, Hugo Odilio
354.
Santamaria, Rafael Jesus
355.
Saunders, Ian Charles
356.
Sedeek, Mustafa
357.
Segura, Alejandro Guerrero
358.
Serrano, Jorge
359.
Shamasha, Rivan Kamil
360.
Shamon, Robert
361.
Shamsi, Nasruddin
362.
Shank, Christopher Thomas
363.
Shekhar, Vinod
364.
Silva, Julio Cesar Verduzco
365.
Singh, Amandeep
366.
Singh, Haramrit N
367.
Singh, Harinder
368.
Singh, Harminder
369.
Singh, Harpinder
370.
Singh, Jagat Biren
371.
Singh, Jaswinder
372.
Singh, Joga
373.
Singh, Manjinder
374.
Singh, Nihal
375.
Singh, Rajwinder
376.
Singh, Upinder
377.
Smith, Archie
378.
Smith, Martin J A Perez
379.
Smith, Sun
380.
Snell, David Michael
381.
Solomon, Rahale
382.
Soltero, Gabriel
383.
Somo, Rami Raad Toma
384.
Somo, Sleever
385.
Sosa, Rafael Antonio
386.
Soto, Juan
387.
Stevens, David
388.
Sugg, Edgar Harbert
389.
Tadeo, John A
390.
Tanks, Gwan Lavar
391.
Theweny, Sarmad
392.
Tobya, Bahaa Qaryaqos
393.
Toledo, Daniel Salvador
394.
Toledo, Elias Cabrera
395.
Tomasomo, Dani
396.
Torany, Firas Jibrael
397.
Tornel, Jose Manuel
398.
Torres, Michael Fred
399.
Torres, Tony
400.
Trujillo, Pablo Alcides
401.
Turner, Derek
402.
Ugalde, Jose Luis
403.
Valdez, Juan C
404.
Valdez, Lluvia
405.
Valdez, Luis J Martinez
406.
Valdez, Raul
407.
Valdez, Raul Antonio
408.
Valenzuela, Jose Antonio
409.
Valerio, Francisco
410.
Vann, Kevin Eugene
411.
Vaquerano, Ricardo Ernesto Rivas
412.
Vargas, Nicolas Tapia
413.
Vasquez, Gilroy
414.
Vasquez, Jonathan Michael
415.
Vasquez, Juan
416.
Ventura, Jose Antonio
417.
Villa, Carlos D
418.
Villanueva, Salvador
419.
Villasenor, Salvador Gonzalez
420.
Villavicencio, Roberto
421.
Wade, Ericson Heath
422.
Walker, Anthony Mason
423.
Walker, Dennis Scott
424.
West, Troy Allen
425.
Williams, Marcus
426.
Wood, William Chester
427.
Woodson, Nathaniel Lenny
428.
Xiong, Choua
429.
Yac, Fredy Rolando De Leon
430.
Younus, Sarmad
431.
Yousif, Bassam Hazim
432.
Yuk, Sophearoath
433.
Zamora, Christian
434.
Zang, Zhaoji
435.
Zilfa, Ryan
436.
Zilfa, Sam Sabah
437.
Zouri, Steven
438.
Zro, Rudy
EXHIBIT B
Opt-Out List
No.
Name
1.
Barbour, Adam Christopher
2.
Khalik, Mehrun A
3.
Matti, Saif
4.
Moore, Mark
5.
Oraha, Maher Potrous
6.
Slaiman, Faris
7.
Yousif, Moler Basil