From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Protest of First Nat. Bank

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
May 6, 1930
287 P. 1043 (Okla. 1930)

Opinion

No. 20162

Opinion Filed May 6, 1930.

(Syllabus.)

Taxation — Limitation on Jurisdiction of Court of Tax Review.

The Court of Tax Review has no jurisdiction to review the application of a legal rate of ad valorem tax levy to specific property, or to determine that specific property is subject thereto.

Appeal from Court of Tax Review; T.G. Chambers, Hal Johnson, and Harve L. Melton, Judges.

In the matter of the protest of the First National Bank of Enid against tax levies by the Excise Board of Garfield County. Protest dismissed, and protestant appeals. Affirmed.

McKeever, Moore Elam, for appellant.


This is an appeal from the judgment of the Court of Tax Review dismissing the protest of the First National Bank of Enid, Okla., against the application of a legal rate of ad valorem tax levy fixed by the excise board of Garfield county, Okla., to the property of the protestant. The Court of Tax Review dismissed the protest on the ground that that court was without jurisdiction to determine the issue presented.

The protestant contends that the rate of levy fixed by the excise board of Garfield county for ad valorem tax purposes could not be lawfully applied to its property because the rate so fixed was excessive and in violation of section 5219, Rev. Stat. of the United States, as amended by the Act of March 4, 1923, and section 9607, C. O. S. 1921.

The issue presented was determined by this court in Protest of First Nat. Bank of Guthrie, 136 Okla. 141, 276 P. 766, wherein this court held that the Court of Tax Review has no jurisdiction to review the application of a legal rate of ad valorem tax levy to specific property or to determine whether or not specific property is subject thereto. That decision is controlling.

The judgment of the Court of Tax Review is affirmed.

LESTER, V. C. J., and CLARK, RILEY, HEFNER, CULLISON, and SWINDALL, JJ., concur. MASON, C. J., and HUNT, J., absent.

Note. See "Taxation," 37 Cyc. p. 1087, n. 46.


Summaries of

Protest of First Nat. Bank

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
May 6, 1930
287 P. 1043 (Okla. 1930)
Case details for

Protest of First Nat. Bank

Case Details

Full title:PROTEST OF FIRST NAT. BANK OF ENID

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: May 6, 1930

Citations

287 P. 1043 (Okla. 1930)
287 P. 1043