From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Powers v. Standard Oil Co.

Supreme Court of South Dakota
Dec 29, 1934
258 N.W. 134 (S.D. 1934)

Opinion

File No. 7660.

Opinion filed December 29, 1934.

Appeal and Error.

Where party to action died subsequent to entry of judgment and before year in which appeal could be taken and no appeal was taken within a year, court had no power to appoint administrators to prosecute appeal thereafter.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Butte County.

Action by A.G. Powers and others against the Standard Oil Company, a corporation. From a judgment for defendant and an order denying motion for new trial, Hubert A. Powers and another, as administrators of the estate of A.G. Powers, who died prior to the taking of the appeal, and others, appeal.

Appeal dismissed.

Dan McCutchen, of Belle Fourche, for Appellants Hubert A. Powers and Winnifred M. Powers.

O'Keeffe Stephens, of Pierre, for Respondent.


This court dismissed an appeal as to one A.G. Powers for the reason that he had died subsequent to the entry of judgment in the case and prior to the taking of the appeal. Powers et al v. Standard Oil Co., 62 S.D. 33, 251 N.W. 187. The administrators of the estate of A.G. Powers, deceased, then applied to the circuit court of Butte county for an order substituting them as parties to the action, and the court granted the application. This is an attempted appeal by such administrators. In an original proceeding in certiorari instituted by the respondent to review the order of substitution, this court held that the circuit court was without jurisdiction to enter such order. Standard Oil Co. v. McNenny, 62 S.D. 277, 252 N.W. 841.

The purported appeal therefore, from the judgment and order denying motion for new trial is dismissed.


Summaries of

Powers v. Standard Oil Co.

Supreme Court of South Dakota
Dec 29, 1934
258 N.W. 134 (S.D. 1934)
Case details for

Powers v. Standard Oil Co.

Case Details

Full title:POWERS, et al, Appellants, v. STANDARD OIL CO., Respondent

Court:Supreme Court of South Dakota

Date published: Dec 29, 1934

Citations

258 N.W. 134 (S.D. 1934)
258 N.W. 134