Opinion
Argued May 1, 1912
Decided May 21, 1912
Thomas Carmody, Attorney-General ( J.A. Kellogg and Valentine Taylor of counsel), for state comptroller, appellant.
Albert W. Putnam and T. Almern Griffin for Harvey G. Alford, appellant.
George J. Hatt, 2d, for respondent.
Appeal dismissed, with costs, on authority of Matter of Gibson ( 195 N.Y. 466); no opinion.
Concur: CULLEN, Ch. J., GRAY, HAIGHT, VANN, WERNER, HISCOCK and COLLIN, JJ.