From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Maynard v. Holder

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1939
5 S.E.2d 535 (N.C. 1939)

Opinion

(Filed 22 November, 1939.)

1. Quieting Title § 1: Statutes § 5d —

The statute relating to actions to quiet title is a remedial statute and must be liberally construed.

2. Quieting Title § 1 —

An action to quiet title may be maintained to determine conflicting claims of title to a strip of land lying between the lands of the parties, C. S., 1743.

APPEAL by plaintiffs from Stevens, J., at May Civil Term, 1939, of WAKE. Reversed.

Stanley L. Seligson and John W. Hinsdale for plaintiffs, appellants.

Douglass Douglass and Thomas W. Ruffin for defendants, appellees.


This was an action to quiet title to certain described land. Plaintiffs alleged that the defendants wrongfully claimed title to a strip of land on the northern side of plaintiffs' land adjacent to and adjoining lands of defendants, and that the claim of defendants cast a cloud upon the title of plaintiffs. Plaintiffs also alleged title by adverse possession. Defendants denied plaintiffs' title to the land referred to and denied that defendants' claim constituted any cloud thereon. At the hearing, upon the reading of the pleadings and arguments of counsel, the court below held that the proper relief of plaintiffs was a suit in ejectment and not an action to quiet title, and thereupon dismissed the action at the cost of plaintiffs. Plaintiffs excepted and appealed.


It is prescribed by C. S., 1743: "An action may be brought by any person against another who claims an estate or interest in real property adverse to him for the purpose of determining such adverse claims."

Giving a liberal construction to this remedial statute, it is apparent that the court below was in error in dismissing this action. The pleadings were sufficient to raise an issue under which the court could proceed to determine the rights of the parties. Satterwhite v. Gallagher, 173 N.C. 525, 92 S.E. 369; Hardware Co. v. Cotton Co., 188 N.C. 442, 124 S.E. 756.

Reversed.


Summaries of

Maynard v. Holder

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1939
5 S.E.2d 535 (N.C. 1939)
Case details for

Maynard v. Holder

Case Details

Full title:HENRY MAYNARD AND WIFE, DESSIE MAYNARD, v. GENEVA MARTIN HOLDER, WIDOW…

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Nov 1, 1939

Citations

5 S.E.2d 535 (N.C. 1939)
5 S.E.2d 535

Citing Cases

Pressly v. Walker

The complaint would not be demurrable merely for the reason that the allegations might be sufficient to…