From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Malcom v. Webb

Supreme Court of Georgia
May 11, 1953
75 S.E.2d 801 (Ga. 1953)

Opinion

18172.

ARGUED APRIL 14, 1953.

DECIDED MAY 11, 1953.

Equitable petition. Before Judge Hendrix. Fulton Superior Court. January 2, 1953.

Harris Gower, for plaintiff in error.

Carl B. Copeland, Paul Webb, Jr., William Hall, Harold Sheats and Durwood T. Pye, contra.


1. A ruling on a general demurrer is reviewable at the option of the losing party by either a direct exception or by exception pendente lite. But by filing pendente lite exceptions the ruling is made a pendente lite judgment and can be reviewed only in a bill of exceptions complaining of the final judgment. Durrence v. Waters, 140 Ga. 762 (1) ( 79 S.E. 841); Gilbert v. Tippens, 183 Ga. 497 ( 188 S.E. 699); Rabhan v. Rabhan, 185 Ga. 355 ( 195 S.E. 193); Story v. City of Macon, 203 Ga. 105 (2) ( 45 S.E.2d 196).

2. Where, as here, the judgment on the general demurrer was excepted to pendente lite, the foregoing ruling requires a dismissal of the writ of error upon the ground that it is premature, since there is no exception to a final judgment terminating the case.

3. The assignments of error upon exceptions pendente lite to rulings on (a) the motion to strike the solicitor-general as a party, and (b) the plea of a former adjudication — if reviewable at all in an exception to a ruling on a demurrer, see Mechanics' Traders' Bank of Rome v. Harrison, 68 Ga. 463 — are for the foregoing reasons premature in this writ of error.

Writ of error dismissed. All the Justices concur, except Atkinson, P. J., not participating.

No. 18172. ARGUED APRIL 14, 1953 — DECIDED MAY 11, 1953.


Summaries of

Malcom v. Webb

Supreme Court of Georgia
May 11, 1953
75 S.E.2d 801 (Ga. 1953)
Case details for

Malcom v. Webb

Case Details

Full title:MALCOM v. WEBB, Solicitor-General, et al

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: May 11, 1953

Citations

75 S.E.2d 801 (Ga. 1953)
209 Ga. 735

Citing Cases

Roughton v. Thiele Kaolin Company

1. At the time the plaintiff's first application for an interlocutory injunction was denied on March 27,…

Malcom v. Webb

A verdict in favor of the County Commissioners in that action was reversed by this court in Malcom v. Fulton…