From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

LIPE v. COUNTY OF STANLY

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Dec 1, 1930
156 S.E. 243 (N.C. 1930)

Opinion

(Filed 19 December, 1930.)

Controversy without Action A b: Appeal and Error E a — Affidavit must be filed in submission of controversy: Record must contain necessary parts.

A case submitted on agreed statement of facts must be accompanied by necessary affidavit, and if an adversary proceeding the record proper must contain necessary parts, otherwise the appeal will be dismissed.

APPEAL by defendant from Johnson, Special Judge, at July Term, 1930, of STANLY.

W.L. Mann for plaintiff.

W. E. Bogle for defendant.


Proceeding to determine the liability of the defendant under C. S., 8035, "for costs and attorney's fees" where unidentified and undiscoverable lands are sold for taxes.

From a judgment for the plaintiff, rendered on an agreed statement of facts, the defendant appeals.


It is not clear from the record whether this is a controversy without action, submitted on an agreed statement of facts, or an adversary proceeding in which the facts were agreed upon. If the former, it must be dismissed for failure to accompany the agreed statement of facts with necessary affidavit. Grandy v. Gulley, 120 N.C. 176, 26 S.E. 779. If the latter, the pleadings are not before us and the appeal must be dismissed for failure to send up necessary parts of the record proper. Waters v. Waters, 199 N.C. 667; Pruitt v. Wood, 199 N.C. 788.

Dismissed.


Summaries of

LIPE v. COUNTY OF STANLY

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Dec 1, 1930
156 S.E. 243 (N.C. 1930)
Case details for

LIPE v. COUNTY OF STANLY

Case Details

Full title:I. W. LIPE v. COUNTY OF STANLY

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Dec 1, 1930

Citations

156 S.E. 243 (N.C. 1930)
200 N.C. 92

Citing Cases

Thrush v. Thrush

On review here, therefore, this Court, in the absence of the complaint, cannot have before it all the…