From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Larned v. Beal

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough
Jun 1, 1889
65 N.H. 184 (N.H. 1889)

Opinion

Decided June, 1889.

A corporation de facto is liable in an action of assumpsit for hired money, notwithstanding a failure to comply with the law in its organization, and its members are not individually liable in such an action if they acted in good faith, believing themselves to be a corporation de jure.

ASSUMPSIT, for money had and received, against "copartners doing business in the name of The Mendocino Flume and Mining Company." Facts found by a referee. The defendants are members of a company which Mann and others undertook to organize as a corporation of that name under Gen. Laws, c. 152, and which is a corporation de facto. The company hired money of the plaintiff, both parties believing the borrower to be a corporation de jury, and understanding that the money was loaned to the company in its corporate capacity.

J. W. Fellows, for the plaintiff.

B. Wadleagh, for Beal, cited Fay v. Noble, 7 Cush. 188; Trowbridge v. Scudder, 11 Cush. 83; Ward v. Brigham, 127 Mass. 24.


It is not material in this case whether the corporation de facto was a corporation de jure or not. A want of regularity in its organization would not affect the validity of its contract with the plaintiff, and would not give him, against its members, as unincorporated persons, an action on a contract which he made with them as a corporation. S. F. Bridge v. Fisk, 23 N.H. 171, 178; Ossipee Manf'g Co. v. Canney, 54 N.H. 295, 312; 313; Saunders v. Farmer, 62 N.H. 572; Jewell v. Gilbert, 64 N.H. 13, 18; Case v. Kelly, 133 U.S. 21, 28; Mor. Corp., ss. 744-755.

Judgment for the defendants.

SMITH, J., did not sit: the others concurred.


Summaries of

Larned v. Beal

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough
Jun 1, 1889
65 N.H. 184 (N.H. 1889)
Case details for

Larned v. Beal

Case Details

Full title:LARNED v. BEAL a

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough

Date published: Jun 1, 1889

Citations

65 N.H. 184 (N.H. 1889)
23 A. 149

Citing Cases

Mitchell v. Carter

"Wherever there is a valid law under which a corporation with the powers assumed might have been lawfully…

Kenneth v. Company

Nothing was done in Manchester save the holding of stockholders' meetings and the making and preservation of…