From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Knox Community School Corp. v. McCurdy

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Sep 29, 1977
174 Ind. App. 347 (Ind. Ct. App. 1977)

Opinion

No. 3-676A133.

Filed September 29, 1977.

SCHOOLS AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS — Board Reorganization. — Where the governing body refused to act upon a petition upon grounds that it did not meet all the requirements of IC 20-4-10.1-6 concerning voter-initiated proposals and a special election conducted while the appeal was pending approved the petitioned-for reorganization, the election result renders harmless any error in the showing of necessary interest for the conduct of an election and the appeal will be dismissed as moot.

Appeal from a judgment on a petition concerning an election of a school board reorganization proposal.

From the Starke Circuit Court, Marvin D. McLaughlin, Judge.

Appeal dismissed by the Third District.

Reed and Ward, of Knox, for appellants.

Charles W. Weaver, Nichols Nichols, of Knox, for appellees.


This appeal arose under the provisions of IC 1971, 20-4-10.1-1 et seq. concerning reorganization of school boards. The statute provides that such changes may be initiated either by the governing body of the school corporation or by the voters in the school corporation. IC 1971, 20-4-10.1-5. Provision is made for notice, remonstrance and alternative plans regardless of where the proposal originates. A proposal from the voters must be submitted to the governing body of the school corporation, but if the governing body does not act within thirty days it shall be deemed to have disapproved the plan. IC 1971, 20-4-10.1-7. While governing body approval of a plan may permit its implementation unless a protest is filed, governing body disapproval does no more than trigger the requirement for a special election by the voters. IC 1971, 20-4-10.1-8, 10.

Where the proposed reorganization is submitted by the voters, the statute requires that the petition be supported by twenty percent (20%) or more of the voters of the school corporation. IC 1971, 20-4-10.1-5. The purpose of this provision is to insure sufficient interest in the plan to make it worthwhile to complete the statutory proceedings while preserving the right of the people to seek change in the organization of their school corporations.

In the present case the governing body refused to act upon a petition upon grounds that it did not meet all the requirements of IC 1971, 20-4-10.1-6 concerning voter-initiated proposals. While the appeal was pending a special election was conducted pursuant to the statute on November 2, 1976. The results of that election, as certified, approve the petitioned-for reorganization by a vote of 2236 to 351. That result renders harmless any error in the showing of necessary interest for the conduct of an election.

This appeal is therefore dismissed as moot.

NOTE — Reported at 367 N.E.2d 1108.


Summaries of

Knox Community School Corp. v. McCurdy

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Sep 29, 1977
174 Ind. App. 347 (Ind. Ct. App. 1977)
Case details for

Knox Community School Corp. v. McCurdy

Case Details

Full title:KNOX COMMUNITY SCHOOL CORPORATION ET AL. v. NORMAN L. McCURDY AND PEGGY…

Court:Court of Appeals of Indiana

Date published: Sep 29, 1977

Citations

174 Ind. App. 347 (Ind. Ct. App. 1977)
367 N.E.2d 1108

Citing Cases

State ex rel. Land v. Board of Trustees of Springs Valley School Corp.

". . . to insure sufficient interest in the plan to make it worthwhile to complete the statutory proceedings…

Jones v. Womacks

re appellees rejected relator's demand that his name be placed on primary ballot, relator filed complaint for…