From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Killian v. Pennsylvania R. Co.

Appellate Court of Illinois, First District
Dec 13, 1948
336 Ill. App. 152 (Ill. App. Ct. 1948)

Summary

In Killian, the plaintiff saw the dangerous condition, instructed the Mallory Company employee to move certain barrels, and thereafter, though standing a mere ten to twelve feet away, did not look to see whether the barrels had been moved.

Summary of this case from Howes v. Baker

Opinion

Gen. No. 44,460. (Abstract of Decision.)

Opinion filed December 13, 1948 Rehearing denied December 27, 1948 Released for publication December 27, 1948

MASTER AND SERVANT, § 134damages not recoverable under Federal Employers' Liability Act for injuries to conductor. Where conductor, injured during switching operations when caught between side of loaded coal car and oil barrel located on ground near spur track situated on private property, had previously observed barrels and stood in full view of, and not more than 12 feet from them when he boarded car, and train was traveling not more than two or three miles per hour, and conductor was in complete charge of operations, and it did not appear that railroad had any duty to maintain premises or that any member of crew could have prevented injuries by exercise of ordinary care, railroad was not negligent and was not liable to conductor under Federal Employers' Liability Act, and conductor was guilty of contributory negligence as a matter of law barring recovery from property owner.

See Callaghan's Illinois Digest, same topic and section number.

Appeal from the Superior Court of Cook county; the Hon. PAUL McWILLIAMS, Judge, presiding.

Reversed. Heard in the first division, first district, this court at the June term, 1948.

Theodore Schmidt, P.J. Cronin, Barrett,

Barrett, Costello Barrett and James A. Dooley, for appellants;

Wendell H. Shanner and John W. Costello, of counsel;

Edward B. Henslee, for appellee;

Melvin L. Griffith and Walter N. Murray, of counsel.


Not to be published in full. Opinion filed December 13, 1948; rehearing denied December 27, 1948; released for publication December 27, 1948.


Summaries of

Killian v. Pennsylvania R. Co.

Appellate Court of Illinois, First District
Dec 13, 1948
336 Ill. App. 152 (Ill. App. Ct. 1948)

In Killian, the plaintiff saw the dangerous condition, instructed the Mallory Company employee to move certain barrels, and thereafter, though standing a mere ten to twelve feet away, did not look to see whether the barrels had been moved.

Summary of this case from Howes v. Baker
Case details for

Killian v. Pennsylvania R. Co.

Case Details

Full title:Alvie D. Killian, Appellee, v. Pennsylvania Railroad Company, and P. R…

Court:Appellate Court of Illinois, First District

Date published: Dec 13, 1948

Citations

336 Ill. App. 152 (Ill. App. Ct. 1948)
82 N.E.2d 834

Citing Cases

Hall v. Chicago N.W. Ry. Co.

Of course the close clearance created by such proximity gives rise to some danger, but not such as to be…

Wetherbee v. Elgin, Joliet Eastern Ry. Co.

Granted that defendant railway had a duty to have someone inspect the tracks before the cars and engine…