Opinion
8:07CV226.
October 14, 2008
ORDER
This matter is before the Court on defendant's objections to plaintiff's deposition designations (Filing No. 111), defendant's objections to plaintiff's rebuttal deposition designations (Filing No. 112), and plaintiff's objections to defendant's deposition designations and discovery designations (Filing No. 117). The Court has reviewed the objections, the corresponding designations (Filing Nos. 116, 104, 117), and the applicable law, and reserves ruling, until the time of trial, on all objections except as follows: Van Norman Deposition Designation Objection Ruling Comment Osterbuhr Deposition Designation Objection Ruling Comment Wilcox Deposition Designation Objection Ruling Comment Armstrong Deposition Designation Objection Ruling Comment Johnson Deposition Designation Objection Ruling Comment
58:10-12 Leading Overruled 114:4-11 Leading Overruled 6:17-20 Relevancy Overruled 71:4-6 Calls for Overruled Speculation 78:5 Non-Responsive Overruled Answer 81:5-15 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 85:21-24 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 85:25-86:3 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 86:9-13 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 88:23-89:10 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 89:11-17 Foundation Overruled 90:12-18 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 95:13-17 Speculation Overruled 96:5-18 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 96:22-97:7 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 97:8-17 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 97:18-98:1 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 98:2-9 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 98:10-19 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 98:20-99:4 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 99:5-12 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 100:5-13 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 101:9-15 Foundation, Overruled Speculation 104:22-24 Leading Overruled 105:5-6 Leading Overruled 108:3-16 Form, Overruled Speculation 114:4-11 Leading Overruled 117:12-20 Incomplete Overruled Hypo, Speculation 46:19-48:1 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation answer through 48:3 48:22 Compound Overruled Not Designated 48:22 Incomplete Overruled Not Designated Designation 49:6-9 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation answer through 49:14 62:4-21 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation question from 61:18 63:24-64:3 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation question from 63:8 25:19-26:18 Relevancy Overruled 27:16-19 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation question from 27:9 31:11-16 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation answer from 31:18 32:13-33:5 Leading Overruled 37:10-13 Incomplete Overruled Designation 83:14-20 Relevancy Overruled 84:4-9 Relevancy Sustained 24:1-14 Overbroad Sustained Includes question Designation without an answer. Stop at 24:8 28:6-21 Incomplete Sustained Must include question Designation from 28:2 or could begin at 28:7 43:1-2 Relevancy Sustained 43:15-44:4 Compound, Overruled Relevancy, Form 47:14-48:12 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation question at beginning and answer at end. 47:9-48:14 48:15-23 Incomplete Sustained Must include entire Designation answer to 48:25IT IS SO ORDERED.