From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Johnson v. Superior Court

Supreme Court of California
Sep 1, 1884
65 Cal. 567 (Cal. 1884)

Opinion

         APPLICATION for writ of certiorari to review an order adjudging the petitioner guilty of contempt for disobeying an injunction.

         COUNSEL:

         Brown & Daggett, for Petitioner.

         Atwell & Bradley, for Respondent.


         OPINION

          ROSS, Judge

         The remaining facts are stated in the opinion of the court.

         In an action brought by one Bliss against the petitioner and others to enjoin them from diverting the waters of a certain [4 P. 576] stream, the Superior Court granted a preliminary in unction commanding the defendants to remove the obstructions by which they diverted the said waters, and to permit them to flow undisturbed in the stream, pending the action. Whether there was error in granting the injunction is not now for consideration. The case being here upon certiorari, the inquiry, of course, goes only to the power of the court to make the order. The jurisdiction of the court to grant a preliminary injunction, restraining the defendant from interfering with the flow of water pending the litigation cannot be doubted, and we cannot see that its jurisdiction is exceeded when it requires the removal of the means by which the diversion is made. The ultimate aim of the injunction is the undisturbed flow of the water. The objections to the removal of the means by which the diversion is made are no more cogent than the objections to preventing the diversion of the water itself. Upon the hearing in the court below there was testimony tending to show that after the dam that diverted the water had been in part removed, it was rebuilt by the direction of petitioner, and the diversion of the water continued, notwithstanding the injunction of the court. We do not think the court exceeded its power in adjudging the petitioner guilty of contempt.

         Writ denied and petition dismissed.

         McKEE, J., and McKINSTRY, J., concurred.

         Hearing in Bank denied.


Summaries of

Johnson v. Superior Court

Supreme Court of California
Sep 1, 1884
65 Cal. 567 (Cal. 1884)
Case details for

Johnson v. Superior Court

Case Details

Full title:J. H. JOHNSON, PETITIONER, v. THE SUPERIOR COURT OF TULARE COUNTY…

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Sep 1, 1884

Citations

65 Cal. 567 (Cal. 1884)
4 P. 575

Citing Cases

Heil v. Sawada

In case of a contempt proceeding, which might involve the respective individual rights and duties of these…

Allen v. Stowell

The courts are perhaps more reluctant to interpose the mandatory writ, but in a proper case it is never…