Opinion
3:19-MD-2913-WHO
01-06-2023
IN RE JUUL LABS, INC., MARKETING SALES PRACTICE AND PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION This Document Relates to All Plaintiffs Identified in Exhibits A and B Plaintiff Case Name Case Number Counsel Date MTD Filed MTD ECF Number Case Case Date MTD with Prejudice Filed MTD ECF Number
[PROPOSED] CONSOLIDATED ORDER GRANTING JLI'S MOTIONS TO DISMISS WITHOUT PREJUDICE FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT DISCOVERY REQUIRED BY CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER NOS. 8 AND 13 AND JLI'S MOTION TO CONVERT ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE
The Honorable William H. Orrick, United States District Judge
This Document Relates To: All Actions
Before the Court are (1) the Motion by Defendant Juul Labs, Inc. to Dismiss the Complaints filed by all plaintiffs identified in Exhibit A (the “Motion to Dismiss”) (Dkt. Nos. 3417, 3428, 3434, 3464, 3486, 3604, and 3632) and (2) the Motion by Defendant Juul Labs, Inc. to Convert Order of Dismissal without Prejudice to Order of Dismissal with Prejudice for all plaintiff identified in Exhibit B (the “Motion to Convert”) (Dkt. No. 3435) in the above referenced, consolidated actions. Having considered the motions and arguments of the parties, and with good cause appearing therefore, the Court hereby (1) GRANTS the Motion to Dismiss and DISMISSES the Complaints filed by all plaintiffs identified in Exhibit A without prejudice, and (2) GRANTS the Motion to Convert and DISMISSES the Complaints filed by all plaintiffs identified in Exhibit B with prejudice.
The Plaintiffs identified in Dkt. Nos. 3386 and 3510 have voluntarily dismissed their cases or submitted Plaintiff Fact Sheets. Accordingly, Dkt. Nos. 3386 and 3510 are TERMINATED as MOOT.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Exhibit A
Count
Plaintiff
Case Name
Case
Number
Counsel
Date MTD Filed
MTD
ECF Number
1.
Weber, William Leonard
William Leonard Weber v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02399
Hare, Wynn, Newell & Newton, LLP
8/22/2022
3417
2.
Lambert, Hunter
Hunter Lambert v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02397
Pulaski Kherkher, PLLC
8/29/2022
3428
3.
Mills, Dominic
Dominic Mills v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02428
Pulaski Kherkher, PLLC
8/29/2022
3428
4.
Christoph, Russell
Russell Christoph v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02471
Pulaski Kherkher, PLLC
8/29/2022
3428
5.
Coker, Ashten
Ashten Coker v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02484
Pulaski Kherkher, PLLC
8/29/2022
3428
6.
Ferreira, Matheus
Matheus Ferreira v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02722
Pulaski Kherkher, PLLC
9/13/2022
3464
7.
Yee, Luke
Luke Yee v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
3:22-cv-02759
Napoli Shkolnik PLLC
9/19/2022
3486
8.
Jimenez, Dave
Dave Jimenez v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al
3:22-cv-03212
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
10/17/2022
3604
9.
Zenith
Academy East
Zenith Academy East v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al
3:22-cv-03307
Frantz Law Group, APLC
10/24/2022
3632
Exhibit B
Count
Case Number
Case
Plaintiff
Counsel
Date MTD with Prejudice Filed
MTD ECF Number
1.
3:21-cv-10087
Kadie Jones v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Jones, Kadie
TorHoerman Law, LLC
5/9/2022
3169
2.
3:21-cv-10090
Morgan Overstreet v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Overstreet, Morgan
TorHoerman Law, LLC
5/9/2022
3169
3.
3:21-cv-10091
Maureen Dwelley v. Juu.
Labs, Inc. et al.
Dwelley, Maureen
TorHoerman Law, LLC
5/9/2022
3169
4.
3:21-cv-09425
Layanna Ahrens v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Ahrens, Layanna
Fears Nachawati, PLLC
4/18/2022
3043
5.
3:21-cv-09491
Alex Sheehan v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Sheehan, Alex
Goldenberg Law, PLLC
4/18/2022
3043
6.
3:21-cv-09534
America Hechavarria v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Hechavarria, America
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/18/2022
3043
7.
3:21-cv-09571
Jalin A.
Howell- Foster v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Howell-Foster, Jalin A.
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/18/2022
3043
8.
3:21-cv-09631
Chevy Lee Paul Huff v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Huff, Chevy Lee Paul
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/25/2022
3054
9.
3:21-cv-09678
Alize Potasz v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Potasz, Alize
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/25/2022
3054
10.
3:21-cv-09679
Tyler Currie v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
Currie, Tyler
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/25/2022
3054
11.
3:21-cv-09695
Joshua Sanders v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al
Sanders, Joshua
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/25/2022
3054
12.
3:21-cv-09724
Elizabeth-Grace
Dickey v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al
Dickey, Elizabeth-Grace
Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles, LLC
4/25/2022
3054
13.
3:21-cv-09749
J.K v. Juul Labs, Inc. et al.
J.K.
Giskan Solotaroff & Anderson
LLP
4/25/2022
3054