From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Heston v. Martin

Supreme Court of California
Oct 1, 1858
11 Cal. 41 (Cal. 1858)

Opinion

         Appeal from the District Court of the Twelfth Judicial District, County of San Francisco.

         This was an action to enforce a mechanic's lien, for the construction of a house and materials furnished.

         Plaintiff made a written contract with the defendant for the construction of a house. Defendant was to pay therefor a specified sum in instalments.

         The case was tried by the Court, and judgment rendered for the defendants--the Court finding that, under the contract, there was nothing due. By a stipulation entered into, it was agreed to submit to the Court for its decision, the question, whether the amount of $ 2,080.75--this being the balance due under the contract--was a lien upon the premises. The Court rendered a decision establishing a lien to this amount, from which decision this appeal is taken.

         COUNSEL:

         Robert C. & Daniel Rogers, for Appellant.

          Harmon & Labbatt, for Respondent.


         JUDGES: Baldwin, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Field, J., concurring.

         OPINION

          BALDWIN, Judge

         This appeal is without merit, and it is apparent that the only point seriously urged by the appellant--to wit: that an account is necessary, giving the items of work and materials in the statement of lien filed--cannot be maintained in case of a contract for a sum in gross.

         Judgment affirmed, with ten per cent. damages.


Summaries of

Heston v. Martin

Supreme Court of California
Oct 1, 1858
11 Cal. 41 (Cal. 1858)
Case details for

Heston v. Martin

Case Details

Full title:HESTON v. MARTIN

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Oct 1, 1858

Citations

11 Cal. 41 (Cal. 1858)

Citing Cases

Hicks v. Murray

The objection to plaintiffs' lien made by appellants, that the claim is for a sum in gross, and does not…

Selden v. Meeks

The lien is bad, inasmuch as it fails to show--1st, an account, or the balance of an account, or that the…