From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Hand Trading Company v. Daniels

Court of Appeals of Georgia
May 23, 1972
190 S.E.2d 560 (Ga. Ct. App. 1972)

Summary

In Hand, the court refused to give an earlier judgment lienholder priority over a loan used to purchase a lot and to construct a home.

Summary of this case from Citibank Mortg. v. Carteret Sav. Bank

Opinion

46887.

ARGUED JANUARY 31, 1972.

DECIDED MAY 23, 1972.

Declaratory judgment. Mitchell Superior Court. Before Judge Culpepper.

H. Thaxton Monk, Jr., for appellant.

Fred B. Hand, Jr., for appellees.


This is a declaratory judgment action in which plaintiffs sought a declaration as to the priority of liens on certain real property as between the Farmers Home Administration and the defendant, a judgment creditor of plaintiffs. It is undisputed that plaintiffs were deeded real estate and gave a security deed to the Farmers Home Administration as security for a $14,500 loan made to plaintiffs for the purchase of a lot and construction of a house. The defendant had previously obtained a money judgment against the plaintiffs. The issue is controlled adversely to defendant, as a "mortgage or deed to land, securing its purchase money and executed as a part of the same transaction in which the purchaser acquires title, will exclude or take precedence over any prior lien against the property arising through or against the purchaser. Where the contracts are simultaneously made, so as to constitute one transaction,`it makes no difference that the purchase-money mortgage may be made to a third person who advances the purchase money at the time the purchaser receives his conveyance.'" Federal Land Bank v. Bank of Lenox, 192 Ga. 543, 556 ( 16 S.E.2d 9); Protestant Episcopal Church v. Lowe Co., 131 Ga. 666 ( 63 S.E. 136, 127 ASR 243); Achey v. Coleman, 92 Ga. 745 ( 19 S.E. 710). The fact that no house was constructed on the land at the time of the transaction will not bring about a different result as it is clear and undisputed that the loan was made for the purpose of providing purchase money for the lot and the construction of a house which has been accomplished. The trial court's judgment declaring that the defendant's prior judgment lien is inferior to the security instrument of the Farmers Home Administration is

Affirmed. Eberhardt, P. J., and Evans, J., concur.

ARGUED JANUARY 31, 1972 — DECIDED MAY 23, 1972.


Summaries of

Hand Trading Company v. Daniels

Court of Appeals of Georgia
May 23, 1972
190 S.E.2d 560 (Ga. Ct. App. 1972)

In Hand, the court refused to give an earlier judgment lienholder priority over a loan used to purchase a lot and to construct a home.

Summary of this case from Citibank Mortg. v. Carteret Sav. Bank
Case details for

Hand Trading Company v. Daniels

Case Details

Full title:HAND TRADING COMPANY v. DANIELS et al

Court:Court of Appeals of Georgia

Date published: May 23, 1972

Citations

190 S.E.2d 560 (Ga. Ct. App. 1972)
190 S.E.2d 560

Citing Cases

Resolution Trust Corp. v. Bopp

Other courts, however, have reached the opposite conclusion. Georgia, for example, in Hand Trading Company v.…

Murray v. Chulak

When the contracts are simultaneously made, so as to constitute one transaction, `it makes no difference that…