Hadley v. Baxendale, 9 Exch. 353. If the purchaser of guano may show a breach of warranty as to its quality by the effect of its use upon his crops ( Carter v. McGill, 168 N.C. 507), why may he not by proper evidence show the relative production of land with and without the fertilizer, or the usual effect under ordinary conditions of delayed planting when fertilizer is used? Evidence as to cultivation and tillage, the crop planted, the time of planting, the quality of the soil, and the condition of the weather and the seasons may, (253) under proper instructions, be considered by the jury. Carter v. McGill, supra; Tomlinson v. Morgan, 166 N.C. 560; Herring v. Armwood, 130 N.C. 177; Spencer v. Hamilton, 113 N.C. 49; Neal v. Hardware Co., 122 N.C. 105; Gatlin v. R. R., 179 N.C. 435. In material respects, Ober v. Katzenstein, 160 N.C. 440, is distinguishable from the case under consideration; but in that case it is said that when the vendor knows that the fertilizer is for the purchaser's crops, and fails to deliver it, and the purchaser, because of the lateness of the season, is unable to purchase it elsewhere, he is entitled to damages.
No error. Cited: Gatlin v. R. R., 179 N.C. 435; Harrill v. R. R., 181 N.C. 316; Iron Works v. Cotton Oil Co., 192 N.C. 445; Troition v. Goodman, 225 N.C. 413; Casey v. Grantham, 239 N.C. 128. (348)
Petition dismissed. Cited: Fertilizer Works v. Aiken, 175 N.C. 401 (c); Gatlin v. R. R., 179 N.C. 435 (c); Fertilizing Co. v. Thomas, 181 N.C. 280, 281 (c); Fertilizer Works v. Simpson, 183 N.C. 253 (c); Pearsall v. Eakins, 184 N.C. 294 (c); Gulley v. Raynor, 185 N.C. 98 (d); Swift Co. v. Aydlett, 192 N.C. 338, 343 (c). (777)
New trial. Cited: Carter v. McGill, 171 N.C. 775; Gatlin v. R. R., 179 N.C. 435; Fertilizing Co. v. Thomas, 181 N.C. 280; Fertilizer Works v. Simpson, 183 N.C. 252; Pearsall v. Eakins, 184 N.C. 294; Gulley v. Raynor, 185 N.C. 98; Brown v. Ruffin, 189 N.C. 266; Swift v. Etheridge, 190 N.C. 168; Swift Co. v. Aydlett, 192 N.C. 338; Gaskins v. Mitchell, 194 N.C. 276.
New trial. Cited: Bland v. Harvester Co., 169 N.C. 419; Winn v. Finch, 171 N.C. 276; Carter v. McGill, 171 N.C. 775; Hollingsworth v. Supreme Council, 175 N.C. 636; Murray Co. v. Broadway, 176 N.C. 151; Gatlin v. R. R., 179 N.C. 435; Fertilizer Co. v. Thomas, 181 N.C. 280; Sprout v. Ward, 181 N.C. 375; Fay v. Crowell, 182 N.C. 534; White v. Fisheries Co., 183 N.C. 231; Brewington v. Laughran, 183 N.C. 565; Colt v. Springle, 190 N.C. 230; Swift Co. v. Aydlett, 192 N.C. 338; Hyman v. Broughton, 197 N.C. 3; Frick Co. v. Shelton, 197 N.C. 297.