From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Flowers v. Sheriff

Supreme Court of Nevada
Apr 14, 1976
548 P.2d 644 (Nev. 1976)

Opinion

No. 8746

April 14, 1976

Appeal from the Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; James A. Brennan, J.

Morgan D. Harris, Public Defender, and Mike Harrison, Deputy, Clark County, for Appellant.

Robert List, Attorney General, Carson City; George E. Holt, District Attorney, and Frank J. Cremen, Deputy, Clark County, for Respondent.


OPINION


At the conclusion of a preliminary examination Terry Dee Flowers was ordered to stand trial for battery with intent to commit rape, a felony under NRS 200.400.

In an effort to avoid trial Flowers timely petitioned for habeas corpus, contending the charge should be dismissed because the evidence adduced at the preliminary examination did not meet the probable cause test delineated in NRS 171.206. He also contends his "in-court" identification should be suppressed because it was based on an unduly suggestive pretrial lineup.

1. Contrary to Flowers' contention, we believe the quantum and quality of the evidence adduced at the preliminary examination met the requirements of probable cause specified in NRS 171.206 and, therefore, warranted the magistrate's determination that Flowers should stand trial. State v. Havas, 91 Nev. 611, 540 P.2d 1060 (1975).

"[W]e are not now concerned with the prospect that the evidence presently in the record may, by itself, be insufficient to sustain a conviction." McDonald v. Sheriff, 89 Nev. 326, 327, 512 P.2d 774, 775 (1973).

2. Flowers' attempted constitutional challenge to the admissibility of the "in-court" identification is not cognizable in habeas; rather, it should be raised through a motion to suppress, as contemplated by NRS 174.125. See Cook v. State, 85 Nev. 692, 462 P.2d 523 (1969), and its progeny.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Flowers v. Sheriff

Supreme Court of Nevada
Apr 14, 1976
548 P.2d 644 (Nev. 1976)
Case details for

Flowers v. Sheriff

Case Details

Full title:TERRY DEE FLOWERS, APPELLANT, v. SHERIFF, CLARK COUNTY, NEVADA, RESPONDENT

Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Apr 14, 1976

Citations

548 P.2d 644 (Nev. 1976)
548 P.2d 644

Citing Cases

Eckert v. Sheriff

3. Eckert's attempt to suppress identification testimony before the grand jury must be raised in a motion to…