First Chicago Corp. v. C.I.R

Full title: FIRST CHICAGO CORPORATION, PETITIONER-APPELLEE, v. COMMISSIONER OF…

Court: United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit

Date published: Sep 4, 1984

742 F.2d 1102 (7th Cir. 1984)

Opinion

No. 83-2267.

Argued April 18, 1984.

Decided September 4, 1984.

John L. Snyder, Hopkins Sutter, Chicago, Ill., for petitioner-appellee.

Ernest J. Brown, U.S. Dept. of Justice, Tax Div., Appellate Sect., Washington, D.C., for defendant-appellant.

Appeal from the United States Tax Court for the Northern District of Illinois.

Before CUMMINGS, Chief Judge, CUDAHY, Circuit Judge, and FAIRCHILD, Senior Circuit Judge.

PER CURIAM.

This appeal involves the question whether the Commissioner's assessment of a deficiency in income taxes of First Chicago Corporation for 1972 was barred by the 3-year statute of limitations contained in Section 6501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, as the full Tax Court held in an 8 to 5 decision reported in 80 T.C. 648 (1983). We hold that the statute of limitations was not a bar because the exceptions in Sections 6501(h) and 6501(j) apply.¹

1 The pertinent parts of Section 6501 are reproduced in the Appendix hereto.

The taxable years involved are 1972 and 1974. Taxpayer filed its income tax return for 1972 on May 17, 1973, and for 1974 on June 13, 1975. On June 2, 1978, the Commissioner mailed taxpayer a notice of deficiency in federal income tax for 1972 in the amount of $298,861, later reduced by stipulation to $227,245 (App. A 45). The majority of the Tax Court accepted taxpayer's argument that the assessment was barred by the 3-year statute of limitations contained in Section 6501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code since the notice of the deficiency for 1972 had not been mailed within 3 years from the date on which taxpayer's return for 1972 had been filed. The Commissioner's position is that since the notice of deficiency was mailed on June 2, 1978, within 3 years from June 13, 1975, the filing date of taxpayer's return for 1974, which reported large net capital losses and unused investment credit carrybacks giving rise to the 1972 deficiency, the notice was timely under Sections 6501(h) and 6501(j).

Taxpayer does not challenge the Commissioner's theory that the 1972 deficiency was attributable to capital loss and investment credit carrybacks from 1974 but relies solely on the Section 6501(a) statute of limitations ( 80 T.C. 654; App. A 6).

The majority of the Tax Court agreed with taxpayer that Section 6501(a) was controlling, even though, as the Supreme Court admonished again this year in Badaracco v. Commissioner, ___ U.S. ___, 104 S.Ct. 756, 761, 78 L.Ed.2d 549, that limitations statutes barring the collection of taxes otherwise due must be strictly construed in favor of the government. In the Tax Court the dissenting judges held that the reduction in the carryover amount of taxpayer's 1971 income tax to 1972 was "attributable to the application to the taxpayer of" the 1974 capital loss and investment credit carrybacks, both of which were effective to reduce its 1971 tax liability and to result in a 1972 deficiency. Following the opinion in Herman Bennett Co. v. Commissioner, 65 T.C. 506 (1975), the dissenters concluded that the "attributable to" language used in Section 6501(h) and in Section 6501(j) was satisfied because the 1972 deficiency can be "traced to" the carrybacks from 1974, as even the majority conceded ( 80 T.C. 652; App. A 8).² This literal construction, uncontradicted by legislative history ( 80 T.C. 666-669; App. A 31-A 34), permits "the [Tax] Court to do what it conceives as equity," quoting from the majority opinion ( 80 T.C. 663; App. A 26).

2 Even taxpayer's July 30, 1975, refund application for 1974 noted that it was carrying back unused investment credit and net capital loss "from 1974 to 1971 * * *" (App. A 47; emphasis supplied).

We agree with and adopt the dissenting opinion of the Tax Court ( 80 T.C. 663-672; App. A 27-A 41) as our own. Therefore the decision of the Tax Court is reversed and the cause is remanded for further proceedings consistent herewith.

APPENDIX

SEC. 6501. LIMITATIONS ON ASSESSMENT AND COLLECTION.

Except as otherwise provided in this section,

* * * * * *

In the case of a deficiency attributable to the application to the taxpayer of a capital loss carryback such deficiency may be assessed at any time before the expiration of the period within which a deficiency for the taxable year of the net capital loss which results in such carryback may be assessed

* * * * * *

In the case of a deficiency attributable to the application to the taxpayer of an investment credit carryback such deficiency may be assessed at any time before the expiration of the period within which a deficiency for the taxable year of the unused investment credit which results in such carryback may be assessed (a) General Rule. — the amount of any tax imposed by this title shall be assessed within 3 years after the return was filed (whether or not such return was filed on or after the date prescribed) or, if the tax is payable by stamp, at any time after such tax became due and before the expiration of 3 years after the date on which any part of such tax was paid, and no proceeding in court without assessment for the collection of such tax shall be begun after the expiration of such period. (h) Net Operating Loss or Capital Loss Carrybacks. — a net operating loss carryback or (including deficiencies which may be assessed pursuant to the provisions of section 6213(b)(2)), [here 1974] net operating loss or [here June 13, 1978]. In the case of a deficiency attributable to the application of a net operating loss carryback, such deficiency may be assessed within 18 months after the date on which the taxpayer files in accordance with section 172(b)(3) a copy of the certification (with respect to the taxable year of the net operating loss) issued under section 317 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, if later than the date prescribed by the preceding sentence. (j) Investment Credit Carrybacks. — (including deficiencies which may be assessed pursuant to the provisions of section 6213(b)(2)), [here 1974] [here June 13, 1978], or, with respect to any portion of an investment credit carryback from a taxable year attributable to a net operating loss carryback or a capital loss carryback from a subsequent taxable year, at any time before the expiration of the period within which a deficiency for such subsequent taxable year may be assessed. (Emphasis supplied.)