Opinion
Civil Action No: MDL 875 E.D. Pa. No: 08-90234
11-16-2012
In re: ASBESTOS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION (No. VI) This Document Relates to: FERGUSON v. A.C. AND S., INC. as well as the other cases on the attached list (all CVLO cases)
ORDER
AND NOW, this 16th day of November, 2012, upon consideration of the following motions, responses, replies, and motions for joinder, as well as plaintiffs' omnibus response (10-67443, Doc. 191) and the September 13, 2012 oral argument on the motions:
1. Defendant CBS Corporation's Motions for Sanctions (10-68073 Doc. 153; 08-90234 Doc. 73) and responses (10-68073 Doc. 172; 08-90234 Doc. 86);
2. Defendant Duke Energy Indiana, Inc's Motion to Strike (08-89340 Doc. 96) and response (08-89340 Doc. 100);
3. General Electric Company's Motion to Strike (08-90058 Doc. 106; 08-90263 Doc. 96; 08-90132 Doc. 102; 08-90122 Doc. 112; 08-90063 Doc. 97; 08-90166 Doc. 110), responses (08-90058 Doc. 114; 08-90263 Doc. 100; 08-90132 Doc. 106; 08-90122 Doc. 115; 08-90063 Doc. 102; 08-90166 Doc. 118) and replies (e.g. 08-90058 Doc. 116); and
4. Owens-Illinois, Inc.'s Motions to Strike (09-60552 Doc. 93; 10-67814 Doc. 114; 09-60256 Doc. 82; 09-61026 Doc. 106; 10-67443 Doc. 175; 11-63501 Doc. 155; 08-90058 Doc. 104; 08-90132 Doc. 101; 08-90263 Doc. 95; 08-90166 Doc. 107; 10-67555 Doc. 116; 11-66746 Doc. 176; 11-63483 Doc. 352) and responses (09-60552 Doc. 102; 09-60256 Doc. 89; 09-61026 Doc. 114; 11-63501 Doc. 164; 08-90132 Doc. 105; 08-90263 Doc. 99; 10-67555 Doc. 118; 11-66746 Doc. 182; 11-63483 Doc. 362);
it is hereby ORDERED that:
5. All motions for joinder are GRANTED;
6. CBS Corporation's Motions for Sanctions in Plue, (10-68073 Doc. 153) and Ferguson, (08-90243 Doc. 73) are DENIED;
7. The remaining motions listed above are GRANTED in part as described in the attached
memorandum in that all interrogatory responses which were not verified by the Plaintiffs are struck; and
8. all other relief requested is DENIED.
BY THE COURT:
______________________
DAVID R. STRAWBRIDGE
UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
CASE LIST
+----------------------------------------------------------+ ¦Krik ¦Charles ¦11-CV-63473 ¦Top Ten ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Menozzi ¦Eugene ¦08-CV-89865 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Carnegie ¦John ¦08-CV-89958 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Hollins ¦Willie ¦08-CV-90201 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Winslow ¦Terry ¦08-CV-92114 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Johnson ¦Richard ¦08-CV-92122 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Weber ¦Daniel ¦08-CV-92132 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Hutchinson ¦Jack ¦08-CV-92157 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦O'Keefe ¦Robert ¦08-CV-92210 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Frankenberger ¦Howard ¦09-CV-61717 ¦1&2 Subgroup A ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦McCullum ¦Roosevelt ¦08-CV-89883 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦De Witt ¦Elsie ¦08-CV-90189 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Centers ¦Albert ¦08-CV-90268 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Smith ¦Ronald ¦08-CV-90287 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Wilson ¦Merle ¦08-CV-91879 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Pray ¦Frankie ¦08-CV-91884 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Buchanan ¦Howard ¦08-CV-92038 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Black ¦John ¦10-CV-68110 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Malone ¦Clifford ¦10-CV-68124 ¦1&2 Subgroup B ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Ferguson ¦James ¦08-CV-90234 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Norberg ¦Earl ¦08-CV-90264 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Bault ¦Charles ¦08-CV-91663 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Bugg ¦William ¦08-CV-91729 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Schurtz ¦Michael ¦08-CV-91742 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Spangler ¦Herbert ¦08-CV-91882 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Thomas ¦Glendel ¦08-CV-92206 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Henney ¦Jean ¦09-CV-64629 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Allen ¦Gary ¦10-CV-67536 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Plue ¦Richard ¦10-CV-68073 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Dover ¦Jackie ¦10-CV-68127 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Cummings ¦Ronald ¦10-CV-68902 ¦1&2 Subgroup C ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Doyle ¦James ¦08-CV-89845 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Haffner ¦Robert ¦08-CV-89863 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Larweth ¦Dennis ¦08-CV-89914 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Wilson ¦Harold ¦08-CV-90732 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Childs ¦Earl ¦08-CV-91089 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Suoja ¦Oswald ¦09-CV-60256 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Hass ¦Laverne ¦09-CV-60267 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Hass ¦Laverne ¦09-CV-60298 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Meagher ¦John ¦09-CV-60445 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Connell ¦Daniel ¦09-CV-60552 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Obermeier ¦Sylvester ¦09-CV-61019 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Schmoll ¦Cyril ¦09-CV-61026 ¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Morris ¦Michael ¦3 20db0a946a¦3 ¦ +---------------+-----------+-------------+----------------¦ ¦Waltenberg ¦Claude ¦09-CV-61499 ¦3 ¦ +----------------------------------------------------------+
+----------------------------------------+ ¦Vradenburg ¦Stanley ¦09-CV-62185 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Woods ¦James ¦09-CV-62583 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Willocks ¦Tommy ¦09-CV-64701 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Stephens ¦John ¦09-CV-64733 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Rickey ¦Marvin ¦10-CV-61345 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Lorentz ¦Eugene ¦10-CV-61348 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Sutherlin ¦James ¦10-CV-64565 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Collins ¦Arthur ¦10-CV-64567 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Louis ¦Richard ¦3 30f95858da¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Cadotte ¦Joseph ¦10-CV-64680 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Ahnert ¦Daniel ¦10-CV-67443 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Held ¦Donald ¦10-CV-67814 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Binder ¦Robert ¦10-CV-67817 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jakubowski ¦Florian ¦10-CV-67831 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Andris ¦Arthur ¦10-CV-67885 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Hakes ¦Donald ¦10-CV-68063 ¦3 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Reed ¦Hugh ¦08-CV-88250 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Austin ¦Richard ¦08-CV-89340 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Heggie ¦JW ¦08-CV-89372 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦McFarland ¦Charles ¦08-CV-89381 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Cook ¦Joseph ¦08-CV-89446 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Kemper ¦Jack ¦08-CV-89498 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Fata ¦Frank ¦08-CV-90058 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Schmidt ¦Donald ¦08-CV-90063 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Phillips ¦John ¦08-CV-90122 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jones ¦Asa ¦08-CV-90132 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Willey ¦Russel ¦08-CV-90166 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jackson ¦Floyd ¦08-CV-90263 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Percy ¦a14 eea ¦08-CV-90465 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Weber ¦Ronald ¦08-CV-91052 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Holme ¦Darrell ¦08-CV-91090 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Baker ¦Joseph ¦08-CV-91189 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bolton ¦John ¦09-CV-60186 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Esser ¦Charles ¦09-CV-60287 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bresnahan ¦Thomas ¦09-CV-60331 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jones ¦Duane ¦09-CV-60440 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Lundahl ¦Robert ¦09-CV-60444 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Sienko ¦Ronald ¦09-CV-60481 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jeske ¦Kenneth ¦09-CV-60547 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Junk ¦Bonnie ¦09-CV-60550 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Nuutinen ¦Charles ¦09-CV-61333 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Frisch ¦Louis ¦09-CV-61354 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Schroeder ¦Cletus ¦09-CV-61430 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Crumwell ¦Richard ¦09-CV-61744 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Ruesken ¦Louis ¦09-CV-61820 ¦4 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Giuliano ¦William ¦09-CV-64609 ¦4 ¦ +----------------------------------------+
+-------------------------------------------+ ¦Ringo ¦Robert ¦09-CV-91454 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bennington ¦Martin ¦10-CV-61115 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Pietrzycki ¦Stanley ¦10-CV-61349 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Suhaysik ¦Raymond ¦10-CV-61865 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Dittamore ¦William ¦10-CV-64583 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Embly ¦Robert ¦10-CV-64584 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Kelley ¦Howard ¦10-CV-67555 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Arseneault ¦Clovis ¦10-CV-67621 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Gosz ¦Clarence ¦10-CV-67808 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Risse ¦Loren ¦10-CV-67857 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Patrick ¦Homer ¦10-CV-68864 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Herr ¦Richard ¦11-CV-60064 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Van Stippen ¦Joseph ¦11-CV-63483 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Strerath ¦William ¦11-CV-63496 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Brazzoni ¦Alfred ¦11-CV-63501 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Tischer ¦Daniel ¦11-CV-63503 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Muehlberger ¦Max ¦11-CV-63518 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Johnson ¦Francis ¦11-CV-66278 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Zellner ¦Clifford ¦11-CV-66746 ¦4 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Kirk ¦Delbert ¦08-CV-89494 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦a5 0ca ¦Irving ¦08-CV-91762 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Hicks ¦William ¦08-CV-91888 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Maulding ¦Duane ¦08-CV-92113 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Walker ¦Clarence ¦08-CV-92136 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Serstad ¦Richard ¦09-CV-60165 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Loeffelad ¦Walter ¦09-CV-60231 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Caturia ¦Frederick ¦09-CV-60271 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Akey ¦Richard ¦09-CV-60286 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Reno ¦Charles ¦4 185f9f630a¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Dunne ¦Michael ¦09-CV-60329 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Burns ¦John ¦09-CV-60476 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Schulze ¦Ronald ¦09-CV-60516 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Miller ¦Frank ¦09-CV-60520 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Reich ¦Ronald ¦09-CV-60523 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Enerson ¦Donald ¦09-CV-61004 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Flaatten ¦Ronald ¦09-CV-61006 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jelinski ¦Jerome ¦09-CV-61012 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦White ¦Paul ¦09-CV-61033 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Holcomb ¦Edward ¦09-CV-61314 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Metzger ¦Jack ¦09-CV-61322 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Rathsack ¦Michael ¦09-CV-61347 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Gabrus ¦Donald ¦09-CV-61357 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Horton ¦Julius ¦09-CV-61469 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Ketchum ¦Richard ¦09-CV-61481 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Reichert ¦Norman ¦09-CV-61487 ¦5 ¦ +-------------+-----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Kiepert ¦William ¦09-CV-61544 ¦5 ¦ +-------------------------------------------+
+-----------------------------------------+ ¦Enos ¦Carroll ¦10-CV-61422 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Kumferman ¦Henry ¦10-CV-61429 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bartlett ¦Robert ¦10-CV-61467 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Gottsacker ¦Randall ¦10-CV-61885 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Zimmer ¦Lawrence ¦10-CV-61896 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Nelson ¦Marlin ¦10-CV-61956 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Sebastian ¦Sigfried ¦10-CV-64686 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Wagner ¦Edward ¦10-CV-67704 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Berger ¦Thomas ¦10-CV-67758 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Conway ¦Harold ¦10-CV-67785 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Hickmann ¦Eugene ¦10-CV-67805 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Junk ¦William ¦10-CV-67841 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Irons ¦Gary ¦10-CV-68130 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bucknell ¦Bertha ¦11-CV-63908 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Reno ¦Charles ¦11-CV-67724 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Oliphant ¦John ¦11-CV-67767 ¦5 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Dice ¦James ¦08-CV-88411 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bartlett ¦Thomas ¦08-CV-89791 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Rome ¦Douglas ¦08-CV-89825 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Czajkoski ¦Walter ¦08-CV-89969 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Klimek ¦David ¦08-CV-90065 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Matlock ¦Benjamin ¦08-CV-90099 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Graham ¦Marion ¦08-CV-90139 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Hamerla ¦John ¦08-CV-90208 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Patrick ¦Carolyn ¦08-CV-90221 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Woodmaster ¦Charles ¦08-CV-91087 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Gard ¦Leslie ¦08-CV-91736 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Van Dolah ¦Vernon ¦08-CV-91880 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Graves ¦William ¦08-CV-92120 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Lawless ¦Anthony ¦08-CV-92161 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Massey ¦Leonard ¦09-CV-61356 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Deters ¦Cletus ¦10-CV-64585 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Richardson ¦Eleanore ¦10-CV-67553 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Nichols ¦Gerald ¦10-CV-68097 ¦6 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Toon ¦Lloyd ¦08-CV-88707 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Brown ¦Gary ¦08-CV-89945 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Bey ¦George ¦08-CV-89979 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Brigham ¦George ¦08-CV-89984 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦White ¦Shirley ¦08-CV-90171 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Smith ¦Leo ¦08-CV-90276 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Scott ¦Thomas ¦08-CV-91314 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Taylor ¦James ¦08-CV-91881 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Nehlsen ¦Michael ¦08-CV-91893 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Ayers ¦Mark ¦08-CV-91953 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Daniels ¦Jimmie ¦08-CV-92259 ¦7 ¦ +------------+----------+-------------+---¦ ¦Engelman ¦Patrick ¦09-CV-60939 ¦7 ¦ +-----------------------------------------+
+----------------------------------------+ ¦Campbell ¦Elmer ¦10-CV-61341 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Benson ¦Harold ¦10-CV-64563 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Carlson ¦Neil ¦10-CV-67533 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Carmichael ¦James ¦10-CV-67545 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦ac9a7 ¦Svatek ¦11-CV-64036 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Jurglanis ¦Clemens ¦12-CV-60003 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Spychalla ¦Leonard ¦12-CV-60004 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Eulgen ¦Louis ¦12-CV-60019 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦Krueger ¦Glenn ¦12-CV-60020 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦a3e057 ¦Luella ¦12-CV-60049 ¦7 ¦ +------------+---------+-------------+---¦ ¦McNair ¦Mary ¦12-CV-60160 ¦7 ¦ +----------------------------------------+
Certificate of Service
MAILED:
ALBERT BOWER
AMBER ACHILLES
ANDREW WOLF
BARRY ROBIN
BEAU SEFTON
BILLEE WARD
BRADLEY FALKOF
BRIAN CAHILL
BRIAN FIELDS
BRIAN PLEGGE
BRUCE KAMPLAIN
BRUCE MARR
C. KOEBELE
CAROL PRYGROSKY
CHARLES BOHL
CHARLES DARGO
CHARLES REITER
CHRISTOPHER RAISTRICK
CLARKE GILLESPIE
CREED TUCKER
D. GLOOR
DANIEL FARROLL
DANIEL OVERBEY
DAVID BARTEL
DAVID MORRIS
DAVID MUELLER
DAVID ROLF
DEAN PANOS
DEBORAH SOLMOR
DEMARCUS GORDON
DENIS RISCHARD
DENNIS DOBBELS
DENNIS GRABER
DEREK SMITH
DEVLIN SCHOOP
DONALD BERGER
DONALD BROAD
ELIZABETH HARVEY
FRANCIS MORRISSEY
GARY SMITH
J. GASS
JACK BLOCK
JACQUELYN CHAMPAGNE
JAMES CULHANE
JAMES FIEWEGER
JAMES PECKERT
JAMES SNYDER
JAMES WHEELER
JAN DODD
JEFFREY MCKEAN
JEFFREY SCHMECKPEPER
JENNIFER FARDY
JENNIFER SEIDLER
JEROME KRINGS
JOAN IRICK
JOEL POOLE
JOHN CHILDERS
JOHN DAMES
JOHN DIXON
JOHN STUCKEY
JOSEPH O'HARA
JOSEPH WITEK
JOSHUA MURPHY
JUAN RAMIREZ
K. CAREY
KARL KOONS
KELLY CHERF
KELLY MCCLOSKEY
KENNETH GORENBERG
KEVIN LONG
KEVIN REID
KRISTIN ACHTERHOF
LAURA O'CONNELL
LEON TODD
LISA WARWICK
LORI YOKOYAMA
MARK JOHNSON
MARK LIES
MARK RAKOCZY
MATTHEW LEE
MAUREEN KELLY
MELISSA SKILKEN
MICHAEL BISHOP
MICHAEL CIESLEWICZ
MICHAEL HENNIG
MICHAEL KAEDING
MICHAEL KOKAL
MICHAEL O'ROURKE
MICHELLE MONTGOMERY
PAMELA PAIGE
PATRICK HAGGERTY
PATRICK JONES
PATRICK MCKENNA
PATRICK PHILLIPS
PETER CARLSON
PETER HATTON
R. MUTH
R. STOMMEL
RICHARD BAKER
RICHARD BOLTON
RICHARD CHAPIN
RICHARD HAAS
RICHARD STEINKEN
ROBERT HALEY
ROBERT KOPKA
RONALD CURTIS
RONALD LIPINSKI
RONALD WELDY
ROSEANNE LOFTUS
RUSSELL HOOVER
SCOTT KYROUAC
SEAN MACK
STACEY SENECZKO
STEPHEN KAUFMANN
STEPHEN KRAVIT
STEPHEN MAASSEN
STEVEN CELBA
STEVEN SANDERS
SUSAN GUNTY
SUSAN HUNTER
THADDEUS STANKOWSKI
THOMAS EHRHARDT
THOMAS MEYER
THOMAS WILSON
TIMOTHY FAGAN
TIMOTHY UEBER
VANI SINGHAL
VICTOR LAZZARETTI
W. WELSH
WILLIAM EHRKE
WILLIAM HASSLER
WILLIAM MCGRATH
ZANE LUCAS
E-MAILED:
ADAM JAGADICH
ADAM LAGOCKI
AHNDREA VANDENELZEN
ALLEN VAUGHAN
AMANDA SUMMERLIN
AMIEL GROSS
ANDREW DETHERAGE
ANTHONY GOLDNER
BARBARA BUBA
BARRY LOFTUS
BARRY SHORT
BASIL DISIPIO
BETH HUGHES
BRADLEY BULTMAN
BRADLEY NAHRSTADT
BRETT LARSEN
BRIAN WATSON
BRUCE CLARK
BRYAN SKELTON
BRYCE BENNETT
DOUGLAS KING
DOUGLAS PROCHNOW
DREW ODUM
EDWARD CASMERE
EDWARD CRANE
EDWARD KENNEY
EDWARD MACCABE
EDWARD MCCAMBRIDG
EMILY ZAPOTOCNY
ERIC CARLSON
FORREST WILKES
GARY SMITH
GEORGE KISER
GERMAINE WILLETT
GREGORY COCHRAN
GREGORY GOLDBERG
GREGORY LYONS
GREGORY MCNAMEE
HEIDI RUCKMAN
HOWARD MORRIS
JOSEPH SULLIVAN
JOSHUA JOHANNINGMEIER
JOSHUA LEE
KAREN RHEINGANS
KATHERINE SPITZ
KATHRYN DOWNEY
KAYCE GISINGER
KEITH HAYS
KENT PLOTNER
KENT ROGERS
KEVIN KNIGHT
KIMBERLY HILLMAN
KIMBERLY SARFF
KIRK HARTLEY
KNIGHT ANDERSON
KRISTINA LEMANSKI
KURT REITZ
KURTIS REEG
LANCE MUELLER
LAUREL JOHNSON
REED SUGG
RICHARD LAUTH
RICHARD RIEGNER
RICHARD SCHUSTER
ROBERT LONG
ROBERT MCCOY
ROBERT PISANI
ROBERT RALEIGH
ROBERT RILEY
ROBERT SANDS
ROBERT SCHROEDER
ROBERT SCOTT
ROBERT SPINELLI
ROBERT SPITKOVSKY
ROGER HEIDENREICH
RONALD AUSTIN
RONALD HACK
RUSSELL KLINGAMAN
RUSSELL SCOTT
SARAH MILLER
Certificate of Service
C. DOUGLAS
C. EVERT
CARMEN ANDERSON
CAROL ZUCKERMAN
CATHERINE CARLSON
CATHERINE MOHAN
CATHY MOLCHIN
CHAN MCLEOD
CHARLES JOLEY
CHRISTI JONES
CHRISTOPHER BANASZAK
CHRISTOPHER CONRAD
CHRISTOPHER LARSON
CHRISTOPHER LEE
CHRISTOPHER P.BANASZAK
CHRISTOPHER TRIBLE
CHRISTOPHER WAHL
CLARE MAISANO
CLARE RUSH
CONNIE POSTELLI
CRAIG BRASFIELD
CRAIG LILJESTRAND
CRAIG TURET
CURTIS BAILEY
CYNTHIA LOCKE
DANIEL CHEELY
DANIEL DONAHUE
DANIEL ELGER
DANIEL GRIFFIN
DANIEL JARDINE
DANIEL LONG
DANIEL MANNA
DANIEL MCGRATH
DANIEL MULHOLLAND
DANIEL O'CONNELL
DANIEL TRACHTMAN
DAVID DAMICO
DAVID DOGAN
DAVID FANNING
DAVID JONES
DAVID SETTER
DAVID SZLANFUCHT
DAVID TEMPLE
DAVID YBARRA
DEMETRA CHRISTOS
DENNIS CANTRELL
DONALD CARLSON
J. BRADLEY
J. MALONEY
JACOB SAWYER
JAMES BOYERS
JAMES CARTER
JAMES HOUSE
JAMES KASPER
JAMES MORRISON
JAMES MURRAY
JAMES NIQUET
JAMES SVAJGL
JAMES WALTON
JAMES WYNNE
JAMIE YADGAROFF
JANELLE LINDER
JASON CINCILLA
JASON KENNEDY
JASON RUBIN
JEFFREY FULTZ
JEFFREY HEBRANK
JEFFREY ROGERS
JEFFREY SCHIEBER
JENNIFER BLACKWELL
JENNIFER KALAS
JENNIFER STUDEBAKER
JEREMY HARRIS
JIN-HO CHUNG
JOHN BABIONE
JOHN CANONI
JOHN DOUGLAS
JOHN FONSTAD
JOHN HELLER
JOHN KUROWSKI
JOHN LAFFEY
JOHN MCCANTS
JOHN SEEBOHM
JOHN SHEFFER
JOHN SON
JOHN WALLER
JON BAROOSHIAN
JON FREDRICKSON
JON GOLDWOOD
JONATHAN MATTINGLY
JONATHAN PARRINGTON
JOSEPH CAGNOLI
JOSEPH KRASOVEC
JOSEPH REJANO
LAURIE MCLEROY
LAURIE RANDOLPH
LESLEY SHERMETA
LISA DILLMAN
M. GRANT
MAJA EATON
MARGARET FOSTER
MARK EISLER
MARK FELDMANN
MARK LUDOLPH
MARK SAMPSON
MARK TIVIN
MARTHA REGGI
MARTIN SCHWARTZ
MARY ANN HATCH
MARY GAY
MATTHEW FISCHER
MATTHEW JARDINE
MATTHEW THIBODEAU
MAUREEN COLEMAN
MELISSA SMITH
MICAH INLOW
MICHAEL ANTIKAINEN
MICHAEL BERGIN
MICHAEL BLOCK
MICHAEL CASCINO
MICHAEL DENNING
MICHAEL DRUMKE
MICHAEL ROSENBERG
MICHAEL TRUCCO
MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI
MITCHELL MOSER
NATHAN FRONK
NATHANIEL CADE
NEAL MCQUEENEY
NICHOLAS NIZAMOFF
NICOLE BEHNEN
OLLIE HARTON
PATRICK FINNEGAN
PATRICK LAMB
PATRICK STUFFLEBEAM
PAUL O'FLAHERTY
PAUL WOJCICKI
PETER MARKS
PETER MCKENNA
R. WILLINGHAM
RAYMOND FOURNIE
RAYMOND MODESITT
SARAH PAGELS
SCOTT HENRY
SCOTT SIMPKINS
SCOTT THOMSEN
SEAN SHEEHAN
SHAWANE LEE
SHAWN BABIUCH
SHEHZAD HASAN
SHEILA BIRNBAUM
STEPHEN JENKINS
STEPHEN MILOTT
STEPHEN SCHWARTZ
STEVEN BARBER
STEVEN BESHORE
STEVEN CARLSON
STEVEN KIRSCH
SUSAN MEHRINGER
TEIRNEY CHRISTENSON
THOMAS CANNON
THOMAS GILLIGAN
THOMAS GONZALEZ
THOMAS HAYES
THOMAS KERNELL
THOMAS NORBY
THOMAS ORRIS
THOMAS SCHMITZER
THOMAS SCHRIMPF
THOMAS TARDY
THOMAS THIBODEAU
TIFFANY TURNER
TIMOTHY KAPSHANDY
TIMOTHY KRIPPNER
TIMOTHY PAGEL
TIMOTHY PIKE
TOBIN TAYLOR
TRACY COWAN
TREVOR WILL
W. SIESENNOP
WALTER JENKINS
WALTER WATKINS
WARD BROWN
WAYNE MARVEL
WILLIAM CROKE
WILLIAM MAHONEY
WILLIAM SERRITELLA
WILLIAM SHULTZ
WILLIAM SMITH
WILLIS TRIBLER