Opinion
Argued December 20, 1907
Decided January 21, 1908
James F. Horan for plaintiff, appellant.
George L. Shearer for United States Trust Company, as trustee, appellant and respondent.
William Pierrepont Williams and Lanman Crosby for Hamilton W. Cary, as administrator, appellant and respondent.
Egerton L. Winthrop, Jr., for Fannie E. Francis, appellant and respondent.
Charles E. Buckingham for Albert C. Bostwick, Jr., et al., appellants and respondents.
Frank L. Polk for Marion B. Carstairs et al., appellants and respondents.
George F. Chamberlain for Albert C. Bostwick, respondent and appellant.
Ward B. Chamberlain for Helen C. Bostwick, respondent and appellant.
Judgment of Appellate Division reversed and that of Special Term affirmed, with costs to all parties appearing in this court and filing briefs, payable out of the fund, on the authority of N.Y. Life Ins. Trust Co. v. Cary ( 191 N.Y. 33).