From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

English v. Reynolds

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1817
4 N.C. 529 (N.C. 1817)

Opinion

(January Term, 1817.)

By the special wording of the two acts of 1777 and 1793 (1 Rev. Stat., ch. 6) a final judgment in an original attachment is equivalent to a final judgment in any other case; and debt will lie on it.

DEBT upon a judgment obtained in RUTHERFORD County Court, upon an attachment taken out by plaintiff v. defendant, levied upon property which was not replevied; and not being sufficient to satisfy the judgment, this action was brought to recover the balance. The plaintiff produced the judgment of the county court, upon which the jury gave a verdict for him. It is referred to the Supreme Court whether the judgment taken upon the attachment is conclusive, prima facie, or any evidence. If it is conclusive, judgment to be for plaintiff; if prima facie, or no evidence, then a new trial to be granted.


The case was submitted without argument.


The act of Assembly of 1793, ch. 16, sec. 8, makes it the duty of the clerk, on the return of an original attachment, "to cause the same, by public advertisement, to be made known for three months next after the return made as aforesaid," and the court cannot enter final judgment until this species of notice is given. But when the act is complied with, the judgment of the court is final. This advertisement is in lieu of personal notice, as two nihils on a scire facias are considered notice. The act of 1777 makes use of these words, "Any person whose estate is attached may, by himself or agent, at any time before final judgment entered, or writ of inquiry executed, upon giving special bail, replevy the estate so attached, and plead to issue." From an examination of the above mentioned acts of Assembly it does appear, to my mind, the Legislature considered a final judgment on an attachment (530) in the same light as a final judgment in any other case.

Judgment for plaintiff.

NOTE. — See Armstrong v. Harshaw, 12 N.C. 187; Washington v. Saunders, 13 N.C. 343.

Cited: Skinner v. Moore, 19 N.C. 149.


Summaries of

English v. Reynolds

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1817
4 N.C. 529 (N.C. 1817)
Case details for

English v. Reynolds

Case Details

Full title:ENGLISH v. REYNOLDS. — TERM, 92

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jan 1, 1817

Citations

4 N.C. 529 (N.C. 1817)