Opinion
Docket Nos. 14–4369–cv(L) 14–4509–cv(XAP) August Term, 2015
10-25-2016
EMI Christian Music Group, Incorporated, Priority Records LLC, Beechwood Music Corporation, Colgems–EMI Music, Incorporated, EMI April Music, Inc., EMI Blackwood Music, Inc., EMI Full Keel Music, Inc., EMI Golden Torch Music Corporation, EMI Longitude Music, EMI Virgin Music, Inc., EMI Virgin Songs, Inc., Capitol Records, LLC, Plaintiffs–Counter–Defendants–Appellees–Cross–Appellants, EMI Al Gallico Music Corporation, EMI Algee Music Corporation, EMI Feist Catalog, Inc., EMI Gold Horizon Music Corp., EMI Grove Park Music, Incorporated, EMI Hastings Catalog, Incorporated, EMI Mills Music, Incorporated, EMI Miller Catalog, Incorporated, EMI Robbins Catalog, Incorporated, EMI U Catalog, Inc., EMI Unart Catalog Inc., Jobete Music Company, Incorporated, Screen Gems–EMI Music, Incorporated, Stone Agate Music, Stone Diamond Music Corporation, Plaintiffs–Appellees–Cross–Appellants, v. MP3tunes, LLC, Defendant–Counter–Claimant–Cross–Appellee, Michael Robertson, Defendant–Appellant–Cross–Appellee.