From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Eelk v. Southern Pacific Co. (mem.)

Supreme Court of California
Apr 29, 1955
44 Cal.2d 882 (Cal. 1955)

Opinion

Docket No. Sac. 6523.

April 29, 1955.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Sacramento County. John Quincy Brown, Judge. Reversed.

Anthony J. Scalora for Appellant.

Horace B. Wulff, Devlin, Diepenbrock Wulff, Dunne, Dunne Phelps and Arthur B. Dunne for Respondent.


THE COURT.

Plaintiff, who was employed by defendant railroad company as a carman helper, was injured while working on the construction of new railroad cars, and he brought this action under the Federal Employers' Liability Act. Before trial of the other issues, the court held a hearing on the question of whether the federal act was applicable and concluded that it was not. Judgment was entered accordingly, and plaintiff appeals.

Defendant first employed plaintiff on November 7, 1950, and assigned him to repairing railroad cars already in service. He was placed on construction of new railroad cars from December 1 until January 8, 1951, at which time, apparently due to a shortage of construction materials, he was reassigned to repairs. On February 13, he again started doing new construction work, and he was so engaged exclusively until June 22 when he was injured while riveting sides on a new gondola car. The construction project was the same as that involved in Gileo v. Southern Pac. Co., ante, p. 539 [ 282 P.2d 872], this day decided, where a welder was injured while working on one of the gondola cars. The factual situations in the two cases are substantially similar, and our decision holding the act applicable to Gileo is controlling here.

The judgment is reversed.


Summaries of

Eelk v. Southern Pacific Co. (mem.)

Supreme Court of California
Apr 29, 1955
44 Cal.2d 882 (Cal. 1955)
Case details for

Eelk v. Southern Pacific Co. (mem.)

Case Details

Full title:CHARLES EELK, Appellant, v. SOUTHERN PACIFIC COMPANY (a Corporation)…

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Apr 29, 1955

Citations

44 Cal.2d 882 (Cal. 1955)
282 P.2d 880

Citing Cases

Southern Pacific Co. v. Gileo

We granted certiorari, 350 U.S. 818, because the cases involve interpretation of an important federal statute…