From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Duba v. Mellette County

Supreme Court of South Dakota
Dec 26, 1939
289 N.W. 417 (S.D. 1939)

Opinion

File No. 8268.

Opinion filed December 26, 1939.

Appeal and Error.

Reviewing court lacked jurisdiction to consider merits of order vacating default judgment, since "order" was not "appealable" because not included in the orders enumerated in the statute as appealable. Rev. Code 1919, § 3168.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Mellette County; Hon. J.R. Cash, Judge.

Action to collect county warrants by Frank B. Duba against Mellette County, S.D., a public corporation. From an order directing that a default judgment be vacated and that defendant be given permission to answer, plaintiff appeals.

Affirmed.

L.E. Waggoner, of Sioux Falls, for Appellant.

Tom Donohue, of White River, for Respondent.


This action was commenced on November 2, 1937, and judgment by default was entered therein on March 7, 1938. Defendant made application for an order to show cause why the judgment entered should not be vacated and set aside. The order was granted and made returnable on December 1, 1938, at which time the trial court ordered that the judgment be vacated and set aside and that defendant be given permission to answer. On February 10, 1939, plaintiff perfected an appeal to this court from this order.

The order was not appealable. Section 3168, Rev. Code 1919, enumerated the orders which were appealable and the order here involved did not come within those enumerated. Paper Supply Co. v. Mac Donald, 44 S.D. 100, 182 N.W. 526; Moore v. Hahn, 65 S.D. 284, 273 N.W. 377.

This court is therefore without jurisdiction to consider the merits of the order and the appeal must therefore be dismissed. It is so ordered.

WARREN, P.J., and ROBERTS, RUDOLPH, and SMITH, JJ., concur.

POLLEY, J., not sitting.


Summaries of

Duba v. Mellette County

Supreme Court of South Dakota
Dec 26, 1939
289 N.W. 417 (S.D. 1939)
Case details for

Duba v. Mellette County

Case Details

Full title:DUBA, Appellant, v. MELLETTE COUNTY, Respondent

Court:Supreme Court of South Dakota

Date published: Dec 26, 1939

Citations

289 N.W. 417 (S.D. 1939)
289 N.W. 417

Citing Cases

In re Swanson's Estate

The appeal is from the order of July 21, 1939. An appeal has not been allowed by this court pursuant to the…

Adamson v. Petersen

The plaintiff sought to appeal from a non-appealable order which vacated a judgment and permitted the…