Opinion
2002
DOCKET DISPOSITION TITLE NUMBER DATE AND JUDGES PARISH State v. Arceneaux 2002 KA 0836 3/28/2002 Convictions Terrebonne and Sentences Affirmed; Remanded with Instructions; Protective Order Issued CARTER, C.J. CLAIBORNE, J., dissents with reasons State v. Webb 2001 KA 1457 3/28/2002 Sentence Livingston Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing CARTER, C.J. State v. Courville 2001 KA 1720 3/28/2002 Conviction St. Tammany Callais v. Alvin Davis Pharmacy, Inc. 2001 CA 0172 3/28/2002 Affirmed LaFourche PARRO, J. Roque v. Stalder 2001 CA 0329 3/28/2002 Reversed and East Baton Remanded Rouge PARRO, J. State v. Johnson 2001 CA 0416 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton PARRO, J. Rouge State v. Francois 2001 KA 1687 3/28/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed PARRO, J. State v. Amos 2001 KA 2024 3/28/2002 Convictions St. Tammany Reversed; Sentences Vacated; Remanded for Further Proceedings PARRO, J. CARTER, J., dissents with reasons 5/09/2002 Reh. den. Shackelford v. 2000 CA 2939 3/28/2002 Affirmed Livingston Harris IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro. Tem. 5/09/2002 Reh. den. Brunson v. Trustees 2001 CA 0015 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton of LASERS IAN W. Rouge CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Lake at White Oak 2001 CA 0422 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton Homeowners' Ass'n IAN W. Rouge CLAIRBORNE, J. Pro Tem. State v. Buford 2001 KA 1573 3/28/2002 Conviction Terrebonne Reversed; Sentence Vacated; Case Remanded for New Trial IAN W. CLAIRBORNE, J. Pro Tem. State v. Edgar 2001 KA 1858 3/28/2002 Convictions Terrebonne and Sentences Affirmed Ian W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Donham v. Flores 2001 CA 0658 3/28/2002 Reversed and St. Mary Remanded FOIL, J. Allison v. Theriot 2001 CA 0753 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton FOIL, J. Rouge Jones v. Town of 2001 CA 0811 3/28/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa Amite FOIL, J. State v. Pennell 2001 KA 2023 3/28/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed FOIL, J. State v. Bateman 2001 KA 2073 3/28/2002 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed FOIL, J. Davis v. St. 2001 CA 0383 3/28/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany Tammany Parish PETTIGREW, J. School Bd Brown v. Brown 2001 CA 0551 3/28/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany PETTIGREW, J. State v. Bone 2001 KA 1886 3/28/2002 Conviction LaFourche and Sentence Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. Hebert v. Malbrough; 2001 CA 0211, 3/28/2002 Affirmed Terrebonne Hebert v. Cunningham WILLIAM F. KLINE, J. Pro Tem. Bowden v. Bowden 2001 CA 0253 3/28/2002 Appeals St. Tammany Dismissed Without Prejudice; Writ Granted; Judgment Modified; Case Remanded WILLIAM F. KLINE Pro Tem. Frisard v. Ulmer 2001 CA 0639 3/28/2002 Appeal St. Tammany Dismissed; Writ Denied WILLIAM F. KLINE Pro Tem. State v. Chopp 2001 KA 1571 3/28/2002 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed WILLIAM F. KLINE Pro Tem. Story v. Calloway 2001 CA 0256 3/28/2002 Reversed and East Baton Fitness Corp Remanded Rouge WHIPPLE, J. Hollingsworth v. 2001 CA 0271 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton Dillard Dept. WHIPPLE, J. Rouge Stores, Inc GUIDRY, J., concurs in the result State v. McLaughlin 2001 KA 1789 3/28/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed WHIPPLE, J. State v. Smith 2001 KA 1956 3/28/2002 Conviction, East Baton Habitual Rouge Offender Adjudication, and Sentence Affirmed; Defense Counsel's Motion to Withdraw Granted WHIPPLE, J. Carmena v. Initial 2001 CA 0130 3/28/2002 Affirmed Iberville Transport, Inc. FOGG, J. 5/02/2002 Reh. den. Bailey v. Pansano 2001 CA 0300 3/28/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa FOGG, J. Silos Lodge Farm, 2001 CA 0528 3/28/2002 Affirmed West Feliciana L.L.C. v. Bayou Sara FOGG, J. Game Preserve, Inc Silos Lodge Farm 2001 CA 0686 3/28/2002 Affirmed West Feliciana L.L.C. v. Woodside FOGG, J. State v. Marcotte 2001 KA 1575 3/28/2002 Conviction St. Mary and Sentence Affirmed FOGG, J. GUIDRY, J., dissents in part and concurs in part and assigns reasons State v. Johnson 2001 KA 2289 3/28/2002 Conviction LaFourche and Sentence Affirmed FOGG, J. Maurice v. Maurice 2001 CA 0118 3/28/2002 Appeal St. Tammany Dismissed; Answer to Appeal Denied; Exceptions of Res Judicata Pretermitted, as Moot GUIDRY, J. FOGG, J., concurs and assigns reasons WHIPPLE, J., concurs in the result Jackson v. Creed 2001 CA 0251 3/28/2002 Vacated and East Baton Remanded Rouge GUIDRY, J. State v. C.W. 2001 CA 0276 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton GUIDRY, J. Rouge 5/02/2002 Reh. den. State v. Hayes 2001 KA 1686 3/28/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed GUIDRY, J. State v. Hebert 2001 KA 2283 3/28/2002 Conviction Washington and Sentence Affirmed GUIDRY, J. Kernan v. Melson 2001 CA 2487 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton GUIDRY, J. Rouge Shafer v. Shafer 2001 CA 0217 3/28/2002 Affirmed in East Baton Part; Rouge Reversed in Part; Remanded in Part FITZSIMMONS, J. Creel v. Board of 2001 CA 0351 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton Sup'rs of Louisiana FITZSIMMONS, J. Rouge State University DOWNING, J., concurs Ballenger v. Stalder 2001 CA 0401 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton Rouge Delta Mechanical, 2001 CA 0415 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton Inc. v. Millers FITZSIMMONS, J. Rouge Mut. Fire Ins. Co. of Texas LeBouef v. Texaco, 2001 CA 0419 3/28/2002 Affirmed Terrebonne Inc. FITZSIMMONS, J. DOWNING, J., dissents and assigns reasons State v. Spicer 2001 KA 2067 3/28/2002 Conviction St. Tammany Reversed; Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Vacated; Remanded for a New Trial FITZSIMMONS, J. DOWNING, J., concurs and assigns reasons State v. Earl 2001 KA 2127 3/28/2002 Convictions Washington and Sentences Affirmed FITZSIMMONS, J. Bickham v. Bickham 2001 CU 2773 3/28/2002 Affirmed in East Feliciana Part, and Remanded FITZSIMMONS, J. DOWNING, J., concurs and assigns reasons Theriot v. Rouse's 2001 CA 0147 3/28/2002 Affirmed Terrebonne Supermarket, Inc. DOWNING, J. State v. Nelson 2001 KA 0726 3/28/2002 Reversed; East Baton Motion to Rouge Suppress Granted; Convictions and Sentences Vacated; Remanded for Further Proceedings DOWNING, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., concurs in result St. Pierre v. 2000 CA 2225 3/28/2002 Affirmed LaFourche Brown's Velvet WALTER I. Dairy Products, LANIER, JR., Inc. J. Pro Tem. Trahan v. Kaufman 2001 CA 0180 3/28/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany WALTER I. LANIER, JR., J, Pro Tem. Ross v. City of 2001 CA 0218 3/28/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa Hammond WALTER I. LANIER, JR., J, Pro Tem. 5/09/2002 Reh. den. Bickham v. Finn 2001 CA 0316 3/28/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany WALTER I. LANIER, JR., J. Pro Tem Vaughn Contractors, 2001 CA 0500 3/28/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany Inc. v. City of GONZALES, J. Slidell Tate v. Security 2001 CA 0513 3/28/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa Fire Ins. Co. GONZALES, J. Hulon v. Allstate 2001 CA 0523 3/28/2002 Amended; In East Baton Ins. All Other Rouge Respects, the Judgment is Affirmed GONZALES, J. Melancon v. Guillot 2001 CA 0421 3/28/2002 Affirmed Ascension GONZALES, J. State v. Davis 2001 KA 1455 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton GONZALES, J. Rouge Brown v. Mire 2001 CA 0197 3/28/2002 Reversed and LaFourche Remanded KUHN, J. Fells v. LSU Health 2001 CA 0350 3/28/2002 Affirmed Civil Serv. Sciences Center, Inc KUHN, J. Com'n Dornier v. Slater 2001 CA 0501 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton KUHN, J. Rouge GONZALES, J., respectfully dissents and may assign reasons Stewart v. Delgado 2001 CA 0466 3/28/2002 Affirmed Civil Serv. Community College KUHN, J. Com'n Valencia v. Slater 2001 CA 0501 3/28/2002 Vacated in St. Tammany Part and Interim Child Support Order Rendered; Amended in Part and, as Amended, Affirmed; Remanded KUHN, J. Hampton v. 2001 CA 0515 3/28/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany Kattengell KUHN, J. 5/03/2002 Reh. den. State v. McGuire 2001 KA 1572 3/28/2002 Conviction Terrebonne and Sentence Affirmed KUHN, J. Union Antioch 2001 CW 2103 3/28/2002 Writ of East Baton Baptist Church, Certiorari Inc. v. Wells Recalled; Writ Denied; Remanded for Further Proceedings KUHN, J. Pitre v. American 2001 CA 0178 Affirmed East Baton Mfrs. Mut. Ins Co. PHILIP C. Rouge CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Dupuy v. Hackbarth 2001 CA 0527 3/28/2002 Affirmed East Baton Delivery Service, PHILIP C. Rouge Inc. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Linares v. Gulf 2001 CA 0563 3/28/2002 Affirmed Terrebonne Pride Marine PHILIP C. Service, Inc. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. 5/03/2002 Reh. den. State v. Adams 2001 KA 1408 3/28/2002 Affirmed LaFourche PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Chauvin 2001 KA 2000 3/28/2002 Convictions Terrebonne Reversed, Sentences Vacated, and Remanded for New Trial PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. KUHN, J. dissents with reasons State v. Murray 1999 KA 1045 3/28/2002 Convictions St. Tammany and Sentences Affirmed GUIDRY, J. Rahman v. Stalder 2001 CA 0529 3/28/2002 Reversed and East Baton Rendered Rouge LANIER, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., concurs and assigns reasons 5/09/2002 Reh. den.