Opinion
2003
DOCKET DISPOSITION TITLE NUMBER DATE AND JUDGES PARISH
Giarrusso v. Giarrusso 2002 CA 0389 06/11/2003 On Rehearing: St. Tammany Prior Opinion Dismissing Appeal Vacated; Judgment Affirmed in Part; Reversed in Part; and Rendered Jarreau v. Bergeron 2002 CA 0517 06/20/2003 Judgment Pointe Coupee Dismissing Jarreau's Claims Affirmed; Judgment on the Rule to Tax Costs Amended and, as Amended, Affirmed PARRO, J. Urso v. Lee 2002 CA 1782 06/27/2003 Affirmed Ascension CARTER, J. Stoetzner v. Stalder 2002 CA 2233 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, J. Rouge Mera v. State 2002 CA 2351 06/27/2003 Affirmed Lafourche CARTER, J. State v. Corkern 2003 KA 0001 06/27/2003 Conviction Washington and Sentence Affirmed CARTER, J. State ex rel. I.W. 2003 KJ 0547 06/27/2003 Adjudication Isberville Affirmed; Disposition Vacated; Remanded for Re-Imposition of the Disposition CARTER, J. Williams v. LA State Bd. of Nursing 2002 CA 1774 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton WHIPPLE, J. Rouge Nickens v. Miletello 2002 CA 2416 06/27/2003 Affirmed Tangipahoa WHIPPLE, J. McKissick v. LA Dept. of Labor Bd. of Review 2002 CA 2483 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton WHIPPLE, J. Rouge State v. Parker 2002 KA 2631 06/27/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed WHIPPLE, J. Thibodeaux v. Cleco Corp. 2002 CA 1264 06/27/2003 Reversed, in St. Tammany Part, and Rendered, Affirmed, in Part PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Wyre v. LA Bd. of Parole 2002 CA 1825 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton PHILIP C. Rouge CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. CARTER, J., concurs in the result State v. Thomas 2002 KA 2039 06/27/2003 Conviction East Baton and Sentence Rouge Affirmed PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Myles 2002 KA 2593 06/27/2003 Conviction East Baton and Sentence Rouge Affirmed PHI[LIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Robinson 2003 KA 0034 06/27/2003 Conviction Ascension Affirmed; Sentence Affirmed in Part and Vacated in Part; Case Remanded PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Richard v. State 2002 CA 0558 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton PARRO, J. Rouge CLAIBORNE, J., dissents Alfonso v. Lauderdale 2002 CA 0726 06/27/2003 Amended and Tangipahoa as Amended, Affirmed PARRO, J. Stevens v. Falkenheiner 2002 CA 1395 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton PARRO, J. Rouge Watts v. Sullivan 2002 CA 1627 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton PARRO, J. Rouge Whitlow v. Audubon Indem. Co. 2002 CA 1737 06/27/2003 Affirmed Livingston PARRO, J. CLAIBORNE, J., dissents and assigns written reasons State v. Edwards 2002 KA 1764 06/27/2003 Conviction on East Baton Count I Rouge Affirmed; Sentence on Count I Amended, and as Amended, Affirmed; Conviction and Sentence on Count II Vacated PARRO, J. State v. Froman 2002 KA 2632 06/27/2003 Sentence East Baton Vacated; Rouge Remanded with Instructions PARRO, J. McDONALD, J., dissents Morris v. Dept. of Health Hospitals 2002 CA 1828 06/27/2003 Affirmed Civil Serv. IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Robinson v. North American Salt Co. 2002 CA 1869 06/27/2003 Amended, as St. Mary Amended, Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. McDONALD, J., dissents and assigns reasons Williams v. Dept. of Public Safety Corrections 2002 CA 2401 06/27/2003 Affirmed Civil Serv. IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. State v. Gubert 2002 KA 2594 06/27/2003 Conviction Washington and Sentence Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. PARRO, J., concurs State v. Maize 2003 KA 0128 06/27/2003 Conviction Terrebonne and Sentence Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Bertrand v. Hollensworth 2002 CA 2311 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton FITZSIMMONS, Rouge J. GUIDRY, J., concurs State v. Wyatt 2002 KA 2368 06/27/2003 Conviction St. Tammany Reversed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for a New Trial FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Bell 2002 KA 2591 06/27/2003 Sentence East Baton Affirmed Rouge FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Williams 2003 KA 0019 06/27/2003 Conviction, Washington Habitual Offender Adjudication, and Sentence Affirmed FITZSIMMONS, J. Lee v. Kern 2002 CA 2077 06/27/2003 Amended and Lafourche as Amended, Affirmed GUIDRY, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., dissents in part and assigns reasons Ryan v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.; Hernandez v. Ventle 2002 CA 2303, 06/27/2003 Reversed and Pointe Coupee 2002 CA 2304 Rendered GUIDRY, J. PETTIGREW, J., concurs FITZSIMMONS, J., concurs Williams v. Dennis 2002 CA 2366 06/27/2003 Affirmed Iberville GUIDRY, J. State v. Johnson 2002 KA 2429 06/27/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed GUIDRY, J. Banks v. Dept. of Health Hospitals 2002 CA 2655 06/27/2003 Affirmed Civil Serv. GUIDRY, J. Adams v. Rhodes 2002 CA 1957 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton PETTIGREW, J. Rouge Magee v. Southern Wood, Inc. 2002 CA 2076 06/27/2003 Affirmed Tangipahoa PETTIGREW, J. State v. Banks 2002 KA 2596 06/27/2003 Conviction East Baton and Sentence Rouge Reversed. Defendant Ordered Discharged PETTIGREW, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., agrees and assigns additional reasons George v. Dept. of Health Hospitals 2002 CA 2640 06/27/2003 Affirmed Washington PETTIGREW, J. Events, Inc. v. Estate of Stamps 2002 CA 1944 06/27/2003 Reversed and St. Tammany Remanded FOIL, J. Randazzo v. T-N-T Lawn Pool Maintenance, Inc.; Turnage v. T-N-T Lawn Pool Maintenance, Inc. 2002 CA 2056, 06/27/2003 Affirmed City of Denham 2002 CA 2057 FOIL, J. Springs Arnold v. Bass 2002 CA 2109 06/27/2003 Reversed in East Baton Part; Amended Rouge in Part, and as Amended, Affirmed FOIL, J. Mill Creek Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. Manuel 2002 CA 2239 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Feliciana FOIL, J. Alleman v. Metropolitan Property Cas. Ins. Co. 2002 CA 2287, 06/27/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne 2002 CA 2288 FOIL, J. Ridge v. Collier 2003 CU 0487 06/27/2003 Affirmed in Iberville Part, Reversed in Part and Remanded FOIL, J. Gaudet v. Gaudet 2002 CA 1793 06/27/2003 Affirmed Lafourche McCLENDON, J. Lowery v. Lenessa 2002 CA 2006 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton McCLENDON, J. Rouge Fontenot v. Noble 2002 CA 2121 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton McCLENDON, J. Rouge In re B.C. 2003 CJ 0504 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton McCLENDON, J. Rouge Orso v. Orso 1995 CA 0033 06/27/2003 Reversed and East Baton Remanded Rouge KLINE, J. Holland v. WSV, Inc. 2002 CA 1817 06/27/2003 Affirmed in Wkrs. Comp. Part; Reversed in Part, Remanded KLINE, J. Richard v. City of Baton Rouge 2002 CA 1900 06/27/2003 Reversed and East Baton Remanded Rouge KLINE, J. Rico v. James Indus. Contractors, L.L.C 2002 CA 2108 06/27/2003 Affirmed Ascension KLINE, J. Stafford v. Walgreens LA 2002 CA 2230 06/27/2003 Reversed Livingston KLINE, J. Lancaster v. State Nat. Ins. Co., Inc. 2002 CA 2369 06/27/2003 Amended; East Baton Affirmed as Rouge Amended KLINE, J. McCLENDON, J., concurs Daigle v. State 2002 CA 0184 06/27/2003 Reversed in East Baton Part. Rouge Affirmed in Part GUIDRY, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., dissents in part for the reasons assigned in his dissent in the original opinion Copous v. Mid-Contiment Cas. Co. 2002 CA 1320 06/27/2003 Affirmed in St. Tammany Part; Reversed in Part; Remanded McCLENDON, J. Bonifay v. City Nat. Bank of Baton Rouge 2002 CA 1511 06/27/2003 Affirmed East Baton KLINE, J. Rouge State v. Stogner 2002 KA 1884 06/27/2003 Convictions St. Tammany and Sentences Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. Dinger v. Manuel 2002 CA 1790 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton KUHN, J. Rouge Lehmann v. St. Tammany Parish Police Jury 2002 CA 2019 07/02/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany KUHN, J. Rogers v. Dokes 2002 CA 2129 07/02/2003 Reversed and Tangipahoa Remanded KUHN, J. Gallaty v. Deroche 2002 CA 2312 07/02/2003 Affirmed in Lafourche Part, Reversed in Part, and Remanded KUHN, J. DOWNING, J., concurs Sims v. Coregis Ins. Co. 2002 CA 2484 07/02/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany KUHN, J. Mikesell v. Mikesell 2002 CA 2037 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge Griffin v. Perkins Cable Vision, Inc. 2002 CA 2413 07/02/2003 Affirmed St. Helena DOWNING, J. Matthews v. Stalder 2002 CA 2580 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge Bass v. Stalder 2002 CA 1792 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton GAIDRY, J. Rouge Messmer v. Piccadilly Cafeteria, Inc. 2002 CA 1986 07/02/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany GAIDRY, J. State v. Glasper 2002 KA 2078 07/02/2003 Conviction West Baton and Original Rouge Sentence Affirmed; Multiple Offender Adjudication and Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Further Proceedings GAIDRY, J. Chiu v. Dillard Dept. Stores, Inc. 2002 CA 2123 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton GAIDRY, J. Rouge Byers v. Indus. Specialty Contractors, Inc. 2002 CA 2423 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton GAIDRY, J. Rouge State v. Hollins 2002 KA 2650 07/02/2003 Conviction East Feliciana and Sentence Affirmed GAIDRY, J. Rogers v. Spagna 2002 CA 2000 07/02/2003 Amended in East Baton Part; As Rouge Amended, Affirmed McDONALD, J. Bean v. Kerek; Richard Price Contracting Co. v. Guy's Towing Service Inc. 2002 CA 2116, 07/02/2003 Amended and, Ascension 2002 CA 2117 As Amended, Affirmed McDONALD, J. PARRO, J., concurs CLAIBORNE, J., concurs with reasons Poole v. Madisonville Boatyard, Ltd. 2002 CA 2367 07/02/2003 Reversed and St. Tammany Remanded McDONALD, J. PARRO, J., concurs State v. Charles 2002 KA 2520 07/02/2003 Conviction Terrebonne and Sentence Affirmed McDONALD, J. Viccinelli v. City of Baton Rouge 2000 CA 2936 07/02/2003 Vacated and East Baton Remanded Rouge KUHN, J. Mrs. G. v. Mr. G. 2002 CA 0559, 07/02/2003 Reversed in East Baton 2002 CA 0560 Part, Amended Rouge in Part and, as Amended, Affirmed. Motion to Supplement Appeal Record Denied KUHN, J. WHIPPLE, J., dissents DOWNING, J., dissents and assigns reasons GAIDRY, J., assigns additional reasons McDONALD, J., concurs with reasons Benton v. Benton 2002 CA 0694 07/02/2003 Reversed and Livingston Remanded GAIDRY, J. State v. Daughenbaugh 2002 KA 2234 07/02/2003 Vacate Guilty Terrebonne Plea and Sentence; Reverse Ruling Denying Motion to Quash; Remand for Further Proceedings DOWNING, J. GUIDRY, J., concurs in the result Marshall v Capital Transp. Corp. 2002 CA 1018 07/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, J. Rouge CAICCIO, J., concurs in part dissents in part State v. Henry 2002 KA 2263 07/02/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed CARTER, J. Bratton v. Bratton 2002 CA 2124 07/02/2003 February 19, St. Tammany 2002 Judgment of Partition Amended, and Affirmed as amended; February 19, 2002 Judgment on Rule Affirmed; June 6, 2002 Order Vacated WHIPPLE, J. CARTER, J., concurs