From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Cruz v. the State

Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas
Jan 13, 1915
172 S.W. 790 (Tex. Crim. App. 1915)

Summary

In Cruz v. State, 172 S.W. 790, to which we are referred by appellant, the affidavit was similar to the one found in the present record.

Summary of this case from Wilson v. State

Opinion

No. 3384.

Decided January 13, 1915.

Aggravated Assault — Statement of Fact — Reversible Error.

Where it appeared from the record on appeal that appellant had been deprived of a statement of facts without negligence on his part and under such circumstances which entitles him to a reversal of the judgment, the same is reversed and the cause remanded.

Appeal from the County Court of Frio. Tried below before the Hon. Crawford Laxson.

Appeal from a conviction of aggravated assault; penalty, a fine of $100 and one hundred and twenty days confinement in the county jail.

The opinion states the case.

S.T. Dowe, for appellant.

C.E. Lane, Assistant Attorney General, for the State.


Appellant was convicted of aggravated assault and prosecutes this appeal.

No statement of facts accompanies this record and under such circumstances we can not review the grounds alleged in the motion for a new trial. However, the affidavit of appellant's counsel accompanies the record and he swears that "he presented to the county judge a statement of facts, duly made out for his approval and that the county judge refused to approve same, stating he did not care to sign it, and that the county judge has failed to make out and file a statement of facts in this cause; that it is in no way the fault of defendant or his counsel that a statement of facts does not accompany the record, but such fact is wholly due to the failure and refusal of the county judge to act in the premises." Under this showing it appears that appellant has been deprived of a statement of facts without negligence on his part, and under such circumstances he is entitled to a reversal of his case.

The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.

Reversed and remanded.


Summaries of

Cruz v. the State

Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas
Jan 13, 1915
172 S.W. 790 (Tex. Crim. App. 1915)

In Cruz v. State, 172 S.W. 790, to which we are referred by appellant, the affidavit was similar to the one found in the present record.

Summary of this case from Wilson v. State
Case details for

Cruz v. the State

Case Details

Full title:PANCHO CRUZ v. THE STATE

Court:Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas

Date published: Jan 13, 1915

Citations

172 S.W. 790 (Tex. Crim. App. 1915)
172 S.W. 790

Citing Cases

Wilson v. State

By no showing made to this court does it appear that the statement of facts submitted to the trial judge by…

Gholston v. State

Hence he is entitled to a reversal of the judgment. Cruz v. State, 172 S.W. 790. The judgment is reversed and…