From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Clark v. Clark

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jan 25, 1916
154 P. 1142 (Okla. 1916)

Opinion

No. 6070

Opinion Filed January 25, 1916.

1. DIVORCE — Grounds — "Extreme Cruelty." Where one spouse frequently cursed and abused the other, such conduct constituted "extreme cruelty" and warranted the granting of a divorce.

2. SAME. Whipping one's wife constitutes one of the highest degrees of "extreme cruelty.

(Syllabus by Mathews, C.)

Error from Superior Court, Custer County; J.W. Lawter, Judge.

Action by Fern A. Clark against Monroe F. Clark. Judgment for plaintiff, and defendant brings error. Affirmed.

G.W. Cornell, for plaintiff in error.

Darnell Darnell, for defendant in error.


The parties will be designated as in the trial court. This was an action for divorce upon the alleged grounds of extreme cruelty and gross neglect of duty. The trial court found for the plaintiff, granting a decree of divorce as prayed for, and defendant prosecutes this appeal, assigning as the only error the insufficiency of the evidence to support the verdict.

It could serve no useful purpose to review the evidence here, but we believe the same fully sustains the finding of the trial court. Plaintiff testified that defendant frequently cursed her, and struck her upon three different occasions, and that he neglected her while she was sick. While it is no uncommon occurrence to find women who do endure such outrageous treatment rather than desert their husbands, yet we will not judicially say that it is their duty to do so. If cursing and whipping one's wife do not constitute "extreme cruelty," it is difficult to imagine a condition that would comply with the term.

We recommend that the judgment be affirmed.

By the Court: It is so ordered.


Summaries of

Clark v. Clark

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jan 25, 1916
154 P. 1142 (Okla. 1916)
Case details for

Clark v. Clark

Case Details

Full title:CLARK v. CLARK

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jan 25, 1916

Citations

154 P. 1142 (Okla. 1916)
154 P. 1142

Citing Cases

Robertson v. Robertson

"Where one spouse frequently cursed and abused the other, such conduct constituted 'extreme cruelty,' and…

Manhart v. Manhart

Conduct which will entitle a party to a divorce on the rounds of "extreme cruelty" may be either of a…