From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Byars v. Superior Court of Los Angeles County

Supreme Court of California
May 10, 1962
57 Cal.2d 869 (Cal. 1962)

Opinion

Docket No. L.A. 26694.

May 10, 1962.

PROCEEDING in prohibition to restrain the Superior Court of Los Angeles County from proceeding to trial on an information. Writ granted.

Frank C. Wood, Jr., for Petitioner.

Stanley Mosk, Attorney General, William E. James, Assistant Attorney General, William B. McKesson, District Attorney (Los Angeles), Harry Wood and Harry B. Sondheim, Deputy District Attorneys, for Respondent and Real Party in Interest.


MEMORANDUM CASE


Petitioner seeks prohibition to restrain respondent superior court from proceeding to trial on an information charging him with violation of section 288a of the Penal Code.

Petitioner and his codefendant were arrested in toilet booths located in a Long Beach amusement park after their activities had been observed by a police officer stationed on the roof of the restroom and looking through a pipe installed in the ceiling of the booths below. The sole issue here presented is whether the testimony of the arresting officers, upon which petitioner was held to answer, was inadmissible because obtained by an illegal search and seizure.

The issue of law is identical with that presented in the case entitled Bielicki v. Superior Court, L.A. 26693, ante, p. 602 [ 21 Cal.Rptr. 552, 371 P.2d 288], also decided this day and the reasoning set forth in our opinion in that case is equally applicable here.

Let the peremptory writ of prohibition issue as prayed.

Gibson, C.J., Traynor, J., McComb, J., Peters, J., White, J., and Dooling, J., concurred.

The petition of the respondent and the real party in interest for a rehearing was denied June 4, 1962.


Summaries of

Byars v. Superior Court of Los Angeles County

Supreme Court of California
May 10, 1962
57 Cal.2d 869 (Cal. 1962)
Case details for

Byars v. Superior Court of Los Angeles County

Case Details

Full title:RUSSELL FRANKLIN BYARS, Petitioner, v. THE SUPERIOR COURT OF LOS ANGELES…

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: May 10, 1962

Citations

57 Cal.2d 869 (Cal. 1962)
21 Cal. Rptr. 556
371 P.2d 292

Citing Cases

State v. Bryant

The Bielicki case held that testimony of officers who secretly observed occupants of toilet stalls through a…

State ex Rel. v. Mayer

Other states have held prohibition to be an appropriate remedy in circumstances very similar to the cases at…