From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Baumann v. Wright

Oregon Supreme Court
Feb 21, 1968
437 P.2d 488 (Or. 1968)

Opinion

Argued February 9, Affirmed February 21, 1968

Appeal from Circuit Court, Lane County.

EDWARD LEAVY, Judge.

AFFIRMED.

Erven L. Kincaid, Eugene, argued the cause for appellant. With him on the brief was Frank B. Reid, Eugene.

No appearance for respondent.

Before GOODWIN, Presiding Justice, and DENECKE and HOLMAN, Justices.


This is an appeal from an order allowing an objection to a final account with the result that certain attorneys fees were reduced.

The attorneys for the estate during probate had obtained an ex-parte order authorizing the payment of $3,439.78 to the attorneys as "fees in the above entitled estate." The customary fee for the work done in connection with the probate of the estate would have been approximately $542.28. The assets of the estate were insufficient to pay the debts of the decedent.

A judgment creditor of the decedent objected to the final account insofar as it authorized the payment of attorney fees in excess of $542.28. The trial court, after a comprehensive hearing into the matter, allowed the $542.28 as the usual fee in such cases together with an additional $1,200 for services performed after the decedent's death in connection with litigation which had been pending at the time of the decedent's death. The remainder of the $3,439.78 was disallowed on the ground that fees earned during the lifetime of the decedent properly should have been segregated and filed as a claim against the estate. As a claim against the estate, such fees would be subject to the applicable statutory priorities that are invoked when the assets of an estate are insufficient to pay all the debts of the decedent. See ORS 117.110. This appeal proceeds on the theory that the ground assigned by the trial court for its ruling had not been urged by the objector. A trial court ruling that is manifestly correct will be affirmed whether or not the point was urged by the prevailing party. ORS 19.125 (2).

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Baumann v. Wright

Oregon Supreme Court
Feb 21, 1968
437 P.2d 488 (Or. 1968)
Case details for

Baumann v. Wright

Case Details

Full title:IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF GEORGE BAUMANN, DECEASED BAUMANN…

Court:Oregon Supreme Court

Date published: Feb 21, 1968

Citations

437 P.2d 488 (Or. 1968)
437 P.2d 488

Citing Cases

Pilgrim v. Clatskanie People's Utility Dist

Because the record on summary judgment shows conclusively that the members of defendant's elected Board of…