From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Barton v. Gammell

Supreme Court of Georgia
Apr 20, 1977
235 S.E.2d 18 (Ga. 1977)

Opinion

32151.

SUBMITTED APRIL 12, 1977.

DECIDED APRIL 20, 1977.

Title to land. Newton Superior Court. Before Judge Ridgway.

Strickland Costley, Charles D. Strickland, for appellants.

Campbell Bouchillon, W. K. Campbell, George C. Gammell, James W. Lewis, Joyce A. Lewis, for appellees.


Appellants appeal a declaratory judgment of the superior court which held that agreements executed ancillary to warranty deeds conveyed to the defendants easements in the plaintiffs' property.

We find merit in appellees' contention that this court lacks jurisdiction because the case is not one "respecting title to land" within the meaning of Art. VI, Sec. II, Par. IV (Code Ann. § 2-3704).

Cases respecting title to land within the meaning of Art. VI, Sec. II, Par. IV of the Constitution of Georgia are actions at law, such as ejectment where plaintiff asserts a presently enforceable legal title for purposes of recovering possession from the defendant; they are not declaratory actions seeking judgment regarding use restrictions on land. Reid v. Standard Oil Co. of Kentucky, 218 Ga. 289 ( 127 S.E.2d 678) (1962).

In Graham v. Tallent, 235 Ga. 47 ( 218 S.E.2d 799) (1975), this court held that suits which must be brought in the county of the residence of the defendant are not "cases respecting title to land." "[A] suit by plaintiff seeking a rule nisi to require defendants to show cause why a non-judicial foreclosure proceeding should not be allowed to proceed (being in essence a suit for declaratory judgment that the foreclosure provisions of a security deed are enforceable) is a personal suit against the defendants which could only be maintained in their county of residence." Id. p. 50.

Transferred to the Court of Appeals. Undercofler, P. J., Jordan, Ingram, Hall and Hill, JJ., concur.


SUBMITTED APRIL 12, 1977 — DECIDED APRIL 20, 1977.


Summaries of

Barton v. Gammell

Supreme Court of Georgia
Apr 20, 1977
235 S.E.2d 18 (Ga. 1977)
Case details for

Barton v. Gammell

Case Details

Full title:BARTON et al. v. GAMMELL et al

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Apr 20, 1977

Citations

235 S.E.2d 18 (Ga. 1977)
235 S.E.2d 18

Citing Cases

Daniel v. Ga. Power Co.

Kinnon v. Mercer, 222 Ga. 309 ( 149 S.E.2d 685). See generally Barton v. Gammell, 238 Ga. 643 ( 235 S.E.2d…

Barton v. Gammell

The two agreements are identical for all practical purposes, and we select the pertinent provisions of the…