From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Asher v. State

Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc
Jun 26, 1925
90 Fla. 75 (Fla. 1925)

Opinion

Opinion Filed June 26, 1925.

A Writ of Error to the Circuit Court for Dade County; Mitchell D. Price, Judge.

Reversed.

G. A. Worley Son and Bart A. Riley, for Plaintiff in Error;

Rivers Buford, Attorney General, and Marvin C. McIntosh, Assistant, for the State.


The plaintiff in error was convicted of murder in the first degree and sentenced to capital punishment. Writ of error was taken. The evidence as to the guilt of the accused is entirely circumstantial.

Where circumstantial evidence is relied upon by the State for conviction in a criminal prosecution, the circumstances taken together must be of a conclusive nature and tendency leading on the whole to a satisfactory conclusion and producing in effect a moral certainty that the accused and no one else committed the offense, before a verdict of guilty is justified. It is not sufficient that the facts create only a strong probability of guilt. Pate v. State, 72 Fla. 97, 72 South. Rep. 517.

In a conviction for capital punishment where the evidence as to the identity of the accused is not satisfactory, a new trial should be granted. Platt v. State, 65 Fla. 253, 61 South. Rep. 502; Davis v. State, 76 Fla. 179, 79 South. Rep. 450.

Reversed for new trial.

WEST, C. J., AND WHITFIELD, TERRELL AND STRUM, J. J., concur.


Summaries of

Asher v. State

Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc
Jun 26, 1925
90 Fla. 75 (Fla. 1925)
Case details for

Asher v. State

Case Details

Full title:W. R. ASHER, Plaintiff in Error, v. THE STATE OF FLORIDA, Defendant in…

Court:Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc

Date published: Jun 26, 1925

Citations

90 Fla. 75 (Fla. 1925)
105 So. 140

Citing Cases

Williams v. State

Where circumstantial evidence is relied upon for conviction in a criminal case, the circumstances when taken…

Townsend v. the State of Florida

Richardson v. State, 80 Fla. 634, 86 So.2d Rep. 619; Smithie v. State, 84 Fla. 498, 94 So.2d Rep. 156. In a…